US Jews Grow Closer to Israel Amid Political Divide, but Many Stay Silent Out of Fear

Leaders cite rising antisemitism across North America, including reported 400% increase in antisemitic incidents in public schools since 2023, and Israeli families affected by the post-October 7 conflict.
You can feel deeply connected and still hold critical views.
JFNA's Mimi Kravetz on how American Jews can feel close to Israel while disagreeing with it.
Mark

The headline number is 62% of American Jews feeling Israelis are family. Why does that matter now?

Mimi

Because the political story says the opposite. Leaders in Washington were describing hostility from both parties, yet the study shows closeness rising from 46% in 2021.

Luke

It's a JFNA study, though, and the federations have a stake in the finding. We also don't have the sample or methodology from this reporting.

Mark

Fair. What about the 36% who call themselves Zionists and speak up?

Mimi

That's the quiet part. Most of the community supports Israel but hesitates to say so, from fear of antisemitism or of being tied to the Israeli government.

Luke

Note that the source gives 7% anti-Zionist and 36% openly Zionist, but not the exact size of the silent middle.

Mark

Fingerhut also said Vance's claim about the elections was wrong.

Mimi

Yes, he said they were about many things, mostly anger at Trump.

Luke

That's his reading. The reporting offers no polling behind it, and his worry about Republicans is a judgment, not a measured trend.

Mark

And the 400% rise in school incidents?

Mimi

It's from one set of data collected by groups on the ground, alongside a B'nai B'rith survey showing 71% of Jewish students experiencing antisemitism.

Luke

Right, advocacy-collected figures. Useful, but not an official count.

  • Leaders warn that anti-Israel currents are surfacing in both parties, and the warning carries a sense of alarm that the old alliances may no longer hold.
  • A new survey shows 62% of American Jews now see Israelis as family, yet many supporters of Israel still feel too afraid to speak up in public.
  • A $35 million Frontline initiative is racing to hire 100 anti-antisemitism professionals, with 36 already on the job across local federations.
  • Schools have become a flashpoint, with reports of a 400% rise in antisemitic incidents since 2023 pressing federations to act.
  • The next battleground looms over US arms sales to Israel, and leaders are preparing for a fight that could move quickly into Congress.

In the week after a contentious American midterm election, some 2,500 Jewish leaders from the United States and Canada gathered in Washington and took stock of a moment when hostility toward Israel and rising antisemitism are reshaping political life. Their own survey suggests a community that feels closer to Israel than it did five years ago, even as many of its members hesitate to say so out loud. The gathering turned toward action, launching a major campaign against antisemitism while bracing for a political fight that may soon center on American weapons sales to Israel.

About 2,500 Jewish representatives from the United States and Canada gathered in Washington a week after the midterm elections, and the results shaped nearly every conversation. Eric Fingerhut, the federations' president, described a troubling picture: Israel had loomed large in the primaries, and several critics of Israel had won office, which he saw as a warning that some Democrats were making Israel a scapegoat. He was equally concerned that Republicans, and especially Vice President JD Vance, were beginning to echo similar views. On US military aid, he understood the positions of Netanyahu and Trump, but argued that ending aid would not end the pressure, which would simply shift to arms sales.

A binational study offered a counterpoint to the idea that American Jews and Israel are drifting apart. Some 62% of American Jews now see Israelis as extended family or part of their community, up from 46% in 2021. Mimi Kravetz linked that closeness to shared grief after October 7 and to rising antisemitism, adding that one can feel deeply connected and still hold critical views. Yet most supporters of Israel remain quiet, fearing antisemitism or being mistaken for endorsing the Israeli government.

To answer that threat, the assembly launched Frontline, a $35 million effort that will fund 100 professionals to work with authorities, schools, universities, and faith communities. Thirty-six have already been hired. Leaders said physical security, while costly, is only part of the response, and that relationship-building is the other essential wing. Public schools, they warned, have become a particular concern, with reports of a dramatic rise in incidents and a majority of Jewish students describing antisemitism there.

The federations also pointed to their work in Israel, where they have raised $283 million since October 7 for loans to small businesses, support for reservists, education, and volunteering. The coming months will show whether Frontline takes hold and whether the political fight shifts to arms sales.

