Each Dhanteras, Indian households renew an old bargain with gold, a ritual rooted in a legend of lamplight and a blinded god of death. This year, a Livemint personal finance piece asks a quieter question that the tradition seldom raises: whether the metal one buys for its worth must be the metal one can hold. For those who see gold chiefly as an investment, it argues, the paper and exchange-traded form offers a lighter path, with lower entry costs, easier exit, and fewer hidden deductions than coins and jewellery carry, even as the choice ultimately turns on what one intends to do with the gol
Why Gold ETFs May Beat Physical Gold This Dhanteras for Investors
If you can't afford piles of gold to ward off serpents, a gold ETF may serve
Mark
The pitch here is simple: if gold is just an investment, skip the jewellery. Why does that land?
Mimi
Because the costs of physical gold show up at the exit. Jewellers typically deduct at least 3% when you sell, and turning coins into jewellery can cost 10% or more.
Mark
And the ETF side?
Mimi
Fees of roughly 0.50% to 0.80% a year, Sebi-required purity of at least 99.5%, and you can start with ₹100.
Luke
Worth noting that the annual fee is a running cost. Over many years it adds up, and the piece doesn't compare it with the one-time costs of physical gold.
Mark
India is the biggest consumer of physical gold but ranks eighth in ETFs. What does that say?
Mimi
That habit and culture run strongly toward the physical metal, and the festival story shows why.
Luke
Careful, though. The ranking is from World Gold Council data, but the article doesn't say what is being ranked, whether holdings or flows, so I wouldn't read much into it.
Mark
What about the liquidity claim from Nippon India's Vikram Dhawan?
Luke
He manages gold products, so he has a stake in the view. It's a reasonable point, but it's one fund manager's assessment, not a measured figure.
Mimi
And the tax rules differ by holding period, so timing matters for returns.
Luke
Right, and the article gives the rates but doesn't work out an after-tax example. That's left unknown.
Der Puls
- Physical gold quietly bleeds value through jeweller deductions of at least 3% on resale and charges of 10% or more to convert coins into ornaments.
- Purity remains a suspicion that hangs over the market, since much jewellery lacks the certification its sellers promise.
- Gold ETFs answer with a click-to-sell exit and a Sebi-mandated purity of 99.5%, shifting the burden from the buyer's vigilance to regulated custody.
- The path is landing on intent: ETFs suit those who want price exposure, while the ₹25 crore threshold keeps physical conversion out of ordinary reach.
Each Dhanteras, Indian households renew an old bargain with gold, a ritual rooted in a legend of lamplight and a blinded god of death. This year, a Livemint personal finance piece asks a quieter question that the tradition seldom raises: whether the metal one buys for its worth must be the metal one can hold. For those who see gold chiefly as an investment, it argues, the paper and exchange-traded form offers a lighter path, with lower entry costs, easier exit, and fewer hidden deductions than coins and jewellery carry, even as the choice ultimately turns on what one intends to do with the gold.
The tale of Dhanteras begins with a prince doomed to a snakebite on the fourth day of his marriage, and a wife who saved him by filling the house with lamps and piles of gold and silver. Her glare, the legend says, blinded the god of death, and Indian women have gathered gold on this day ever since.
This year, a Livemint personal finance piece offers a more practical counsel. For those who buy gold purely as an investment, it suggests, the physical metal is rarely the most convenient route. Gold exchange traded funds can be bought for a fraction of the price and spare the buyer many headaches.
The contrast with national habit is striking. India is the world's largest consumer of physical gold yet ranks only eighth in gold ETFs. Physical gold brings real costs: jewellers deduct at least 3% when you sell back, converting coins into jewellery adds 10% or more, and purity is hard to verify even when hallmarks promise it.
Gold ETFs store the metal on the investor's behalf, priced from London benchmarks and converted into rupees. Custodians hold the gold in vaults, Sebi requires 99.5% purity, and the funds charge roughly 0.50% to 0.80% a year. Selling is simpler too: an ETF sells with a click, while selling physical gold means finding a fair buyer and absorbing a heavy impact cost.
Taxes depend on the holding period, and one real limit remains. Converting ETF units into physical gold requires at least ₹25 crore, so ordinary investors who later want the metal are advised to sell the units and buy separately. The entry point, as little as ₹100, makes this path open to many. The deciding question, the piece concludes, is whether you want to wear and keep the metal or simply hold its price.
The story Indians tell about Dhanteras begins with a 16-year-old prince, the son of King Hima. A fortune teller had cursed him: he would die of a snakebite on the fourth day of his marriage. When that day arrived, his wife lit lamps throughout the house and laid out piles of gold and silver ornaments at the entrance. The glare, as the legend goes, blinded the god of death, who had arrived disguised as a snake. Women in India have been gathering gold and silver jewellery on Dhanteras ever since.
A Livemint personal finance piece published ahead of this year's festival makes a more practical argument: for anyone who sees gold purely as an investment, buying the physical metal is not the most convenient route. Gold exchange traded funds, it says, can be bought at a fraction of the price of physical gold and spare the buyer a number of headaches.
The contrast with the country's habits is sharp. India is by far the world's largest consumer of physical gold, yet it ranks only eighth for gold ETFs, according to the latest World Gold Council data cited in the piece.
The costs of physical gold are concrete. When you sell coins or ornaments back to a jeweller, the jeweller typically deducts at least 3% as fees. If you hold coins or bars and want them turned into jewellery, the bill is another 10% or more. Then there is the question of purity. Measuring it is not straightforward, and although some jewellery is hallmarked, meaning certified as genuine, the article notes that it is common to find gold that is not.
Gold ETFs work differently. The metal is stored on the investor's behalf, and the value of the holding follows gold prices polled by the London Bullion Market Association. Those prices are converted into Indian units and currency, with transportation and other charges for moving the gold from London added in. Asset management companies that sell the ETFs appoint custodians to hold the metal in vaults. Sebi regulations require the gold they buy to be at least 99.5% pure by LBMA standards. The funds charge roughly 0.50% to 0.80% a year, a figure that covers running costs and insurance.
Selling is where the gap widens. Selling physical gold means finding a buyer who will pay a fair price; an ETF can be sold with a click. Vikram Dhawan, head of commodities and fund manager at Nippon India Mutual Fund, said the liquidity of gold ETFs is much better than in the physical market, and that someone selling physical gold would face a huge impact cost.
Taxes depend on how long you hold. Units held for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% on a portion of the gains; those held for less than 12 months are taxed at the investor's slab rate. Gold mutual funds that use gold ETFs as their underlying asset are taxed at 12.5% if held for more than 24 months.
There is one real limit. Sebi rules technically allow ETF holdings to be converted into physical gold, but only with a minimum investment of ₹25 crore. For ordinary investors who later want the metal, the article's advice is to sell the units and buy gold separately.
The entry point is low: a gold ETF lets you invest as little as ₹100 at a time. For those who cannot afford piles of gold to ward off serpents this Dhanteras, the piece suggests, a gold ETF may serve. The deciding question is intent, whether you want to wear and keep the metal or simply hold its price.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Liquidity of gold ETFs is much better than in the physical market; selling physical gold would carry a huge impact cost.— Vikram Dhawan, head of commodities and fund manager, Nippon India Mutual Fund
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei Livemint ↗
Economy & Finance