In early November, Japan's minister in charge of policy on foreign nationals, Kimi Onoda, made the case that the ceiling on foreign workers under the Specified Skilled Worker program should eventually fall rather than rise. The program was designed as a stopgap for genuine labor scarcity, and her position sits uneasily against the hopes of industries that have grown dependent on that help. Her reasoning looks ahead to a time when machines and a tighter labor market do more of the work that outside hands once did. Whether that horizon arrives quickly enough to satisfy restaurants and kitchens s
Japan Minister Says Foreign Worker Cap Should Eventually Shrink, Not Grow
Far from expanding, the cap should naturally shrink as time goes on.
Mark
Why does this statement matter if no cap has actually changed?
Mimi
Because it signals direction. The minister responsible for foreign-national policy is saying the ceiling should shrink over time, while food service is already frozen out of new admissions.
Luke
Worth being precise, though: she said "eventually" and "should." No new reduction has been announced in what we have.
Mark
What triggered the food-service freeze?
Mimi
Projections in April showed the sector would hit its cap for Specified Skilled Worker No. 1, so the government stopped new admissions.
Mark
And industry reaction?
Mimi
Concern. The Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry and others asked in May for a review of the cap when there are legitimate grounds.
Luke
Note that the request was conditional. And we don't know how many workers food service is actually short, because the reporting gives no figure.
Mark
Onoda mentioned the No. 2 status. Why?
Mimi
Some workers move up to it, and it has no effective limit on stay or intake. Her point is that the pipeline continues beyond the capped tier.
Luke
Her AI and labor-market argument is her stated reasoning. The reporting doesn't show data backing it, so it stays her assessment.
Mark
What comes next?
Mimi
An expert panel is reviewing the overall approach, and other sectors may hit caps sooner than expected.
Le Pouls
- Japan has frozen new admissions in food service after projections showed the sector hitting its cap, and restaurant operators say they still cannot find enough staff.
- Minister Kimi Onoda has signaled that the foreign worker ceiling should shrink over time, a stance that cuts directly against industry pressure for more room.
- Business groups, including the Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry, are pressing the government to reconsider caps where there are legitimate grounds.
- Other sectors may run into their limits sooner than expected, while a government expert panel reviews the country's broader foreign-national policy under Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi.
In early November, Japan's minister in charge of policy on foreign nationals, Kimi Onoda, made the case that the ceiling on foreign workers under the Specified Skilled Worker program should eventually fall rather than rise. The program was designed as a stopgap for genuine labor scarcity, and her position sits uneasily against the hopes of industries that have grown dependent on that help. Her reasoning looks ahead to a time when machines and a tighter labor market do more of the work that outside hands once did. Whether that horizon arrives quickly enough to satisfy restaurants and kitchens still short of staff is the question the country now has to answer.
On Nov. 2, Kimi Onoda, Japan's minister of policy on foreign nationals, said the cap on foreign workers under the Specified Skilled Worker program should eventually go down, not up. The program was built to fill genuine labor shortages, and her remark runs against what many industries had hoped to hear.
Onoda linked her view to the rise of artificial intelligence and an improving labor market. She described the program as a last resort, meant only for cases where shortages persist even after companies have raised productivity, hired domestically and improved working conditions. As those conditions improve, she argued, fewer workers should need to come through the system.
The pressure is already visible in food service. In April, projections showed the sector would reach its ceiling for the category covering stays of up to five years, and the government halted new admissions. Operators say they still need workers. In May, the Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry and other business groups asked officials to consider reviewing the cap, and other industries may soon face similar limits.
Onoda was firm: the cap should shrink as time goes on, and this is not simply a matter of raising numbers to meet shortages. She pointed out that some workers can move on to the more highly skilled No. 2 category, which has no effective limit on stay or admissions. Against a backdrop of tighter policy under Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi, the government's expert panel will shape what comes next, and whether food service gets any relief remains open.
On Nov. 2, Kimi Onoda, Japan's minister of policy on foreign nationals, said that the country's cap on foreign workers under its Specified Skilled Worker program should eventually go down, not up. The program was built to fill labor shortages, and her remark runs against the hopes of industries that want more room.
Onoda tied her view to two developments: the advance of artificial intelligence and an improving labor market. As both continue, she said, Japan will not need to bring in as many workers through the program. She described the system as one meant for cases where there are still too few workers even after companies have tried to raise productivity, draw on domestic workers and improve working conditions.
The question is already pressing in food service. The government halted new admissions in that sector after projections in April showed it would reach its limit for Specified Skilled Worker No. 1. That category lets foreign workers stay in Japan for up to five years, and each sector has its own intake ceiling. The freeze has worried the industry, which says it still needs more workers.
Business groups have pressed the government on the point. In recommendations submitted in May, the Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry and other organizations urged officials to "consider reviewing the cap when there are legitimate grounds to do so." Food service may not be the only sector affected: other industries could hit their caps sooner than expected.
Asked about expanding intake, Onoda gave a firm answer. The program, she said, is a system for when workers remain scarce despite efforts on productivity, domestic hiring and working conditions. She also noted that some workers move on to the No. 2 status, a category for more highly skilled workers that has no effective limit on length of stay or number of admissions. Pointing to AI progress and a better labor market, she said that "far from expanding, the cap on the number of workers accepted should naturally shrink as time goes on." She added that this is not a discussion about simply increasing numbers because there is a labor shortage.
Her comments come against a broader political backdrop. Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi's administration has pledged tighter policies on foreign nationals, and a government expert panel is reviewing Japan's overall approach to accepting them. How that panel's work interacts with sector caps, and whether food service gets any relief, are the things to watch next.
Citations marquantes
Far from expanding, the cap on the number of workers accepted should naturally shrink as time goes on.— Kimi Onoda, minister of policy on foreign nationals
Consider reviewing the cap when there are legitimate grounds to do so.— Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry and other groups, May recommendations
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur 朝日新聞 ↗
Politics & Governance