On Saturday in Copenhagen, Canada's General Jennie Carignan will stand for election to NATO's highest military office — a role only three Canadians have ever held — knowing that the most powerful voice in the room has already spoken for someone else. The United States, whose weight in alliance decisions remains decisive, is backing Germany's General Carsten Breuer, a reflection less of Carignan's qualifications than of shifting strategic priorities and, some suggest, an American political culture resistant to women in senior command. Ottawa has campaigned earnestly across Europe, and Carignan'
U.S. opposition clouds Canada's bid for NATO military leadership role
Without American backing, a Canadian victory becomes nearly impossible.
Mark
So Canada's top soldier is running for NATO's biggest military job, and we're being told she's going to lose. What's the actual mechanism here—is this a vote where the U.S. can block her directly, or is it more subtle than that?
Mimi
It's the latter. NATO members vote by secret ballot, so there's no formal veto. But the U.S. carries enormous weight in these rooms. If Washington is backing someone else—in this case, Germany's General Breuer—that signal ripples through the alliance. Countries take cues from American preferences. It's not a block; it's a gravitational pull.
Luke
But we should be clear about what we actually know here. The reporting is based on three unnamed sources who say Ottawa isn't counting on a win, and one former official who says American support won't materialize. Those are strong claims, but they're not on the record. We don't have a Pentagon spokesperson saying "we're backing Breuer." We have inference.
Mark
Fair point. But why would the U.S. prefer Germany? Carignan seems qualified.
Mimi
Germany has become a much bigger player in NATO in the last few years. They've increased defence spending significantly and they're a major troop contributor. Right now, they're also negotiating with the Trump administration about replacing military capabilities that would disappear if the U.S. pulls troops out of Europe. From Washington's perspective, Germany is strategically more important to manage.
Luke
That's the economic and strategic argument. But there's also what Perry said about the Pentagon not being enthusiastic about female senior military leadership under Trump. That's a real factor, but it's also worth noting that's one analyst's assessment, not confirmed reporting about Pentagon policy.
Mark
So Carney and McGuinty have been campaigning for her all summer. Did that help at all?
Mimi
One source suggested it may have helped somewhat—Carney is apparently well-regarded in Europe right now because of his middle-power cooperation message and his focus on the EU. But improved prospects aren't the same as a realistic path to victory. McGuinty himself wouldn't predict a win on Friday. He just said these races are tough.
Luke
And historically, only three Canadians have ever held this chair. Germany has never held it. So there's no precedent working in Canada's favor either way. This is genuinely uncertain territory.
Mark
What happens after Saturday?
Mimi
The vote happens in Copenhagen. Someone becomes NATO's principal military adviser. If it's Breuer, that's a significant shift in who shapes the alliance's defence strategy. If somehow Carignan wins, it would be historic—the first woman to hold the post.
Luke
But based on what we know from these sources, the betting odds are heavily against her.
O Pulso
- Canada's top soldier enters a NATO vote this Saturday that three sources say Ottawa has privately conceded she is unlikely to win.
- The decisive obstacle is American backing for Germany's General Breuer — and without U.S. support, a Canadian victory in a NATO vote is historically near-impossible.
- Germany's surging defence spending, its troop contributions, and its active negotiations with Washington over European security gaps have made Berlin the more strategically valuable partner in American eyes.
- Analysts note a further complication: the Trump Pentagon's apparent reluctance to elevate women to senior military roles may be working against Carignan, who would be the first woman to chair NATO's Military Committee.
- Prime Minister Carney and Defence Minister McGuinty campaigned across Europe all summer, and officials suggest Carney's standing on the continent offered some lift — but not enough to overcome Washington's preference.
- The secret ballot Saturday will determine whether Canada extends a rare legacy or watches a historic first slip to another ally.
On Saturday in Copenhagen, Canada's General Jennie Carignan will stand for election to NATO's highest military office — a role only three Canadians have ever held — knowing that the most powerful voice in the room has already spoken for someone else. The United States, whose weight in alliance decisions remains decisive, is backing Germany's General Carsten Breuer, a reflection less of Carignan's qualifications than of shifting strategic priorities and, some suggest, an American political culture resistant to women in senior command. Ottawa has campaigned earnestly across Europe, and Carignan's record is formidable, but in the architecture of great-power alliances, merit and momentum do not always converge.
General Jennie Carignan, Canada's Chief of the Defence Staff, will enter a Copenhagen conference room Saturday to compete for the chair of NATO's Military Committee — the alliance's highest military office, advising the Secretary-General and shaping defence strategy for all 32 member nations. Three sources familiar with the race say Ottawa has already accepted the likely outcome: she will not win.
