In Dallas on a September night, Vice-President JD Vance stepped before a Republican convention crowd already chanting his name and spent an hour demonstrating that the art of political succession is less about replacing a leader than becoming his most faithful mirror. With practiced grievance, theatrical fury, and carefully calibrated rhetoric, Vance signaled his ambitions for 2028 while never once appearing to reach for the crown — a balance that has defined the careful dance of heirs throughout political history. The crowd's enthusiasm, and a poll placing him at 43% among likely Republican p
Vance positions himself as Trump heir with fiery speech to GOP base
If you love Mexico so much, get your ass over there
Mark
So Vance is clearly running for 2028. But what's actually new here? He's echoing Trump, he's energizing the base—isn't that just what any vice-president does?
Mimi
The specificity matters. He's not just supporting Trump; he's demonstrating he can replicate Trump's rhetorical style—the dog whistles, the false claims, the performative aggression toward protesters. He's showing the base he can be Trump without being Trump.
Luke
But let's be precise about what we know versus what we're inferring. We know he got enthusiastic applause. We know he made false claims about Democrats and October 7. We know a poll shows him at 43 percent. What we don't know is whether that support is durable or whether it's just convention energy.
Mark
The Iran war thing—that seems like a real vulnerability, right? He's unpopular on that issue, and he barely mentioned it.
Mimi
Exactly. He sidestepped it entirely, just invoking Charlie Kirk's supposed disdain for war without actually addressing the policy. That's a tell. He knows it's a problem.
Luke
Though we should note: the reporting says the war is "deeply unpopular," but we don't have a specific number on that. And we know Trump's advisers have raised the possibility it could drag on through his term. That's one source's reporting, not confirmed fact.
Mark
So if Vance becomes the nominee, does he have to own that position?
Mimi
That's the open question. Right now he's betting that base loyalty and Trump's favor matter more than any single policy disagreement. He's literally asking voters not to abandon the party over "policy issues here or there."
Luke
Which is a remarkable ask, given that the Iran war involves actual American military commitment and lives. But yes, that's what he said.
Mark
And Trump just lets him do this? There's no tension there?
Mimi
Not visibly. Vance has been careful never to cross Trump publicly. He praised him effusively, ended by calling him the greatest president. He's playing the role of loyal heir, not rival.
Luke
We should be clear: we don't have reporting on any private conversations between them. We only know what happened on that stage.
Der Puls
- The convention hall in Dallas became an audition stage, with Vance drawing the warmest reception of any speaker besides Trump himself — some in the crowd already calling for him to be the 2028 nominee before he had spoken a word.
- Vance deployed a practiced arsenal of inflammatory rhetoric, false claims about Democratic positions, and a viral confrontation with a protester, each moment engineered to energize the base and circulate beyond the arena.
- The speech required a precise tightrope walk — asserting his own political identity and strength while lavishing praise on Trump and never appearing to reach past him, a constraint that shapes every move in a party built around one man's approval.
- Other potential successors — Cruz, Kennedy, and an absent Rubio — also auditioned in Dallas, but Vance entered with the structural advantage of having never publicly drawn Trump's anger, a currency worth more than any poll number in this political ecosystem.
- A 43% primary polling lead signals Vance has successfully positioned himself as the natural heir, but his unpopular stance on the Iran conflict lingers as a potential liability in a party whose loyalties remain, above all, contingent.
In Dallas on a September night, Vice-President JD Vance stepped before a Republican convention crowd already chanting his name and spent an hour demonstrating that the art of political succession is less about replacing a leader than becoming his most faithful mirror. With practiced grievance, theatrical fury, and carefully calibrated rhetoric, Vance signaled his ambitions for 2028 while never once appearing to reach for the crown — a balance that has defined the careful dance of heirs throughout political history. The crowd's enthusiasm, and a poll placing him at 43% among likely Republican primary voters, suggested the performance landed; yet the shadow of an unpopular Iran policy and a party still entirely organized around one man's favor reminded observers that succession, in any era, is never simply declared.
JD Vance walked onto the stage in Dallas on Thursday night to chants of his name — the warmest greeting anyone besides Trump had received at the two-day Republican midterm convention. Some in the crowd were already calling for him to be the 2028 nominee. He smiled and deflected, insisting the party had to focus on November first. But the message was unmistakable, and he spent the next hour making his case.
Vance opened by channeling the grievances that animate the MAGA base, telling the crowd that Republicans had spent years being called racist simply for noticing the country was becoming 'dirtier and poorer and less safe.' The arena warmed to him. But the night's loudest applause came when a protester briefly interrupted his remarks. Vance claimed the person was waving a Mexican flag and responded with theatrical fury, offering to buy the protester a plane ticket to Mexico. The crowd erupted. It was a moment designed for viral circulation, and it worked.
Throughout the speech, Vance demonstrated a willingness to echo Trump's false claims and deploy rhetoric calibrated for maximum effect. He accused some New York Democrats of having cheered on the October 7 massacre — a claim without factual basis. He framed defunding police and abolishing borders as the driving forces of Democratic politics. He attacked transgender rights, praised manufacturing and religious freedom, and warned Democrats to stay away from children. He also praised Charlie Kirk, the far-right activist killed in Utah a year earlier, and used Kirk's stated disdain for war as an oblique defense of his own unpopular position on the Iran conflict.
