On a Monday in late September, President Trump stood beside Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington and declared the two sides close to a Gaza peace deal, after Israel's leader publicly embraced a 20-point American plan to end a war now nearing its second year. It is a moment that carries the weight of many earlier promises, because the party whose consent matters most, Hamas, has not yet answered. The plan offers a ceasefire, a hostage-for-prisoner exchange, staged Israeli withdrawal, and an eventual though vaguely defined path toward Palestinian statehood, yet the hardest questions of disarmament a
Trump Wins Netanyahu's Backing for 20-Point Gaza Plan; Hamas Response Remains the Open Question
A yes from Netanyahu, and still no answer from the one party that must give it
Netanyahu said yes. Why isn't that the end of the story?
Because Hamas is the other half, and it hasn't answered. Its official said nothing official had arrived, though Qatar and Egypt later passed it the document and Hamas said it would review it in good faith.
"In good faith" is a phrase from an official briefed on the talks, not a Hamas statement on the record. It tells us they'll respond, not what they'll say.
And Netanyahu's yes, is it complete?
He said the plan achieves Israel's war aims, but he kept distance from Palestinian Authority reforms and eventual statehood, which he rejects.
Right, and the source says it wasn't clear all differences between Washington and Israel were resolved. We don't know what was settled in the room.
What's the pressure on him at home?
Hostage families and a war-weary public on one side, far-right ministers who could break his coalition on the other.
The polling is characterized only generally here, no figures. And the coalition risk is a possibility, not something that's happened.
Does Trump's record matter?
He has said a deal was near before, and Baumgartner himself urged caution while citing the Abraham Accords as precedent.
Both are opinions. The firm facts are the plan's terms, Netanyahu's statement, and the hostage count, which is Israel's figure.
O Pulso
- Netanyahu has endorsed the 20-point plan, yet he quietly distances himself from its clauses on Palestinian statehood and reforms of the Palestinian Authority.
- Hamas has not formally received the document, and its refusal to disarm stands as the central obstacle to any ceasefire taking hold.
- Trump has warned that if Hamas rejects the offer, Israel will have full American backing for whatever action it deems necessary.
- Far-right ministers threaten Netanyahu's coalition if he concedes too much, while hostage families and a war-weary public press him for a resolution.
- Qatar and Egypt carry the document to Hamas, and the next move rests with mediators pressing a group that has repeatedly said no.
On a Monday in late September, President Trump stood beside Benjamin Netanyahu in Washington and declared the two sides close to a Gaza peace deal, after Israel's leader publicly embraced a 20-point American plan to end a war now nearing its second year. It is a moment that carries the weight of many earlier promises, because the party whose consent matters most, Hamas, has not yet answered. The plan offers a ceasefire, a hostage-for-prisoner exchange, staged Israeli withdrawal, and an eventual though vaguely defined path toward Palestinian statehood, yet the hardest questions of disarmament and political authority remain unsettled, as they have throughout this long and grievous conflict.
On Monday, standing beside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at a White House news conference, President Trump said the two sides were "beyond very close" to a Gaza peace deal. Netanyahu had just publicly backed a U.S.-sponsored plan to end a war nearly two years old, but Hamas, the party whose agreement matters most, had not yet responded.
The 20-point document calls for an immediate ceasefire, an exchange of hostages for Palestinian prisoners, a staged Israeli withdrawal, Hamas disarmament, and a transitional government led by an international body. It was shaped by envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, and it envisions a "board of peace" chaired by Trump, with former British Prime Minister Tony Blair among its members. Gaza would be governed without Hamas, and the path to Palestinian statehood is sketched only vaguely.
Netanyahu said the plan "achieves our war aims," but he distanced himself from the reforms demanded of the Palestinian Authority and from the prospect of statehood, which a source close to the talks described as a main sticking point. Hamas has stayed outside the negotiations. Qatar and Egypt passed the document along, and Hamas said it would review it in good faith, though it has repeatedly refused to disarm.
Behind the diplomacy lies a human toll that frames everything: around 1,200 people killed and 251 taken hostage in the October 2023 attacks, and more than 66,000 Palestinians killed since, in a territory largely in ruins. Netanyahu faces pressure from hostage families and a weary public, and he risks his coalition if far-right allies believe he has conceded too much. Whether Hamas accepts the framework, and whether Netanyahu can sell it to his security cabinet, are the next tests.