About 2,500 Jewish representatives from the United States and Canada met in Washington last week for the General Assembly of the Jewish Federations of North America. They came a week after the American midterm elections, and the results hung over nearly every conversation. The gathering was meant as a show of strength at a time when antisemitism is rising and Israel's standing in the United States has fallen to a low point.

Eric Fingerhut, JFNA's president and CEO, called the election outcome complicated. He named friends he trusts completely: House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Sen. Chuck Schumer, both of Brooklyn, and Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz. But he called it very troubling that Abdul El-Sayed won the Michigan Democratic primary and then a Senate seat, and said party leaders should have called his candidacy a bridge too far instead of embracing it. He also listed mayors critical of Israel who were elected: Zohran Mamdani in New York, Nithya Raman in Los Angeles, Janeese Lewis George in Washington and Katie Wilson in Seattle.

In Fingerhut's account, Israel loomed large in the primaries but mattered less in the general elections, which were driven mainly by anger at President Donald Trump. He rejected Vice President JD Vance's claim that the elections were about Israel. His warning ran in both directions. Some Democrats, he said, are making Israel a scapegoat, and Jewish leaders hope that does not become party policy. What they had not expected was a similar turn among Republicans. Tucker Carlson, he noted, never shaped the party, but Vance does have influence. On aid, Fingerhut said he understood the positions of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Trump on ending U.S. military assistance. He argued, though, that ending it would not satisfy opponents, and that the fight would move to American arms sales.

The central finding of a new binational study by the federations cut against the idea that American Jews and Israel are drifting apart. Some 62% of American Jews now see Israelis as extended family or part of their own community, up from 46% in 2021. Mimi Kravetz, JFNA's chief impact and growth officer, said the bond is strongest among those with existing ties to Israel, and she tied some of the shift to shared grief since the October 7 Hamas attack and to rising antisemitism. "You can feel deeply connected and still hold critical views," she said. She added that left-leaning American Jews hold views on control of the West Bank similar to those of left-leaning Israelis, though the American center sits further left than the Israeli one.

The study also found that 7% of American Jews identify as anti-Zionist, while 36% call themselves Zionists and are comfortable standing publicly behind Israel. Most of the community supports Israel but is reluctant to say so, out of fear of antisemitism and of being seen as endorsing the Israeli government's positions. Kravetz said JFNA is thinking about how to give them the confidence to speak. Becky Caspi, director general of JFNA's Israel office, said the organization does not do public diplomacy for Israel and instead encourages critical, respectful discussion. Right after October 7, about half of North American Jews said they had become more involved in Jewish activities; three years later, roughly a third still say so.

The assembly also launched Frontline, a $35 million initiative against antisemitism. Grants will go to 120 local federations to recruit 100 professionals who will work with local and state authorities, schools, universities and other religious communities. Thirty-six have been hired. The grants cover the positions for two years, after which the federations will keep employing them. Shira Hutt, a senior executive vice president, said federations have already spent more than $1 billion on physical security, but called that just one wing of an airplane, with relationship-building as the other. Lauren Steinberg, vice president for civic engagement, pointed to public schools: one dataset shows a 400% rise in antisemitic incidents since 2023, and a B'nai B'rith survey found 71% of Jewish students had experienced antisemitism there.

The federations also reported on Israel. Three years after October 7, and a year after closing a $908 million emergency fund, they have raised and invested $283 million in Rebuild Israel. That includes $242 million in loans to 4,132 small businesses and $176 million for 13,773 reservists. The Habayta initiative supports 40,000 students in 14 local authorities, and Volunteer in Israel, run with Birthright Israel, has drawn more than 30,000 volunteers who gave over 150,000 days of service. Next to watch: Frontline's hiring, and whether the political fight moves to arms sales.

If both parties agree that Israel is to blame, that's a cause for concern.
— Eric Fingerhut, JFNA president and CEO
This didn't happen in a vacuum. It has been building for years, and because it didn't erupt, it wasn't addressed.
— Lauren Steinberg, JFNA vice president for civic engagement
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei Ynetnews ↗
Kontakt FAQ