England's most-capped men's player and its record goalscorer now stands at a crossroads of memory and measure, where a single career invites comparison with the men who came before it. BBC Sport places Harry Kane third in its ranking of the national side's greatest, behind Bobby Moore and Sir Bobby Charlton, judging not only goals and caps but the imprint a player leaves on a nation's feeling for its team. The verdict is one writer's opinion, yet it reflects a deeper human habit of reckoning greatness while the one being measured is still in the arena, when the final chapter has not yet been w
Where Harry Kane Ranks Among England's All-Time Greats, From Beckham to Charlton
Kane has come closer to a major title than any England captain since Moore
Mark
Kane has the goals record and the caps record. Why is he only third?
Mimi
Because the list isn't a stats table. The writer weighs ability, memorable moments and longevity, and Moore and Charlton both have a 1966 World Cup win. Kane has finished close but not won.
Luke
Worth saying plainly: this is one writer's opinion. There's no objective formula, and the article admits the debate has so many variables it's hard to settle.
Mark
Who gets left out that surprises you?
Mimi
Geoff Hurst, who gave the most recognisable performance in England history. And Jimmy Greaves, who would have been a certainty but for an injury in 1966.
Luke
Those are the writer's judgment calls. A different weighting of tournament moments would change the list.
Mark
Bellingham at seventh, aged 23. Isn't that early?
Mimi
The writer says so himself. But seven goals at one World Cup is a record for an England player, and he has 61 caps and 14 goals.
Luke
And that is a list of what he has done so far. Keane's remark about potential is a prediction, not a fact.
Mark
What does the Kane ranking hinge on, then?
Mimi
Robinson's point: we may appreciate him more in 10, 15 or 20 years. His career isn't over, so the number three could move.
Il Polso
- Harry Kane's record haul of caps and goals has thrust him into a fierce debate over where he truly belongs among England's legends.
- The ranking places him third, a position that stirs argument because it trails Bobby Moore and Sir Bobby Charlton by a clear margin.
- The writer's criteria of impact, longevity and major-tournament moments force hard exclusions, leaving out famous names and sparking fresh disputes.
- Kane's two lost World Cup semi-finals and back-to-back Euros final defeats keep the major-title question open, and his standing may rise as his career closes.
England's most-capped men's player and its record goalscorer now stands at a crossroads of memory and measure, where a single career invites comparison with the men who came before it. BBC Sport places Harry Kane third in its ranking of the national side's greatest, behind Bobby Moore and Sir Bobby Charlton, judging not only goals and caps but the imprint a player leaves on a nation's feeling for its team. The verdict is one writer's opinion, yet it reflects a deeper human habit of reckoning greatness while the one being measured is still in the arena, when the final chapter has not yet been written.
Harry Kane is now England's most-capped men's player as well as its record goalscorer, and BBC Sport has asked where that places him among the national team's greatest. In the writer's top ten, he ranks third, behind Bobby Moore and Sir Bobby Charlton.
The list weighs more than ability. It considers memorable moments, longevity in the shirt and the mark a player leaves on the national mood. That leaves out obvious names, from Ballon d'Or winners to Geoff Hurst, whose 1966 display is among England's most famous. At the foot of the list stand the icons: Beckham's 93rd-minute free-kick against Greece, Gascoigne's summers of 1990 and 1996, and Billy Wright's 100 caps.
Kane's case rests on being the most important England player of his generation: 21 goals in 36 games at six major tournaments, a Golden Boot in 2018, and two World Cup semi-final defeats and two Euros finals lost. Teammates and former players believe he will be valued even more in years to come.
Moore, second, was trusted by Alf Ramsey as a lieutenant on the field and captained the 1966 World Cup winners at 25. Charlton, first, scored three goals on the way to that final, held England's goalscoring record for 55 years, and survived the Munich air disaster to win the 1968 European Cup.