The reason is not her record, which spans more than four decades in uniform and includes the top job in the Canadian military since 2024. The reason is the United States. American officials are backing Germany's General Carsten Breuer, a position confirmed to The Globe and Mail by a former senior U.S. national-security official with direct Pentagon contacts. In NATO votes, American support is rarely just one voice among equals.
Prime Minister Carney and Defence Minister McGuinty spent the summer making Carignan's case across Europe — Carney raised her candidacy at the July summit in Turkey, and both men worked European counterparts throughout the season. Canadian officials suggested Carney's broader European standing may have helped at the margins. But Germany's expanded defence spending, its major troop contributions, and its ongoing talks with Washington about filling gaps left by a potential U.S. drawdown in Europe have made Berlin the more strategically compelling partner for the Trump administration.
Analyst David Perry of the Canadian Global Affairs Institute was direct: when European allies weigh Germany against Canada, Germany wins. He also flagged a harder dimension — the Trump Pentagon, he said, does not appear inclined to support a female four-star general for such a post. Carignan would be the first woman to chair NATO's Military Committee, a milestone McGuinty highlighted Friday. In the current American political climate, that distinction may be a liability rather than an asset.
McGuinty declined to predict the result, calling such races unpredictable by nature. The secret ballot Saturday will show whether Canada can add a fourth name — and a first woman — to a list that includes only Generals Foulkes, Falls, and Henault across NATO's entire history. The sources say the odds are slim.
General Jennie Carignan, Canada's Chief of the Defence Staff, will walk into a Copenhagen conference room Saturday to face a vote she is unlikely to win. Three sources familiar with the race say Ottawa has already accepted this reality. The position at stake—chair of NATO's Military Committee—is the Western alliance's highest military office, the role that sits closest to the civilian Secretary-General and shapes defence strategy for all 32 member nations. Carignan has spent more than four decades in uniform and has held the Canadian military's top job since 2024. By any measure of qualification, she is a serious candidate. But qualification, it appears, is not the deciding factor.
The obstacle is straightforward and, according to those sources, insurmountable: the United States is not supporting her. Instead, American officials are backing General Carsten Breuer, the chief of Germany's armed forces. A former senior U.S. national-security official who has been in contact with top Pentagon officers confirmed this directly to The Globe and Mail. Without American backing in a NATO vote, a Canadian victory becomes nearly impossible.
Prime Minister Mark Carney and Defence Minister David McGuinty have spent the summer pressing the case for Carignan across Europe. Carney raised her candidacy at the July NATO leaders' summit in Turkey, and both men have been working European counterparts throughout the season. One Canadian military source suggested that Carney's own standing in Europe—bolstered by his Davos speech on middle-power cooperation and his focus on deepening ties with the European Union—may have improved Carignan's prospects somewhat. But improved prospects are not the same as a path to victory.
Germany's position in the alliance has shifted considerably in recent years. Berlin has ramped up defence spending and is a major contributor of troops to NATO deployments. The country has also been in active discussions with the Trump administration about replacing military capabilities that would be lost if the United States follows through on plans to reduce its troop presence in Europe. From Washington's perspective, Germany is a more strategically valuable partner than Canada in this moment. David Perry, president of the Canadian Global Affairs Institute, put it plainly: if European countries had to choose between Germany and Canada, Germany would win. "No matter how much they like maple syrup," he said, "the Germans are a way more important partner to them."
There is another dimension to the American position that Perry flagged. The Trump administration's Pentagon leadership, he noted, does not appear enthusiastic about elevating women to senior military posts. Carignan would be the first woman to chair NATO's Military Committee if elected—a historic breakthrough that McGuinty emphasized in remarks to reporters Friday. But in the current American political climate, that distinction may work against her rather than for her. Perry said it was difficult to imagine the Pentagon supporting a female four-star general for such a role.
McGuinty declined Friday to predict the outcome, calling these races inherently unpredictable. He said he has written to other NATO ministers on Carignan's behalf and praised her campaign, her credibility, and her outreach to counterparts across the alliance. The vote happens Saturday by secret ballot. Only three Canadians have ever held this position in NATO's history: General Charles Foulkes from 1952 to 1953, Admiral Robert Falls from 1980 to 1983, and General Raymond Henault from 2005 to 2008. Carignan's candidacy represents a chance to extend that legacy and to place a woman in NATO's most senior military chair. The sources say that chance is slim.
Citações Notáveis
If European countries had to choose between Germany and Canada, Germany would win—no matter how much they like maple syrup, the Germans are a way more important partner to them.— David Perry, Canadian Global Affairs Institute
She's worked very hard. She's got enormous credibility. She has reached out to her counterparts in all NATO alliance member countries.— Defence Minister David McGuinty
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em The Globe and Mail ↗
War & Conflict