On Monday, standing beside Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at a joint White House news conference, President Donald Trump said the two sides were "beyond very close" to a peace deal for Gaza. Netanyahu had just given his public backing to a U.S.-sponsored plan to end a war that is nearly two years old. The party whose agreement matters most, Hamas, had not yet answered.
The White House released a 20-point document. It calls for an immediate ceasefire, an exchange of hostages held by Hamas for Palestinian prisoners held by Israel, a staged Israeli withdrawal, the disarmament of Hamas, and a transitional government led by an international body. Trump also warned Hamas that if it rejects the offer, Israel would have full U.S. support to take whatever action it considers necessary.
The plan was crafted by special envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, Trump's Middle East adviser in his first term. It envisions a ceasefire followed by the release, within 72 hours, of all remaining hostages in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, with Israeli forces withdrawing gradually. The U.S. would work with Arab partners and others to build a temporary stabilization force. Gaza would be run without Hamas, with only a limited initial role for a Palestinian Authority "representative." A technocratic Palestinian committee would handle day-to-day services, overseen by an international "board of peace" chaired by Trump and including former British Prime Minister Tony Blair. The plan sketches a vague path toward Palestinian statehood once Gaza's redevelopment is well advanced and the Authority has made reforms, but gives no details.
Netanyahu said he supports the plan because it "achieves our war aims": returning all hostages, dismantling Hamas's military capabilities, ending its political rule, and ensuring Gaza never again threatens Israel. Yet he distanced himself from parts of it, including the reforms demanded of the Palestinian Authority and the prospect of eventual statehood, which he has forcefully rejected. A source close to the talks said statehood was among the main sticking points. It was not immediately clear whether Washington and Israel had settled all their differences. The Palestinian Authority welcomed Trump's efforts, according to the news agency WAFA, and said it would work toward a comprehensive deal.
Hamas stayed outside the negotiations and has repeatedly refused to disarm, which clouds the plan's prospects. A Hamas official told Reuters the group had received nothing officially beyond media publication. An official briefed on the talks later said Qatar and Egypt had passed the document to Hamas, which told mediators it would review it "in good faith" and then respond. Israel says Hamas still holds 48 hostages, 20 of them alive.
The visit was Netanyahu's fourth to the White House since Trump returned to office in January. It came days after several Western leaders formally recognized Palestinian statehood at the United Nations, over U.S. and Israeli objections. Trump has called that recognition a prize for Hamas. Washington presented its plan to Arab and Muslim states on the sidelines of the General Assembly last week. Trump took no questions at what had been billed as a news conference.
Trump has promised a quick end to the war since his 2024 campaign and has repeatedly said a deal was near, only for none to materialize. In August he went into a summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin seeking a Ukraine ceasefire, left without one, and still rated the meeting "a 10."
Netanyahu faces pressure from hostages' families and, according to polls, a war-weary public. He also risks his governing coalition if far-right ministers think he has conceded too much. Israel launched one of its largest offensives of the war this month, with Netanyahu saying he aims to destroy Hamas in its last strongholds.
The human toll frames everything. Israeli tallies say Hamas-led fighters killed around 1,200 people and seized 251 hostages on Oct. 7, 2023. Gaza health authorities say more than 66,000 Palestinians have been killed since, and much of the territory is in ruins amid a major humanitarian crisis.
Rep. Michael Baumgartner, a Spokane Republican on the House Middle East and North Africa Subcommittee, welcomed the announcement but said the region is "littered with failed peace plans." He pointed to the Abraham Accords as evidence Trump can do what others thought impossible, and called the Emirates' apparent support significant. Steven Cook of the Council on Foreign Relations said Qatar must now press Hamas and Netanyahu must sell the plan to his security cabinet. Those two steps, and Hamas's reply, are what to watch next.
Citações Notáveis
I support your plan to end the war in Gaza, which achieves our war aims.— Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli prime minister
The Qataris now must put the screws to Hamas and Netanyahu needs to sell to his security cabinet.— Steven Cook, Council on Foreign Relations