The ranking remains one writer's view, and Kane, still playing, may yet look different once his England career is over.
Harry Kane is now England's most-capped men's player as well as its record goalscorer, and BBC Sport has used the moment to ask a harder question: where does that put him among the greatest players the national team has ever had? The answer, in the writer's ranked top ten, is third, behind Bobby Moore and Sir Bobby Charlton.
The writer is open about the rules. The list is not just a test of ability but of impact on the national psyche: memorable moments, longevity in an England shirt, and talent combined. That excludes some obvious names. Ballon d'Or winners Stanley Matthews, Kevin Keegan and Michael Owen miss out, as do technicians such as Glenn Hoddle, Chris Waddle and John Barnes. Geoff Hurst, author of the most recognisable performance in England history, is left off, and Jimmy Greaves would have been a certainty but for injury earlier in the 1966 tournament. Players from before the continental competitions, including Eddie Hapgood, Tom Finney, Nat Lofthouse and Dixie Dean, are hard to rank at all.
At the bottom end sit the icons. David Beckham is tenth: 115 caps, a 93rd-minute free-kick against Greece that sent England to the 2002 World Cup, and a recovery from the fallout of his 1998 red card against Argentina. Paul Gascoigne is ninth, with 57 caps and 10 goals, remembered for the summers of 1990 and 1996. Billy Wright, eighth, was the first men's player to reach 100 caps, including 70 successive appearances, and captained England 90 times, a joint record that Kane has recently equalled or passed. Jude Bellingham, seventh at just 23, has 61 caps and 14 goals, and scored seven at this World Cup, more than any previous England player in a single edition. England finished third there. Wayne Rooney is sixth, with 53 goals from 120 caps across 15 years.
Gordon Banks takes fifth as the goalkeeper: a 1966 World Cup winner, 73 caps between 1963 and 1972, and named Fifa's best goalkeeper five years running from 1966. His 1970 save from Pele is among the most famous ever, and Pele called him a "goalkeeper with magic". Gary Lineker is fourth. He won the Golden Boot at the 1986 World Cup, scored four more in 1990, and ended his international career after Euro 92 one goal short of Charlton's record.
Kane, third, is described as England's most important and influential player of a generation. The Bayern Munich striker, a Ballon d'Or winner, scored on his debut 79 seconds after coming on against Lithuania in March 2015. His 21 goals in 36 games at three World Cups and three European Championships include the 2018 World Cup Golden Boot. He has lost two World Cup semi-finals and back-to-back Euros finals, which the writer says brings him closer to a major title than any England captain since Moore. Bellingham called him the "greatest player that has ever played for England". Former goalkeeper Paul Robinson said England will appreciate him even more in 10, 15 or 20 years.
Moore is second. Geoff Hurst said nobody out-ran or out-jumped him, and Sir Alf Ramsey called him his lieutenant on the field, a footballer he could trust with his life. He captained England to the 1966 World Cup at 25, having become the youngest England captain three years earlier. The 1970 group game against Brazil produced the tackle on Jairzinho, Banks' save and the shirt swap with Pele, who called him the greatest defender he ever played against.
Charlton is first. His 49 England goals stood as the record for 55 years until Rooney passed it in 2015. He scored three on the way to the 1966 final, including two against Eusebio's Portugal in the semi-final, and won that year's Ballon d'Or. He earned 106 caps, and at Manchester United won three league titles, an FA Cup and the 1968 European Cup after surviving the Munich air disaster of 6 February 1958, which killed 23 people. Lineker has called him England's greatest ever player.
The ranking is one writer's opinion, and Robinson's comment points to where it may move: Kane is still playing, and his place may look different once his England career is over.
Citazioni salienti
We'll appreciate him even more in another 10, 15, 20 years when you look back and see what he has achieved.— Paul Robinson, former England goalkeeper
Kane is the greatest player that has ever played for England.— Jude Bellingham, England team-mate
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su BBC News ↗