U.S. Intelligence Skeptical of Israeli Iran Assassination Warning for Trump

The threat was treated as real enough to act on, regardless of what analysts thought.
U.S. intelligence doubted Israel's Iranian assassination warning, yet Trump was still evacuated during his Turkey visit.
Mark

Why would Israel present intelligence it knew the Americans would doubt?

Mimi

Because the warning itself—even if questioned—still shapes how the president thinks about the region. It plants a seed. It makes Turkey seem more dangerous, more unpredictable.

Mark

But if the CIA didn't believe it, didn't that undermine Israel's credibility?

Mimi

In the short term, yes. But the evacuation still happened. Trump still got moved to a catering truck. The threat was treated as real enough to act on, regardless of what analysts thought.

Mark

So Israel gets the outcome it wanted even without full buy-in from U.S. intelligence?

Mimi

Partly. But there's a cost. Once officials start seeing a pattern—once they believe you're using intelligence to manipulate rather than inform—trust erodes. That's what the Post reporting suggests is happening.

Mark

What about Huckabee calling Israeli settlers "terrorists"? That's extraordinary language from a U.S. ambassador.

Mimi

It is. It signals that the administration is willing to publicly break with Israeli actions, at least when they involve American citizens. But notice he also said the embassy had already been handling it. The public statement came after the fact.

Mark

Does that weaken his criticism?

Mimi

It complicates it. He's defending the embassy's work while condemning the settlers. He's saying we're on top of this, we're the adults in the room. But calling them terrorists—that's not diplomatic language. That's a choice.

Mark

And Iran blocking the Strait of Hormuz while Trump claims total control—that's a direct contradiction.

Mimi

It is. And Iran's response is essentially: your words don't change what's happening here. We control this waterway until our conditions are met. It's a test of whether Trump's rhetoric translates to actual leverage.

  • CIA analysts rated Israel's Iranian assassination warning as 'low confidence,' yet the threat was taken seriously enough to reroute Trump through an airport catering truck to a secret military plane.
  • Some U.S. officials suspect Israel deliberately amplified the threat to steer Trump away from deepening ties with Turkey's Erdoğan — a pattern they believe has appeared before in Israeli intelligence sharing.
  • Iran flatly rejected Trump's claim of 'total control' over the Strait of Hormuz, with Tehran's newly formed Persian Gulf Strait Authority insisting the waterway remains blocked until Iranian conditions are met.
  • U.S. Ambassador Mike Huckabee publicly called Israeli settlers who besieged a Palestinian home in the West Bank — trapping an American citizen inside for five days — 'terrorists' engaging in 'disgusting, thuggish behavior.'
  • Negotiations over Hezbollah's disarmament verification body continued, with Britain, Italy, Switzerland, and Indonesia on a shortlist, though Washington retains final say over which nations participate.
  • An Israeli military probe into the abuse of a Palestinian detainee by Netzah Yehuda soldiers resulted in disciplinary measures, including removal of a company commander and detention sentences, though the army stopped short of criminal charges.

In the layered world of intelligence and alliance, trust is never fully given — only calibrated. American analysts quietly doubted an Israeli warning of an Iranian assassination plot against President Trump during his Turkey visit, suspecting the alert may have been shaped as much by Israeli anxieties over Washington's warming ties with Ankara as by any genuine threat. The episode, in which Trump was nonetheless spirited away in a catering truck to an alternate aircraft, illuminates the quiet contest of perception and influence that runs beneath the surface of even the closest alliances.

American intelligence officials did not believe Israel's warning of an Iranian plot to kill President Trump during his visit to Turkey. CIA analysts rated the intelligence as low confidence — yet the threat was treated with enough gravity that Trump was quietly moved from his scheduled aircraft to an airport catering truck, then transferred to an alternate military plane that carried him from Ankara onward to Britain.

The skepticism ran deeper than doubt about the threat itself. Some U.S. officials suspected Israel had shaped the warning at least partly to influence Trump's posture toward Turkey and his relationship with President Erdoğan, whose warming ties with Washington appear to unsettle Israeli leadership. American officials described this as consistent with a broader pattern in which Israeli intelligence has been calibrated, in some instances, to steer presidential thinking.

Elsewhere, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee took an unusually sharp public stance over a five-day settler siege of a Palestinian home in the West Bank village of Qusra — a home that sheltered an American citizen. Huckabee called the settlers 'terrorists' on social media, said the U.S. Embassy had been deeply engaged in seeking resolution, and credited his own request with prompting the IDF and Israeli police to intervene. He described the settlers' conduct as 'disgusting' and 'thuggish,' designed to intimidate and harass the family inside.

Iran, meanwhile, dismissed Trump's repeated assertion that the United States holds 'total control' of the Strait of Hormuz. Tehran's newly established Persian Gulf Strait Authority stated flatly that the strait remains blocked and will not reopen until Iran's conditions are accepted, brushing aside U.S. officials' statements about lifting the blockade as having no bearing on reality.

