Across Northland's classrooms, two long-running pressures — a chronic teacher shortage and the seasonal tide of winter illness — have converged into a crisis that leaves school leaders with no good choices. Principals must weigh the harm of closing classes against the harm of asking unwell staff to keep teaching, while Ministry guidance on mild symptoms sits uneasily against the lived reality of crowded, coughing rooms. What is unfolding is less a sudden emergency than the slow accumulation of strain on a system that has been running without adequate reserves for years.
Winter illness compounds Northland school staffing crisis, forcing class closures
Students sent home from school, teachers working while ill, disrupted learning for multiple classes across Northland schools.
Either that or you have to close because it's not safe
Mark
Why does a teacher shortage make winter illness so much worse? Couldn't schools just adjust their schedules?
Mimi
Because there's no one to call. When a teacher is sick and there's no relief teacher available, the school has two options: close the class or ask the sick teacher to come in anyway. There's no third choice.
Mark
So teachers are choosing to work sick?
Mimi
Not really choosing. They're being forced into it. If they stay home, their class has nowhere to go. They're not trying to be heroes—they're trying to keep the school functioning.
Mark
But that spreads the illness faster, doesn't it?
Mimi
Exactly. A sick teacher infects thirty kids. Those kids go home and infect their families. A week later, the teacher gets sick again from a variant. It's a cycle that feeds itself.
Mark
The Ministry says mild symptoms are fine for school. Why are principals so angry about that?
Mimi
Because "mild" in a crowded classroom becomes severe. One child sniffling becomes thirty children sniffling. The guidance doesn't account for the reality of density and contagion in a school building.
Mark
Is this a money problem?
Mimi
It's multiple problems at once. Schools don't have enough teachers. Parents can't afford to keep kids home. The Ministry's guidance doesn't match what schools can actually manage. You'd need to fix all three to break the cycle.
The Pulse
- Northland schools are being forced to close entire classes when relief teachers cannot be found, leaving families scrambling mid-week with no warning.
- Teachers are returning to work while still sick rather than leave their schools without cover — a choice that accelerates the very spread of illness they are trying to contain.
- Principals are openly challenging Ministry guidance that permits children with mild symptoms to attend, arguing that thirty sniffling children in one room is a transmission event, not a manageable inconvenience.
- The illness is cycling back through staff who recover, return too soon, and are knocked down again — stretching what began as a winter wave into a grinding, multi-week ordeal.
- Cost-of-living pressure means some parents cannot afford to keep sick children home, feeding the cycle from the community side even as schools try to slow it from within.
- The Ministry maintains that schools make the final call on closures, but that framing offers little comfort to principals already operating beyond their limits.
Across Northland's classrooms, two long-running pressures — a chronic teacher shortage and the seasonal tide of winter illness — have converged into a crisis that leaves school leaders with no good choices. Principals must weigh the harm of closing classes against the harm of asking unwell staff to keep teaching, while Ministry guidance on mild symptoms sits uneasily against the lived reality of crowded, coughing rooms. What is unfolding is less a sudden emergency than the slow accumulation of strain on a system that has been running without adequate reserves for years.
Northland schools are caught between two crises that have arrived at the same time. A teacher shortage that has been building for years is now colliding with a heavy winter illness season, and the result is forcing principals into choices with no good outcome: close classes and send students home, or ask sick staff to keep working.
Brendon Morrissey of the Tai Tokerau Principals' Association describes the pressure plainly. When a teacher calls in sick and no reliever is available, the school either asks that teacher to come back unwell or shuts the class. Many teachers choose to push through rather than leave their colleagues and students without cover — and in doing so, they spread illness further.
At Hora Hora School, principal Pat Newman has watched the cycle repeat itself. Teachers recover, return, and are struck down again within days. He has had to send whole classes home and is openly critical of Ministry guidance suggesting children with mild symptoms can safely attend. Thirty coughing, sniffling children in one room, he argues, will reliably infect their teacher — and from there, the illness fans out through the whole school community.
The Ministry has offered free flu vaccinations to staff and maintains that unwell children should stay home until they can participate in learning. But principals say the official messaging conflicts with what they are experiencing. Lucy Naylor of the Auckland Primary Principals' Association adds another layer: parents under financial pressure may feel they simply cannot afford to keep a sick child home, which keeps the cycle turning from the community side.
Schools retain the final authority to close classes, and many are exercising it. That decision, however necessary, is itself a sign of a system stretched too thin to absorb the ordinary pressures of a New Zealand winter.
Northland schools are caught in a squeeze that has no easy exit. Winter illness is sweeping through classrooms, but there aren't enough teachers to cover the absences, so principals face an impossible choice: close the doors or ask staff to work through their own sickness. Some schools have already chosen the first option, sending entire classes home when they can't find relief teachers to step in.
Brendon Morrissey, who leads the Tai Tokerau Principals' Association, frames the problem plainly. The teacher shortage itself isn't new—it's been grinding on for years—but right now it's colliding with the seasonal wave of colds and flu in a way that's forcing schools to their limits. When a teacher calls in sick and there's no one to replace them, the calculus becomes brutal. Either the teacher comes back to work unwell, or the class doesn't meet. "When there's nobody else there, it's either that or you have to close because it's not safe and you haven't got enough staff," Morrissey said. Teachers, he noted, often choose to push through their illness rather than leave their school without coverage.
At Hora Hora School, principal Pat Newman has watched the pattern repeat itself across his staff. The illness isn't a clean, three-day affair anymore. Teachers recover, return to work, then get knocked down again a week or two later. The cycle perpetuates itself, and Newman has had to send entire classes home because he couldn't find relievers to cover. "Staff are being hit really hard," he said. The toll is visible in how the sickness spreads: one teacher gets sick, comes back too soon, infects a classroom full of children, those children go home and infect their families, and the wave rolls through the community.
Newman is also frustrated with the Ministry of Education's guidance that children with mild symptoms—what officials call "snivels"—can safely attend school. He sees it differently. Put thirty kids in a classroom, all coughing and sniffling, and the teacher will catch it. Then everyone else in the building catches it. "I'd like to see them sitting in a classroom with a class full of kids snivelling and coughing," Newman said, his frustration evident. He wonders too whether people are simply more vulnerable to serious illness because they're already worn down—whether the baseline health of the community has shifted.
The Ministry has offered free flu vaccinations to staff, but the broader tension remains unresolved. Lucy Naylor, from the Auckland Primary Principals' Association, acknowledges that parents facing cost-of-living pressures may feel they have no choice but to send sick children to school. They can't afford to lose a day's wages. But she also points to the confusion: the Ministry's messaging about when children should stay home conflicts with what schools are actually experiencing on the ground.
The Ministry's position, delivered through Helen Hurst, the group general manager for operational standards and support, is that while attendance matters, unwell children should remain home until they're well enough to participate in learning. Health New Zealand has published guidance on the Ministry's website outlining when symptoms are mild enough for school. But schools themselves make the final call on whether to stay open, and right now, many are deciding they can't. The decision to close a class or send students home isn't a failure of the system—it's a school protecting itself and its community from a cycle it can't break while running on empty.
Notable Quotes
When there's nobody else there, it's either that or you have to close because it's not safe and you haven't got enough staff.— Brendon Morrissey, Tai Tokerau Principals' Association president
I'd like to see them sitting in a classroom with a class full of kids snivelling and coughing.— Pat Newman, Hora Hora School principal, on Ministry guidance about mild symptoms
Want the full story?
Read the original at NZ Herald ↗
Education