Witnesses Describe Frantic Rescue as Gaza Sand Bank Collapse Buries Displaced Family

Five people were killed, including two children and their mother, and at least three tents were crushed; the children's father survived and the family is now homeless.
My tent and everything I own are now buried under the sand.
Abdul Karim al-Sahhar describes losing his shelter in Sunday's landslide near Deir al-Balah.
Mark

Five people died, but the detail that stays is the father stepping away from the tent.

Mimi

Yes. Sahhar said one of the children called him to come and eat, and he was a little late returning. That delay is why he's alive, and why he was shouting for people to save his children.

Luke

That's one witness's account of the father, though. We have it secondhand, and the father himself isn't quoted.

Mark

Fair. What do we know firmly about the rescue?

Mimi

A boulder sat on top of the victims and young men broke it apart. Video shows hammers, shovels and flashlights. Darbali said the collapse sounded like an explosion.

Luke

Notably, the reporting doesn't say whether anyone was pulled out alive. The headline speaks of saving three people, and the piece names three dead among the five.

Mark

Why did the bank give way?

Mimi

Wind and heavy rain triggered it. Unicef's Toby Fricker said the camp is overcrowded and people settle wherever they can, which includes beneath slopes.

Luke

Be careful with the scale numbers. The 26,000 households is a UN figure; the 70,000 flooded tents is from the Hamas-run media office, which is a party to the conflict. And Cogat's 91,000 tents is Israel's own count.

Mark

So the supply picture is contested.

Mimi

Very. Qazzaat says only limited tents are allowed and no prefabricated homes. Cogat lists tents and trucks delivered. Both can be true, since neither speaks to whether the shelters hold up.

Luke

And what's still unknown is how many tents are needed, and whether anything will change before more storms arrive.

  • A sand bank towering over a crowded camp gave way on Sunday, and within moments three tents were buried and five people were dead.
  • Neighbors and young men raced to dig with hammers and shovels, breaking a huge boulder apart by hand while flashlights swept the sand for signs of life.
  • More than 26,000 households have reported damage to their shelters and belongings, and tens of thousands of tents were flooded in the same storms.
  • Aid for shelter remains restricted, with prefabricated homes barred and metal tent poles blocked, while the ceasefire's terms on Hamas disarmament and Israeli withdrawal stay unresolved, so the families face the rainy season still in fragile tents.

On a Sunday when storms and high winds turned already fragile ground against the people living on it, a sand bank above a displaced families' camp south of Deir al-Balah gave way and buried tents beneath it. Five lives were lost, among them two young children and their mother, in a place where the ordinary need for shelter has become a daily negotiation with the weather. The collapse is one unhappy sign of a wider condition, in which most of Gaza's 2.3 million people sleep under canvas or in ruins while the political questions that would allow rebuilding remain unanswered.

On Sunday, after a stretch of high winds and heavy rain, a sand bank looming over a camp for displaced families south of Deir al-Balah gave way. It buried at least three tents and killed five people, among them an eight-year-old, a six-year-old and their mother.

Abdul Karim al-Sahhar, 30, was there. Originally from Izbat Beit Hanoun in northern Gaza, his own shelter was badly damaged. He described people under the sand and rocks, none of them moving or making a sound, and a tent that had vanished so completely no trace of it remained.

The children's father had stepped outside, which is why he survived. One of the children had called him to eat, and he was a little late returning. When the bank came down he began shouting for help, and neighbors dug with their hands and tools until young men broke a huge boulder into pieces to reach those beneath.

The landslide was part of a wider storm damage. The UN said more than 26,000 households reported harm to their shelters or belongings, and Gaza's government media office said about 70,000 tents were flooded. Most of the territory's 2.3 million people live in tents or ruins, and reconstruction has not begun after Israel's two-year military assault.

Sahhar and his family are now homeless. Their tent, mattress and everything they owned lie under the sand. Behind the disaster stands the question of materials: prefabricated homes have been barred, and metal tent poles are restricted, so aid workers have improvised poles from food pallets. A US-brokered ceasefire called for rebuilding, but negotiators have not agreed on Hamas disarmament or Israeli withdrawal, and Israel says reconstruction cannot begin before disarmament. Until that standoff eases, the families in the camps must face the rest of the rainy season in the same tents.

On Sunday, a sand bank towering over a camp for displaced families south of Deir al-Balah gave way after a stretch of high winds and heavy rain. It buried at least three tents and killed five people. Among the dead were an eight-year-old, a six-year-old and their mother.

Abdul Karim al-Sahhar, 30, was there. He is originally from Izbat Beit Hanoun in northern Gaza, and his own shelter was badly damaged in the collapse. He described seeing people under the sand and rocks, none of them moving or making a sound. The tent they had been in had vanished so completely, he said, that no trace of it remained.

The children's father was outside the tent when the bank came down, which is why he survived. Sahhar said one of the children had called him to come and eat with them, and he was a little late returning. Then the collapse happened. He began shouting for people to save his children, and neighbors came and started digging. A huge boulder lay on top of the victims, and young men had to break it into pieces to reach those underneath.

Another witness, Abu Darbali, told Reuters the collapse sounded like an explosion. Three tents, he said, were covered completely, and people were trapped beneath rubble that rescuers could not see through. Video posted to social media showed men swinging hammers at large rocks, others clearing sand with shovels, and flashlights sweeping the ground in search of anyone still alive.

The landslide was one part of a wider weekend of damage. The UN said more than 26,000 households had reported harm to their shelters or belongings after the rainstorms. The Hamas-run government media office said about 70,000 tents sheltering tens of thousands of displaced people were flooded on the first day of rain, and that dozens of cracked walls and roofs collapsed, causing injuries, some of them critical.

Most of Gaza's 2.3 million people live in tent encampments or in the ruins of bombed-out buildings, and reconstruction has not begun after Israel's two-year military assault, launched following the Hamas attacks on southern Israel in October 2023. Toby Fricker, a Unicef spokesperson, said the collapse was waiting to happen: Gaza is extremely overcrowded, and people are simply trying to find a place wherever they can. Unicef has been working to prevent similar tragedies and to improve drainage in the camps.

Sahhar said he and his family are now homeless. His tent, mattress, household utensils and everything else he owned are under the sand, and he could not retrieve anything.

The question of materials sits behind much of this. Mustafa Qazzaat, a Gaza City council member, said Israel has not allowed prefabricated homes since the truce was announced and has permitted only limited numbers of tents. Many so-called dual-use items remain restricted, including metal tent poles, so humanitarian workers have used wooden poles fashioned from pallets that carry food. Earlier this year, an assessment by shelter specialists in Gaza found that thousands of tents supplied by China, Egypt and Saudi Arabia offered only limited protection against rain and wind. Cogat, the Israeli defence ministry body overseeing aid, said more than 91,000 tents and over 8,200 trucks carrying tarpaulins, blankets and winter clothing have reached Gaza, along with fuel and engine oil for pumping facilities and other humanitarian installations.

A US-brokered ceasefire last year called for Gaza's eventual reconstruction, but little has moved. Negotiators have not agreed on terms for Hamas to disarm or for Israel to withdraw troops, who control about two-thirds of the territory and from which residents have been ordered to leave. Israel says no reconstruction can happen before Hamas is disarmed. With that standoff unresolved, the families in the camps face the rest of the rainy season in the same tents.

The collapse was waiting to happen. Gaza is extremely overcrowded, and people are just trying to find a place wherever.
— Toby Fricker, Unicef spokesperson
We saw people buried beneath the sand and rocks. None of them was moving or making a sound.
— Abdul Karim al-Sahhar, witness
Contattaci Domande frequenti