A crowd that once cheered now chants its disappointment, and in the quiet after a heavy defeat in Guwahati, a former player has asked the coach to hear that noise without flinching. Every era of cricket carries this old bargain: teams that are expected to win will be judged harshly when they do not, and the people who love them demand both results and reasons. Zaheer Khan's counsel, offered from the outside of the current dressing room, is less a verdict than an invitation to explain oneself, since trust can survive frustration when the path behind a decision is visible.
Zaheer Khan Tells Gautam Gambhir to Grow a Thicker Skin Amid Mounting Criticism Over South Africa Test Loss
Accountability and appraisal go hand in hand with the job
Mark
Zaheer's advice sounds gentle. Why does it matter?
Mimi
Because it comes from someone who played alongside Gambhir in the 2011 World Cup. He isn't piling on; he's saying the scrutiny comes with a team expected to win everything.
Mark
And the scrutiny is real. The 408-run loss in Guwahati set off chants of "Gambhir Aye Haye".
Mimi
Enough that Sitanshu Kotak and Mohammed Siraj had to step in to calm the fans.
Luke
Worth noting what's reported there: that they intervened and the chants happened. How widespread the chanting was isn't stated.
Mark
What is the criticism actually about?
Mimi
Selection mainly. Too many all-rounders, specialists overlooked, and a rank turner in Kolkata despite the 0-3 loss on similar pitches to New Zealand.
Luke
Those are criticisms attributed to critics, not established fact about why the results went the way they did. The article doesn't prove cause.
Mark
And the record?
Mimi
Five losses in the last seven Tests, a lost ODI series in Sri Lanka, and the New Zealand whitewash.
Luke
Fair, but whether Gambhir will change his communication is simply unknown. Zaheer is advising, not reporting any plan.
Le Pouls
- Fans in Guwahati broke into 'Gambhir Aye Haye' chants after a 408-run Test defeat, and the tension was strong enough that staff had to step in to calm the stands.
- Criticism is sharpening around Test selection, with complaints about too many all-rounders in the XI and specialists being left out.
- The Kolkata rank turner has become a flashpoint, as many recall India's 0-3 whitewash on similar surfaces against New Zealand last year.
- Zaheer Khan urges the coach to grow a thicker skin and communicate his strategy openly, arguing that supporters will stay loyal if the reasoning is explained.
- The situation is still unresolved, with no sign yet of whether the head coach will change his public approach or simply keep his selections as they are.
A crowd that once cheered now chants its disappointment, and in the quiet after a heavy defeat in Guwahati, a former player has asked the coach to hear that noise without flinching. Every era of cricket carries this old bargain: teams that are expected to win will be judged harshly when they do not, and the people who love them demand both results and reasons. Zaheer Khan's counsel, offered from the outside of the current dressing room, is less a verdict than an invitation to explain oneself, since trust can survive frustration when the path behind a decision is visible.
After India lost the Guwahati Test to South Africa by 408 runs, the crowd made its anger impossible to miss. Fans chanted "Gambhir Aye Haye" at head coach Gautam Gambhir, and the atmosphere grew tense enough that batting coach Sitanshu Kotak and pacer Mohammed Siraj moved in to settle the supporters.
The discontent has not faded. Former India pacer Zaheer Khan, who once shared a dressing room with Gambhir during the 2011 World Cup, has offered him a piece of advice: develop a thick skin and hear the criticism with an open mind. Speaking on Cricbuzz, Zaheer said the scrutiny is part of the job, since India are expected to win almost every game and the passion behind the criticism comes from that expectation.
The record gives the anger its weight. Under Gambhir, India lost an ODI series to Sri Lanka, were whitewashed by New Zealand in Tests, and have now lost five of their last seven Tests. His relationship with Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma also remains a talking point.
The complaints about selection are specific. Critics say he has picked too many all-rounders in the Test XI at the cost of specialists, and many question the rank turner prepared for the Kolkata Test, given the similar pitches that cost India dearly against New Zealand.
Zaheer's second point concerned communication. Fans, he said, are frustrated because they know the team can do better, and management should answer with open dialogue rather than let emotion decide. Explain the thinking behind decisions, he argued, and supporters will stay with the team even when they are unhappy.
Whether Gambhir will take that advice is still unknown. What Zaheer asks for is not a change in selections, but a willingness to explain them, something the team management could choose to do at any time.
After India lost the Guwahati Test to South Africa by 408 runs, the crowd made its feelings about head coach Gautam Gambhir plain. Fans broke into chants of "Gambhir Aye Haye", and the mood grew tense enough that batting coach Sitanshu Kotak and pacer Mohammed Siraj stepped in to calm the supporters.
The jeering has not faded. Former India pacer Zaheer Khan, who shared a dressing room with Gambhir during the 2011 World Cup, has now offered the coach some advice: develop a thick skin and listen to the criticism with an open mind.
Speaking on Cricbuzz, Zaheer framed the scrutiny as part of the job. Emotions run high, he said, because India are expected to win nearly every game, an expectation built on years of consistent results and a team with the strength to deliver them. Accountability and appraisal, in his words, go hand in hand with that standard. The role demands balance, he said, and the criticism comes from the passion and expectation that surround a team of this ability.
The record explains the pressure. Under Gambhir, India lost the three-match ODI series against Sri Lanka last year, then were whitewashed by New Zealand in Tests. India have now lost five of their last seven Tests under him. Beyond results, his relationship with Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma remains a talking point, and fans continue to speculate about the future of the two in ODI cricket.
The criticism of selection is specific. Gambhir has drawn fire for fielding too many all-rounders in the Test XI while overlooking specialists. He is also being questioned over the rank turner prepared for the Kolkata Test against South Africa, given that India lost 0-3 on similar pitches against New Zealand only last year.
Zaheer's second piece of advice was about communication. He said the frustration fans feel comes from knowing the team can do better, and that team management should respond with open dialogue rather than letting emotion take over. If the thinking behind decisions is explained, he argued, supporters will understand, and they will stay with the team even when frustrated. As long as a clear process is being followed toward the desired outcome, he said, the key is not to get carried away.
Whether Gambhir takes up the suggestion is unknown. What Zaheer is asking for is not a change in selections but a willingness to explain them, which is something the team management could do at any point.
Citations marquantes
You've got to be thick-skinned to be able to deal with all these kinds of criticism.— Zaheer Khan, on Cricbuzz
If the team is more vocal and transparent about its thought process, fans will understand where it is coming from.— Zaheer Khan (paraphrased)
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur Hindustan Times ↗
Sports