In the quiet machinery of a government trying to rein in its own spending, a cabinet minister was asked whether he wanted the sniping at the treasurer to stop, and he said yes, adding that everyone could see such comments were being made. The moment reveals a familiar tension in public life: the need to cut costs in a fragile economy, set against the strain of a party losing ground in the polls. As the mid-year budget update approaches in December, the choices about which popular programs to trim will test how much unity the government can hold.
Watt Urges Labor Colleagues to Stop Undermining Chalmers as Budget Savings Push Divides Cabinet
"All sorts of people making all sorts of comments."
Why does a minister saying "stop undermining the treasurer" matter this much?
Because it's an admission. Watt conceded that people inside Labor are making comments against Chalmers. That's rarely said out loud by a cabinet member.
Worth being careful, though. He said there are "all sorts of comments." He didn't name anyone or say what was leaked. The tension with Albanese is described as speculation.
And the money side? What's actually on the table?
The home battery program, announced April 2025, was meant to cost about $2 billion and is now $7 billion, with over 600,000 systems installed. Means testing could be added. EV subsidies have also cost far more than expected.
Could, though. Nothing has been decided. These are options being discussed ahead of the December update.
Why would they cut popular programs?
The Reserve Bank raised rates last week, and Bullock pointed to excess demand from public and private spending. That puts pressure on the budget.
Bullock also said budgets are for governments to manage independently. She didn't tell them what to cut.
And the polls?
Resolve has Labor at 28%, Redbridge at 26%, with One Nation ahead of the Coalition in one and level-ish in the other.
Two polls, different pollsters, and the Coalition moved in opposite directions between them. The $10 billion figure is Watt's claim about blocked measures, and it's his political argument.
Der Puls
- Cabinet ministers are sifting through savings options in a closed-door review, with the mid-year budget update looming in December.
- A cabinet colleague openly acknowledged that the treasurer is being undermined from within Labor, exposing cracks at the top.
- Polling has turned sharply against Labor, with its primary vote falling to 28% and 26% in separate surveys.
- Popular clean energy schemes, including the home battery subsidy now at $7 billion and overrun EV incentives, are on the chopping block.
- Roughly $10 billion in savings measures sit stalled in parliament, and the outcome of that standoff will shape what lands in December.
In the quiet machinery of a government trying to rein in its own spending, a cabinet minister was asked whether he wanted the sniping at the treasurer to stop, and he said yes, adding that everyone could see such comments were being made. The moment reveals a familiar tension in public life: the need to cut costs in a fragile economy, set against the strain of a party losing ground in the polls. As the mid-year budget update approaches in December, the choices about which popular programs to trim will test how much unity the government can hold.
On Monday, after cabinet's expenditure review committee met again, environment minister Murray Watt was asked whether he wanted an end to the leaking and undermining aimed at Treasurer Jim Chalmers. He said yes. The committee's task is to decide which savings will go into the mid-year budget update due in mid-December, with the goal of easing spending pressure on an economy that the Reserve Bank had just responded to with another rate rise.
Watt defended Chalmers as doing an excellent job and reminded colleagues of their duty to support one another in hard times. But he also admitted it was plain that "all sorts of people" were making "all sorts of comments," a rare public acknowledgement of internal friction.
The political mood is grim. Recent polls put Labor's primary vote at 28% in one survey and 26% in another, well below its election result. Watt turned his fire on the opposition, accusing the Coalition of blocking $10 billion in savings measures in parliament, including changes to the private health insurance rebate for people over 65.
The hard choices are coming. Public service departments have been asked to find savings of up to 5%, and the popular home battery subsidy, which has ballooned from an expected $2 billion to $7 billion and reached more than 600,000 installations, may face means testing. Electric vehicle incentives, also far over budget, could be reined in too. Both are well liked, which makes cutting them politically painful.
The next test is the December update, where the government must show its hand and reveal whether the stalled $10 billion has moved.
On Monday, after cabinet ministers sat down again to go through possible budget savings, the environment minister, Murray Watt, was asked a direct question: did he want to see an end to the "undermining and leaking" aimed at the treasurer, Jim Chalmers? "Yes, I would," he said.
The meeting was of the expenditure review committee of cabinet, and its job is to settle which savings go into the mid-year budget update, expected in the middle of December. The aim is to reduce government spending and ease pressure on the economy. It came days after the Reserve Bank raised interest rates. The governor, Michele Bullock, said that while governments manage their budgets independently of the central bank, public and private spending had created "excess demand" in the economy.
Watt was asked about speculation of tension between Chalmers and the prime minister, Anthony Albanese. He framed his answer around the duty of government members to support one another and government policy in what he called very difficult times. He said Chalmers was doing an excellent job, and that many of the forces bearing on the economy sit well outside any treasurer's control. Then he made an admission: it was "pretty obvious," he said, that "all sorts of people" were making "all sorts of comments." In effect, a cabinet colleague confirmed that the treasurer is being undermined from within Labor.
The political backdrop is poor for the government. A Resolve Political Monitor poll in the Age and the Sydney Morning Herald put Labor's primary vote at 28%, down from 34.6% at last year's election. The Coalition fell one point to 22%, and One Nation held steady at 25%. A Redbridge poll in the Financial Review was grimmer for Labor: its primary vote slipped two points to 26%. The Coalition rose four points to 25%, while One Nation dropped one point to 28%.
Watt also turned toward the opposition. He accused the Coalition and minor parties of letting existing spending proposals sit in parliament, among them savings from changes to the private health insurance rebate for people over 65. "For all of their demands that we find more savings," he said, the Coalition is currently blocking $10 billion in measures before the parliament.
Albanese has confirmed that public service spending will be scrutinised in the update. Last year, departments and agencies were asked to identify potential savings of as much as 5% from their annual budgets, part of an effort to cut lower-priority spending.
The clean energy programs are also in play. Labor's home battery subsidy, announced in April 2025, was originally designed to cost about $2 billion but is now a $7 billion program. More than 600,000 systems have been installed, and the program could have means testing added. Separately, subsidies meant to encourage electric vehicle purchases have cost the budget far more than first expected, and these too could be reined in. Both are popular measures, which makes the choice politically awkward.
On the opposition side, Angus Taylor announced a "red tape razor gang" on Monday, intended to reduce the burden of costly regulation on business.
The next marker is the December update, where the government will have to show which savings it has chosen, and whether the $10 billion stalled in parliament has moved by then.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
I think that Jim Chalmers is doing an excellent job as a treasurer in what are very difficult economic times.— Murray Watt, environment minister
It's pretty obvious that there are all sorts of people making all sorts of comments.— Murray Watt, environment minister