In Lebanon, U.S.-mediated talks produced a shortlist — Britain, Italy, Switzerland, and Indonesia — of countries that could contribute to a body overseeing Hezbollah's disarmament under a June agreement. A Lebanese official confirmed the two sides had aligned on candidates, but noted Washington would make the final selection. Israeli officials said no agreement had yet been finalized.

An Israeli military investigation into the abuse of a Palestinian detainee by soldiers from the ultra-Orthodox Netzah Yehuda battalion concluded he had attempted to harm himself — while acknowledging that photographing and sharing the image online violated army standards. Disciplinary measures followed: a company commander was removed from his post, a deputy battalion commander received a formal reprimand, and several soldiers were sentenced to days in military detention or confined to base.

In Gaza, an Israeli airstrike critically wounded a Palestinian man riding a rickshaw in Beit Lahiya — the military said it targeted a Hamas commander planning attacks on Israeli troops. The strike was the first significant one in over a week, following U.S. pressure to scale back operations as Trump's latest plan to end the war takes shape.

The U.S. intelligence community did not believe Israel's warning about an Iranian plot to assassinate President Trump during his visit to Turkey last week. According to reporting from The Washington Post, CIA analysts found the intelligence unconvincing and classified it as "low confidence." Yet the threat was treated seriously enough that Trump was moved from his scheduled aircraft to an airport catering truck, which transported him to an alternate military plane that carried him from Ankara to Britain.

The skepticism among American intelligence officials ran deeper than simple doubt about the threat itself. Some U.S. officials suspected that Israel had presented the warning partly to shape Trump's thinking on regional policy—specifically to influence his approach toward Turkey and his relationship with President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. American officials noted this fit a broader pattern: they believe Israeli intelligence reports have been calibrated, at least in some cases, to steer presidential decision-making. The concern centers on Israel's unease about warming ties between Washington and Ankara, a shift that appears to worry Israeli leadership.

Meanwhile, U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee took a forceful public stance on a different security matter unfolding in the West Bank. Israeli settlers had maintained a five-day siege of a Palestinian home in the village of Qusra, and the family inside included an American citizen. Huckabee called the settlers "terrorists" on social media, stating that the U.S. Embassy in Jerusalem had been deeply involved in seeking resolution. He said the IDF and Israeli police arrived at the scene at his request to remove what he termed "the Israeli terrorists doing this." Huckabee characterized their actions as "disgusting" and "thuggish behavior" meant to intimidate and harass the family. He added that the White House had not needed to formally intervene because the embassy had kept Washington continuously informed.

On the Iranian side, Tehran rejected Trump's repeated claims that the United States maintains "total control" of the Strait of Hormuz. Trump had told reporters on Tuesday that America alone controlled the waterway. Iran's newly established Persian Gulf Strait Authority responded on social media, stating flatly that the strait "remains blocked and will not be reopened until Iran's conditions are accepted." The authority dismissed repeated statements by U.S. officials about lifting the blockade, saying such rhetoric had no bearing on the actual situation on the ground.

In Lebanon, negotiations continued over the mechanism that would oversee Hezbollah's disarmament under a June agreement tying Israel's phased withdrawal to the militant group's disarmament. Israel and Lebanon had agreed on a shortlist of potential countries—Britain, Italy, Switzerland, and Indonesia—that could contribute personnel or troops to verify compliance. The list emerged from U.S.-mediated talks in Rome the previous week. A Lebanese official told Reuters that while the two sides had agreed on the candidates, the United States would make the final decision about which countries would participate. An Israeli Embassy spokesperson said negotiations over the body's composition were still ongoing and no agreement had been finalized.

An Israeli military investigation concluded that a Palestinian detainee tied to a bed by soldiers from the ultra-Orthodox Netzah Yehuda battalion had attempted to harm himself. The military acknowledged, however, that the soldiers' conduct—photographing the detainee and sharing the image online—violated army values and expected standards. Several soldiers and commanders faced discipline: the company commander was removed from his position and transferred to a staff role; the deputy battalion commander received a command reprimand; the soldier who restrained the detainee was sentenced to five days in military detention and removed from combat duty; the soldier who photographed him also received five days in detention; another soldier was confined to base for fourteen days. Disciplinary action against two additional soldiers from other units remained pending.

In Gaza, an Israeli airstrike critically wounded a Palestinian man in what the military described as a strike targeting a Hamas commander planning attacks against Israeli troops. Palestinian medics and witnesses said the man had been riding in a rickshaw in Beit Lahiya in northern Gaza when struck. The airstrike marked the first major strike in over a week, following U.S. pressure on Israel to scale back operations as it implements the latest version of Trump's plan to end the war. The Israeli military said its forces would remain deployed in the area and continue operations against what it termed immediate threats.

Actions by those who carried out this horrific act of terror meant to intimidate and harass this family are disgusting. No excuse for such thuggish behavior.
— U.S. Ambassador Mike Huckabee, on Israeli settlers in Qusra
The Strait of Hormuz remains blocked and will not be reopened until Iran's conditions are accepted.
— Iran's Persian Gulf Strait Authority
Quer a matéria completa? Leia o original em Haaretz ↗
Fale Conosco FAQ