On the margins of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, American and Iranian officials engaged in their most direct contact in weeks, with mediators working to bridge a chasm between two nations whose standoff over the Strait of Hormuz threatens the arteries of global commerce. Iran arrived with explicit conditions — the lifting of a naval blockade, the release of frozen assets, the end of military pressure — while Washington oscillated between optimism and the language of annihilation. Whether this fragile opening at the world's foremost diplomatic forum can hold long enough to bec
US, Iran hold mediated talks at UN on ending war and reopening Strait of Hormuz
Iran could reopen the strait within seven days if pressure eased
Mark
So what actually happened in that room on Tuesday? Did they meet face-to-face or not?
Mimi
Both accounts are true in a way. Mediators shuttled between the delegations all day, but at some point Araghchi and the American envoys—Witkoff and Kushner—sat down together. Trump initially made it sound like a three-hour direct meeting, which created confusion, but the White House clarified he wasn't there.
Luke
That's the thing though—we don't have independent confirmation of what was actually discussed in that direct meeting, or how long it lasted, or what was agreed. We have Trump's characterization and Iran's characterization, and they're quite different.
Mark
What does Iran actually want?
Mimi
Three things: lift the naval blockade, unfreeze the assets, stop the military pressure. In return, they say they can reopen Hormuz in seven days.
Luke
But "reopen" is vague. Does that mean normal traffic? What about inspections? What about the ships Iran has seized? Those details matter and we don't have them.
Mark
Is there real momentum here or is this theater?
Mimi
An Iranian official told Reuters they see this as a genuine opportunity and that they've already submitted a proposal on September 16. That suggests some seriousness. But Trump also just threatened to annihilate Iran in his UN speech, so the mood is fragile.
Luke
Right—and we should note that Trump has said things are "moving along nicely" before. In August he said parameters were reached. We don't know what changed or why these talks are different.
Mark
What about the other countries involved?
Mimi
Qatar and Oman are doing their own diplomatic work. Qatar is working with Pakistan, and there's apparently a Qatari proposal for a security framework that Iran is reviewing.
Luke
But Qatar hasn't made that proposal public, so we don't know what it actually contains or whether it's even serious. It could be a trial balloon or it could be substantive. We just don't know.
Mark
So what happens next?
Mimi
The mediators keep working. Both sides say they want to continue. But the core issue—whether the US will actually lift the blockade and unfreeze assets—that's still unresolved.
Luke
And that's the real test. Everything else is negotiating theater until someone moves on that.
O Pulso
- The Strait of Hormuz remains closed, and every day of its closure tightens the pressure on global energy markets and the populations that depend on them.
- Confusion over whether talks were direct or mediated exposed the opacity and mistrust that shadows every exchange between Washington and Tehran.
- Iran set a precise, seven-day clock on reopening the strait — but only if the US lifts its naval blockade, unfreezes assets, and ends military pressure, conditions Washington has not publicly accepted.
- Trump swung between offering Iran economic revival and threatening to 'annihilate the Islamic Republic' in the same UN address, a duality that complicates any negotiator's task.
- Qatar, Oman, and Pakistan are running parallel diplomatic tracks, with a Qatari regional security framework quietly circulating among Gulf states and Tehran.
- Both sides claim momentum, yet the gap between Iran's demands and what Washington is prepared to concede has not visibly narrowed, leaving the outcome suspended between possibility and collapse.
On the margins of the United Nations General Assembly in New York, American and Iranian officials engaged in their most direct contact in weeks, with mediators working to bridge a chasm between two nations whose standoff over the Strait of Hormuz threatens the arteries of global commerce. Iran arrived with explicit conditions — the lifting of a naval blockade, the release of frozen assets, the end of military pressure — while Washington oscillated between optimism and the language of annihilation. Whether this fragile opening at the world's foremost diplomatic forum can hold long enough to become something durable remains the defining question of a conflict that has already outlasted several near-agreements.
On Tuesday, in the corridors surrounding the United Nations General Assembly in New York, American and Iranian officials held hours of mediated negotiations — the closest thing to direct contact the two sides had managed in weeks. At the center of the talks were two linked questions: would the United States lift its naval blockade of Iranian ports and release frozen assets, and would Iran reopen the Strait of Hormuz, one of the world's most consequential shipping lanes.
The American account of the day's events shifted almost immediately. Special envoy Steve Witkoff described the process as indirect, with mediators shuttling between delegations. President Trump told reporters something different — that Witkoff and Jared Kushner had sat directly with Iranian officials for three hours in a 'very productive' meeting. The confusion was eventually clarified, but it underscored the opacity surrounding the negotiations. What was not disputed was that Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and the American envoys had met face-to-face, ending weeks of silence.
Iran's conditions were unambiguous: lift the naval blockade, unfreeze assets held abroad, and end military pressure on what Tehran calls the 'resistance' fronts. In return, an Iranian official told Reuters that the strait could be reopened within seven days. The same official described the UN gathering as a 'golden opportunity,' noting that Iran had already submitted a proposal to Washington through mediators on September 16.
