On a Friday morning in Istanbul, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul carried a warning that stretches far beyond the port cities and sea lanes where it originates: when ships are attacked on the world's trade routes, the consequences travel slowly through fuel, fertilizer and bread until they reach those with the least room to absorb them. Gathered with ministers from Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt, France and the United Kingdom, he framed the crisis as one in which the poorest, who depend most on wheat and imported fertilizer, may pay the heaviest price. Yet he also reminded the ro
Wadephul Warns Shipping Disruptions Could Trigger Famine as Istanbul Summit Convenes
Wadephul warned that people across the region suffering hunger and insecurity face worsening conditions if shipping disruptions continue.
We will not accept Iran and the Houthis holding global trade hostage.
Mark
Why is a foreign minister talking about famine at a meeting about shipping?
Mimi
Because Wadephul linked the two directly. Fertilizer and wheat move by sea, and he named Hormuz, the Red Sea and the Black Sea as the routes under attack.
Mark
He also said it can't be solved militarily. What's the alternative he offered?
Mimi
Talks. Germany, France and the UK say they're willing to negotiate with Iran, and he urged Russia to agree to a Black Sea shipping deal.
Luke
Willingness to talk isn't a deal, though. Nothing in the reporting says Iran has accepted or even responded.
Mimi
Fair. It's an offer, stated in Istanbul on Friday.
Mark
What's new about the format?
Mimi
R4+E3 had never met before. Four regional powers formed the R4 earlier this year over the war on Iran, and the E3 dates to early nuclear talks.
Luke
And the famine warning is Wadephul's own projection. The reporting gives no figures on shortages or hunger so far.
Mimi
Right, he spoke of a threat, not a measured crisis.
Mark
So what counts as success here?
Luke
Concrete coordinated steps. So far we have a meeting and an agenda, not an outcome.
The Pulse
- Attacks on shipping through Hormuz, the Red Sea and the Black Sea are already pressing up on fuel prices in Europe and threatening grain and fertilizer flows to poorer regions.
- Wadephul warns that if fertilizer fails to arrive, famine could follow in places where basic food production depends on it.
- The first-ever R4+E3 meeting in Istanbul brings together two groups of ministers with competing histories, seeking a shared response to overlapping wars.
- Germany, France and the UK signal readiness to negotiate with Iran, while Wadephul insists the Red Sea conflicts cannot be solved by force.
- Wadephul calls on Russia to agree to a Black Sea shipping deal, and the outcome now hinges on whether the talks produce concrete steps rather than statements.
On a Friday morning in Istanbul, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul carried a warning that stretches far beyond the port cities and sea lanes where it originates: when ships are attacked on the world's trade routes, the consequences travel slowly through fuel, fertilizer and bread until they reach those with the least room to absorb them. Gathered with ministers from Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt, France and the United Kingdom, he framed the crisis as one in which the poorest, who depend most on wheat and imported fertilizer, may pay the heaviest price. Yet he also reminded the room that the sea cannot be pacified by guns alone, and that the path forward runs through negotiation, even with adversaries.
On Friday morning, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul arrived in Istanbul with a warning that reaches well beyond the fuel pump and the supermarket checkout. Europeans are already feeling the effects of attacks on shipping in rising prices, he said, but in the poorest parts of the world the threat is hunger. If fertilizer and grain cannot move through the Strait of Hormuz, the Red Sea and the Black Sea, the basic food production that millions depend on could fail.
He spoke before the first meeting of the R4+E3 format, which brings together ministers from Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt, France, the United Kingdom and Germany. The European trio has worked on Iran together since the early 2000s, and the regional four formed this year to respond to the war on Iran. The agenda ranges from Palestine and Hormuz to Yemen and Ukraine.
Wadephul's message was firm: the group will not accept Iran and the Houthis holding global trade hostage, and the indiscriminate attacks on shipping and neighboring countries must stop. Yet he ruled out military force as the answer, saying the conflicts cannot be solved that way. Germany is ready to negotiate with Iran alongside France and the UK, and he called on Russia to agree to a deal securing Black Sea shipping.
The question now is whether this gathering produces more than statements, whether it yields coordinated steps on shipping security, a channel to Iran, or arrangements for the Black Sea. Wadephul's case is that every day of waiting is paid for in grain and fertilizer that never arrive.
On Friday morning, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul arrived in Istanbul with a warning about what is happening to the world's shipping lanes, and what it could mean for people far from the gas station or the supermarket checkout. Speaking before a meeting with fellow foreign ministers, he said Europeans are already feeling the effects of attacks on shipping, in prices at the pump and in the shops. In poorer parts of the world, he said, the threat is famine, if fertilizer does not reach the places where basic food production depends on it.
Wadephul was pointing at several pressure points at once: the Iranian closure of the Strait of Hormuz, Houthi threats to the Bab al-Mandab strait, and Russian attacks on shipping in the Black Sea as part of Moscow's war against Ukraine, one of the world's leading wheat producers. He said the people hit hardest are the world's poorest, whose basic food relies heavily on wheat, as well as partners such as Turkey, which he described as the biggest wheat-processing country in the world.
The meeting itself is a first. It brings together ministers from Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt, France, the United Kingdom and Germany in a format labeled R4+E3. The E3 (Germany, France and the UK) took shape in the early 2000s during nuclear negotiations with Iran. The R4, made up of Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Egypt, was formed earlier this year to coordinate a regional response to the US-Israeli war on Iran. A spokesperson for the Turkish foreign ministry said the agenda covers the Palestine question, the situation in the Strait of Hormuz, developments in Yemen and the search for an end to the war in Ukraine.
Wadephul's message was firm in tone. He said the group wants to send a signal that it will not accept Iran and the Houthi militias in Yemen holding global trade hostage. The indiscriminate attacks on free shipping and on neighboring countries, he said, must stop, and he described the continuing insecurity as unacceptable for people across the region who are hungry and no longer feel safe in their own homes.
But he also ruled out force as the answer. The conflicts threatening free shipping, including Houthi fire on vessels in the Red Sea, cannot be solved militarily, he said. Germany is ready to negotiate with Iran together with France and the UK, the three European signatories of the 2015 JCPOA nuclear deal, which Donald Trump tore up during his first term. Wadephul also called on Russia to agree to a deal securing shipping in the Black Sea.
Elsewhere in Germany on Friday, the Bavarian CSU opened a two-day conference in Munich, with Chancellor Friedrich Merz due to speak Saturday. In Berlin, Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari began a state visit marking 75 years of diplomatic relations. And federal prosecutors said a Ukrainian man arrested in Brandenburg is accused of spying on German and NATO military sites for Russian intelligence.
What to watch now is whether this first R4+E3 gathering produces anything beyond statements: coordinated steps on shipping security, a channel to Iran, or arrangements for the Black Sea. The case Wadephul made is that the cost of waiting is measured in grain and fertilizer that fail to arrive.
Notable Quotes
We're all feeling the effects of the attacks on shipping lanes, but elsewhere there is a threat of famine when fertilizers don't arrive where they are essential.— Johann Wadephul, German Foreign Minister
Want the full story?
Read the original at Deutsche Welle ↗
Politics & Governance