The vice-president had to navigate a careful balance — establishing himself as a force in his own right while never appearing to challenge Trump. He praised Trump as 'the toughest SOB in American politics,' invoked the recent birth of his fourth child as a symbol of his political mission, and closed by declaring Trump the greatest president before leaving the stage for his boss.
Vance was not the only potential successor auditioning in Dallas. Ted Cruz drew a rousing response in his home state, and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. delivered a well-received attack on Democrats. Marco Rubio was absent entirely, touring South America. But Vance held a crucial advantage: he had never publicly incurred Trump's wrath, a distinction that matters enormously in a party where the former president's favor determines political viability. A recent poll showed him as the favorite among likely Republican primary voters at 43%, with Rubio at 21% and Trump Jr. at 7%. The numbers suggested Vance had successfully positioned himself as the natural heir — though how long that arrangement would hold, and whether his stance on Iran would eventually cost him, remained an open question.
JD Vance walked onto the stage in Dallas on Thursday night to chants of his name—the warmest greeting anyone besides Trump had received across the two-day Republican midterm convention. Some in the crowd were already shouting that he should be the party's nominee in 2028. He smiled and deflected: "We gotta take care of business this November, then we'll worry about what comes next." But the message was unmistakable. The vice-president had come to make his case as Trump's successor, and he spent the next hour proving he had learned his boss's playbook well.
Vance opened by channeling the grievances that animate the MAGA base. Two years ago, he told the crowd, Republicans were exhausted by being called racist simply for observing that the country was becoming "dirtier and poorer and less safe and less prosperous." The arena responded warmly. But the night's loudest applause came when a protester briefly interrupted his remarks. Vance claimed the person was waving a Mexican flag and responded with theatrical fury: "Well, my friend, if you love Mexico so much, get your ass over there I'll buy you the plane ticket." The crowd erupted. It was a moment designed for viral circulation, and it worked.
Throughout the speech, Vance demonstrated a willingness to echo Trump's false claims and deploy rhetoric that operated on multiple levels. He accused some Democrats in New York of having "cheered on" the October 7 massacre of Israelis—a claim without factual foundation. He suggested that a "new generation" of Democrats wanted to defund police and abolish borders, framing these as the driving force behind Democratic politics. He attacked transgender rights, praised American manufacturing and religious freedom, and warned Democrats to "stay the hell away from our kids." Each line was calibrated to energize the base while maintaining plausible deniability about the inflammatory nature of what he was saying.
Vance also praised Charlie Kirk, the far-right activist assassinated in Utah a year earlier, calling him "a great man" and "a good man." Kirk had been a vocal promoter of Trump's false claims about the 2020 election and had endorsed the racist great replacement theory. In an oblique reference to the ongoing Iran conflict—a policy position that has made Vance deeply unpopular with some Republicans—Vance invoked Kirk's stated disdain for war, urging voters not to abandon the party over disagreements on individual issues.
The vice-president had to navigate a delicate balance. He needed to establish himself as a force in his own right while never appearing to overshadow or challenge Trump. He praised Trump as "the toughest SOB in American politics," pausing repeatedly to allow the crowd to cheer. He invoked the recent birth of his fourth child, framing his political mission as securing "the birthright" of the next generation. And he ended by shouting that Trump was the "greatest president" before leaving the stage for his boss to close the convention.
Vance was not the only potential successor auditioning in Dallas. Robert F. Kennedy Jr., now the health secretary, delivered a well-received speech attacking Democrats. Ted Cruz, the Texas senator, received a rousing response in his home state, declaring that Democrats "hate Christians, they hate Jews, they hate capitalism, they hate the constitution and they hate America"—claims he offered no evidence for. Marco Rubio, the secretary of state, was absent, touring South America instead.
But Vance held a significant advantage: he had never publicly incurred Trump's wrath, a distinction that mattered enormously in a party where the former president's favor determined political viability. A recent poll showed Vance as the favorite choice among likely Republican primary voters, with 43 percent saying they wanted him as the 2028 nominee. Rubio, who had run against Trump in 2016 and been dubbed "Little Marco" for his trouble, received 21 percent. Trump Jr. got 7 percent. Those numbers suggested Vance had successfully positioned himself as the natural heir—but they also reflected a party still entirely organized around Trump's preferences and personality. How long that arrangement would hold, and whether Vance's unpopular stance on the Iran conflict would eventually become a liability, remained to be seen.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
We gotta take care of business this November, then we'll worry about what comes next.— JD Vance, responding to chants that he should be the 2028 nominee
What I'm asking you to do is do what Charlie did: do not throw the baby out with the bathwater. Don't give the country over to a bunch of crazy people because you happen to disagree with us on a policy issue here or there.— JD Vance, urging voters not to abandon the party over disagreements
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei The Guardian ↗
Politics & Governance