Trump's posture at the General Assembly moved between promise and menace. He offered Iran the prospect of economic renewal if it abandoned its nuclear program and support for what Washington calls terrorism — then warned that the alternative was annihilation. Iran's military leadership dismissed the threats as 'strategic weakness' and pledged readiness for 'more severe, crushing, and unpredictable blows' if attacked.
Around the bilateral talks, a wider regional effort was taking shape. Qatar announced it was working with Pakistan on de-escalation and the protection of Gulf shipping. Oman remained quietly engaged on maritime arrangements. Trump held separate meetings with leaders from Gulf Cooperation Council states, Turkey, Jordan, Syria, and Iraq. A Qatari proposal for a common regional security framework involving Iran and the Gulf states was reported to be under consideration, though Tehran had not yet responded publicly.
The talks arrived after months of incremental movement and repeated setbacks — a collapsed memorandum of understanding in June, tentative parameters in August, and a series of cautious statements that never quite hardened into agreement. With Witkoff signaling that mediation would continue and Trump speaking of 'a lot of momentum,' the question was whether the narrow opening created in New York could widen — or whether the distance between what Iran demands and what Washington will concede remains too great to cross.
In the margins of the United Nations General Assembly in New York on Tuesday, American and Iranian officials engaged in hours of mediated negotiations—the first direct contact between the two sides in weeks. The talks centered on two interlocking questions: whether the United States would lift its naval blockade of Iranian ports and release frozen Iranian assets, and whether Iran would reopen the Strait of Hormuz, one of the world's most critical shipping lanes.
The American account of what happened shifted within hours. Steve Witkoff, Trump's special envoy, initially described the day's work as indirect—mediators, he said, had "shuttled between" the two delegations throughout Tuesday. But President Trump offered a different version to reporters at the UN, saying Witkoff and Jared Kushner had sat down directly with Iranian officials for three hours and that the meeting had been "very productive." The White House later clarified that Trump himself had not attended, but the initial confusion underscored the opacity surrounding the negotiations. What became clear, however, was that Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi and the American envoys had met face-to-face, marking a resumption of direct contact after weeks of silence.
Iran's conditions for moving forward were explicit and unambiguous. According to state media and an Iranian security official who spoke to Al Jazeera, Tehran demanded that Washington lift its naval blockade, unfreeze Iranian assets held abroad, and cease military pressure on what Iran calls the "resistance" fronts. In exchange, an Iranian official told Reuters that Iran could reopen the Strait of Hormuz within seven days. That same official, speaking on condition of anonymity, described the UN gathering as a "golden opportunity" for the United States to return to serious diplomacy. Iran had already submitted its latest proposal to Washington through mediators on September 16, the official said, and believed the details of a possible agreement to end hostilities could be hammered out in New York.
Trump's public posture oscillated between optimism and threat. In his address to the General Assembly, he framed the choice starkly: the United States could reach a deal that would allow Iran to rebuild its economy, or it could move to "annihilate the Islamic Republic." He also reminded the assembly that Washington had previously offered Iran "full economic cooperation" if it abandoned its nuclear program and what the US describes as support for terrorism. Iran's military leadership responded swiftly, dismissing Trump's threats as evidence of "strategic weakness" and declaring readiness to deliver "more severe, crushing, and unpredictable blows" if attacked further.
The bilateral talks were accompanied by a broader regional diplomatic push. Qatar announced it was working with Pakistan to reduce tensions, safeguard shipping through the Strait of Hormuz, and promote stability across the Gulf. Qatar's Prime Minister and Foreign Minister met with Araghchi on Tuesday to discuss de-escalation efforts. Oman, which has long played a quiet role in maritime diplomacy with Iran, remained engaged in discussions about navigation arrangements through the strait. Trump also held separate meetings with leaders from Gulf Cooperation Council states, Turkey, Jordan, Syria, and Iraq to discuss Iran and regional security. Reuters reported that a Qatari proposal for a common security framework involving Iran and the Gulf states was under consideration, with one regional source saying Tehran was reviewing it, though Qatar had not made the proposal public.
The negotiations came against a backdrop of months of incremental progress punctuated by setbacks. In June, a memorandum of understanding between the parties had collapsed. By early August, Trump said the sides had reached parameters for a possible agreement. In subsequent weeks, he described talks over the Strait of Hormuz as "moving along nicely," though he acknowledged significant differences remained. Earlier in September, he had expressed hope that the war was "towards the end." Now, with Witkoff saying mediators would continue their work and Trump expressing belief in "a lot of momentum" toward a settlement, the question was whether the narrow opening created at the UN could widen into something durable—or whether the gap between Iran's demands and what Washington was willing to concede would prove too wide to bridge.
Citações Notáveis
This latest meeting was held at the request and insistence of the American side, and was aimed at conveying Iran's messages and conditions, particularly around reopening the Strait of Hormuz.— Iranian state media account reported by Al Jazeera's Tohid Asadi
They had a very good meeting, a very productive meeting. I believe there is a lot of momentum towards an agreement.— President Trump to reporters at the UN
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em Al Jazeera ↗
War & Conflict