Manila Warns China May Exploit US Exercise Cuts, Though Washington Reaffirms Philippine Commitments

China is very quick to exploit gaps.
Philippine Defence Secretary Gilberto Teodoro on how Beijing might read cuts to US-South Korean exercises.
Mark

Teodoro is saying China could exploit the cuts, but also that nothing changes for the Philippines. Isn't that contradictory?

Mimi

Not quite. He's separating the region from his own country. For the Indo-Pacific broadly, he sees a possible opening for China. For Manila, he says Washington has given definite assurances on the Mutual Defence Treaty.

Luke

Worth noting those assurances are his account. We have no US statement here confirming them.

Mark

And the cuts themselves? What do we actually know?

Mimi

Only that Trump decided in August to scale back exercises with South Korea. The article doesn't give the size or the timeline.

Luke

Right, so the scale is unknown. And the idea that China will exploit it is a possibility Teodoro raised, not something that has happened.

Mark

He also talked about new partners.

Mimi

Canada and New Zealand agreements are done, a visiting forces agreement with France is signed, and Britain is under negotiation. It reads like hedging without abandoning Washington.

Luke

He says cooperation with the US is not reduced. That's his claim too, and China hasn't responded to the remarks.

Mark

What about the oil and gas talks?

Mimi

Marcos spoke of progress; Teodoro called it doubtful that economic cooperation could be separated from sovereignty disputes. That's a visible difference in tone.

Luke

Though he didn't say the two men disagree on policy, only that he is skeptical.

  • A US decision to scale back exercises with South Korea has unsettled analysts who now question whether American deterrence in Asia still carries full weight.
  • Manila fears that Beijing is quick to exploit any opening, and Teodoro refuses to dismiss the risk of Chinese reassertion across the Indo-Pacific.
  • Washington has given the Philippines definite assurances that its Mutual Defence Treaty obligations are untouched, while Manila rapidly signs new pacts with Canada, New Zealand, France and Britain.
  • Talks on joint oil and gas exploration with China remain stalled, with Teodoro calling their prospects doubtful amid unresolved sovereignty disputes.
  • Submarine ambitions with Seoul are still under review, leaving the Philippines' longer-term defence modernisation uncertain.

On a September day in Seoul, the Philippine Defence Secretary faced a question that has quietly haunted Asian capitals since August: when a great power pulls back from its drills with an ally, who notices, and who moves? Gilberto Teodoro, speaking to Reuters on the sidelines of the Seoul Defence Dialogue, acknowledged that China may well seize such gaps, while insisting that Washington has assured Manila its treaty commitments remain intact. The episode sits within a longer story of smaller nations widening their security circles as rivalry in the South China Sea hardens, and it leaves open the old question of how much an alliance's promise weighs when its rehearsals are reduced.

On Monday, September 7, Philippine Defence Secretary Gilberto Teodoro sat down with Reuters in Seoul, during the Seoul Defence Dialogue, to address a question that analysts across Asia have been asking since August. President Donald Trump had ordered a scaling back of military exercises with South Korea, and many wondered whether rivals like China would read this as a sign of weakening American resolve.

Teodoro did not dismiss the possibility. China, he said, is very quick to exploit gaps, and the cuts may open some room for Beijing to reassert itself across the Indo-Pacific. Yet he was just as firm about what Manila has been told: Washington has given definite assurances that the Mutual Defence Treaty with the Philippines is unaffected, and there has been no reduction in US-Philippine military activity.

He also described a Philippines steadily widening its partnerships. Agreements have been concluded with Canada and New Zealand, a visiting forces pact has been signed with France, and one is under negotiation with Britain. Teodoro accused China of pairing military pressure with influence operations, and said Manila is pursuing stronger espionage and foreign influence laws in response.

On economics, he was guarded. He called talks on joint oil and gas exploration with China doubtful, since no economic cooperation, in his view, can be fully separated from the South China Sea disputes. Beijing had not responded to a request for comment.

In Seoul, he discussed deeper defence ties with South Korea, a major supplier of aircraft and frigates, and sought industrial cooperation and emerging technologies. On submarines, however, he cautioned that the programme remains under review and is still a way off. He closed by suggesting that shared concern over China may eventually draw regional states into a more interconnected security network.

On Monday, September 7, Philippine Defence Secretary Gilberto Teodoro sat down with Reuters in Seoul, on the sidelines of the Seoul Defence Dialogue, and addressed a question many security analysts in Asia have been asking since August: what happens when the United States dials back its military drills with an ally?

The trigger was a decision by US President Donald Trump to scale back military exercises with South Korea. That move has set off debate among analysts over how credible US deterrence in Asia remains, and whether rivals such as China might read it as a sign of weakening American resolve. Asked whether Beijing could seize on the change, Teodoro did not wave the idea away. "It is a possibility, of course. China is very quick to exploit gaps," he said. Looking at the Indo-Pacific as a whole, he added, the cuts may signal some opportunity for China to reassert itself.

He was equally direct about what Manila has been told. Washington, he said, has given the Philippines "definite assurances," and there is "no indication" that the changes in South Korea will touch commitments under the US-Philippines Mutual Defence Treaty. Teodoro said there has been no reduction in US-Philippine military activities, and that bilateral and multilateral cooperation involving Manila continues to expand.

That expansion has been a hallmark of President Ferdinand Marcos Jr's tenure, with larger joint exercises and wider access for US forces to Philippine military facilities, as tensions with China in the South China Sea have sharpened. Teodoro said Manila is also widening its circle of partners. The Philippines recently concluded agreements with Canada and New Zealand, has signed a visiting forces agreement with France, and is negotiating a similar pact with Britain.

Teodoro also accused China of leaning more heavily on influence operations alongside its military and maritime pressure. "Definitely it takes advantage of democratic space in order to co-opt people and to use a free media to expand its distortive narratives," he said. He added that the Philippines is pursuing stronger espionage and foreign influence legislation to counter such activity.

On the economic front, he was guarded. Asked about Marcos's recent remarks that progress was being made toward possible talks on joint oil and gas exploration with China, Teodoro called it "doubtful" that any economic cooperation could be insulated from the long-running sovereignty disputes in the South China Sea. China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs and its embassy in Manila did not immediately respond to a request for comment on his remarks.

Teodoro was in Seoul to discuss expanding defence ties with South Korea, one of the Philippines' largest arms suppliers. Seoul has provided FA-50 light combat aircraft, frigates and other equipment as Manila modernises its armed forces. He said the Philippines wants deeper industrial cooperation and access to emerging defence technologies from South Korea.

On submarines, he tempered expectations. "The submarine programme is still under review," he said, pointing to open questions over mission requirements and the substantial infrastructure such a capability demands. "I would say it will be still a way off."

Teodoro closed by suggesting that worry over China is pulling regional states together and could eventually produce a more interconnected Indo-Pacific security network. "I believe so because the motivating factor there is China," he said. What to watch next: whether the deterrence debate changes any policy, and what becomes of the tentative oil and gas talks with Beijing.

It is a possibility, of course. China is very quick to exploit gaps.
— Gilberto Teodoro, Philippine Defence Secretary
Manila has received definite assurances from Washington, with no indication Mutual Defence Treaty commitments are affected.
— Gilberto Teodoro (paraphrased)
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en The Star ↗
Contáctanos FAQ