Across Europe, governments spent the energy crisis cushioning households against soaring costs, and now the question turning over in Frankfurt is when that cushion should be lifted. Christine Lagarde, president of the European Central Bank, has asked that support be withdrawn promptly and together, tied to the moment retail bills actually begin to fall. The gap she points to is a quiet one: wholesale power and gas have eased over six months, yet the relief has not yet reached the kitchen-table bill. In Ireland, the clock is visible, since several support measures reach their end this month and
ECB's Lagarde Urges Governments to Roll Back Energy Price Support as Prices Fall
Households are still waiting for the relief wholesale markets have already registered.
Mark
So what exactly did Lagarde ask for?
Mimi
That governments start rolling back their energy support measures, promptly and in a coordinated way, as energy prices fall. She met Paschal Donohoe, the Eurogroup president, in Frankfurt to discuss it.
Mark
Why does the timing hinge on retail prices?
Mimi
Because wholesale gas and electricity prices have fallen over six months, but domestic bills haven't followed. She said rollback should happen when prices come down at retail level.
Luke
Worth being clear: that's her stated condition, not a finding that bills are about to drop. The report doesn't say when they might.
Mark
And what's the risk she's pointing to?
Mimi
That measures falling short of a rollback would likely drive up medium-term inflationary pressures, and require a stronger monetary policy response. In effect, higher interest rates.
Luke
"Likely" is doing work there. It's her assessment. The report gives no figures on how much inflation or how many rate rises.
Mark
How does this reach Ireland?
Mimi
Irish support measures are due to expire at the end of the month, and no decision has been made on extending them.
Luke
And nothing here says Lagarde was addressing Ireland specifically. She spoke about governments across Europe. The Irish link is the timing.
Der Puls
- Wholesale electricity and gas prices have fallen for six months, but domestic bills have stubbornly refused to follow.
- The ECB president is pressing governments to start unwinding energy support now, not at some distant later date.
- Lagarde warns that subsidies kept in place too long could feed medium-term inflation and force interest rates higher.
- Ireland's energy support measures expire at the end of the month, and ministers have yet to decide whether to extend them.
- The unresolved tension is whether retail prices will fall in time to justify letting support lapse without a jolt to households.
Across Europe, governments spent the energy crisis cushioning households against soaring costs, and now the question turning over in Frankfurt is when that cushion should be lifted. Christine Lagarde, president of the European Central Bank, has asked that support be withdrawn promptly and together, tied to the moment retail bills actually begin to fall. The gap she points to is a quiet one: wholesale power and gas have eased over six months, yet the relief has not yet reached the kitchen-table bill. In Ireland, the clock is visible, since several support measures reach their end this month and the government has not yet decided whether to let them go.
In Frankfurt, the day before this report, Christine Lagarde sat down with Paschal Donohoe, who chairs the Eurogroup of euro-area finance ministers. The question on the table was whether the emergency measures governments built to shield households from rising energy prices should now begin to come down.
Lagarde was direct. Support should be rolled back promptly, in a coordinated way, and the process should start now. She tied the timing to the retail level: the signal is when prices fall for ordinary consumers, not just in wholesale markets.
That is where the difficulty sits. Wholesale electricity and gas have dropped over the past six months, but families have not yet seen those savings on their bills. Lagarde warned that measures lingering beyond what the market justifies could push inflation up over the medium term, and that the central bank would then have to tighten policy, with higher borrowing costs landing on ordinary people.
In Ireland, the warning arrives at a pressure point. Several government support measures expire at the end of this month, and no decision has been taken on extending them. The government now has to weigh bills that have not yet eased against a central bank argument that support should fade as prices come down. Whether those two things line up before the deadline is what to watch.
In Frankfurt, on the day before this report, the European Central Bank's president, Christine Lagarde, met Paschal Donohoe, who chairs the Eurogroup of euro-area finance ministers. The subject was the emergency measures governments across Europe have put in place to cushion households from rising prices, and whether it is time to begin withdrawing them.
Lagarde made her position plain in both her opening statement and the press conference that followed. The measures, she said, should be rolled back "promptly in line with the fall in energy prices and in a concerted manner." She said the process should "start" now, rather than waiting for some later point.
In the press conference she was asked what that would mean in practice, and she explained that the trigger is when prices come down at the retail level. That qualifier matters, because the retail level is where the gap lies. Wholesale electricity and gas prices have fallen over the past six months, but that fall has not so far translated into cheaper domestic bills. Households are still waiting for the relief that wholesale markets have already registered.
Lagarde's warning was aimed at governments that might hold support in place too long. Any measures falling short of the rollback she described, she said, would likely "drive up medium-term inflationary pressures." That in turn would call for a stronger response on monetary policy, which in effect means higher interest rates. The argument, then, is that keeping subsidies in place after prices have eased could leave the central bank having to tighten further, and borrowers would feel that directly.
The message lands in Ireland at a particular moment. A range of support measures introduced by the Irish Government in response to higher energy costs are due to expire at the end of this month. No decision has yet been made on whether to extend them or let them lapse.
That leaves the Government weighing two things: household bills that have not yet fallen, and the central bank's argument that support should unwind as retail prices come down. Whether the two line up by the end of the month is the question to watch, along with what ministers announce about the measures before the deadline.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Measures should be rolled back promptly in line with the fall in energy prices and in a concerted manner.— Christine Lagarde, ECB President
Any measures falling short of this would likely drive up medium-term inflationary pressures.— Christine Lagarde, ECB President
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei RTE.ie ↗
Politics & Governance