In the long and bloody story of Europe's largest war since 1945, a new and uncomfortable question has surfaced: whether a territorial price might be attached to Ukraine's path into NATO. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky reports that Washington, after two days of talks in Abu Dhabi that ended without a breakthrough, asked Kyiv whether it would withdraw from Donbas if it joined the alliance, the first time such an exchange has been framed to him that way. He has neither accepted nor rejected it, saying that any answer must rest on concrete Western guarantees and ultimately on the consent o
US Floats Ukraine Land-for-NATO Trade, Zelensky Says; Russia Rejects Energy Ceasefire
Continued fighting in the Donetsk region, including around the contested city of Kostiantynivka, is affecting civilians and forces on both sides.
The first time this had been raised, Zelensky says: land for NATO
Mark
Why does this one question from the Americans matter so much?
Mimi
Because it links two things that had been separate: territory and NATO membership. Zelensky says it was the first time Washington put them in the same sentence.
Luke
Worth saying plainly, though: this is Zelensky's account. The reporting has no US statement confirming how the question was framed.
Mark
He didn't accept it, did he?
Mimi
No. He said he'd ask Ukrainian society if Western guarantees were confirmed, and that he has no right to decide alone.
Luke
And that's an "if." Nothing in the reporting says NATO has offered membership or anything concrete.
Mark
What about the energy ceasefire?
Mimi
He says Russia rejected it. That's a direct claim about the talks, and winter makes it weigh more.
Luke
I'd keep his reading of Russia betting everything on winter separate from the rejection itself. One is a report, the other is his assessment.
Mark
And Kostiantynivka?
Mimi
Russia says it took the town. Ukraine says fighting goes on. Zelensky calls the humanitarian mission idea a way to empty the city.
Luke
That motive is his interpretation. What we don't have is Moscow's explanation of the proposal.
Il Polso
- A single question from Washington, as Zelensky describes it, has shaken the frame of the negotiations: land for a seat at the NATO table.
- Abu Dhabi talks between Ukrainian and Russian delegations closed with no breakthrough, leaving the war's core demands unresolved.
- Moscow has refused an energy-infrastructure ceasefire, and Zelensky reads this as a bet on the coming winter campaign.
- A Russian offer of a 'humanitarian mission' to Kostiantynivka is viewed in Kyiv as a pretext for seizing the city, while fighting there continues.
- Navigation now turns to concrete security guarantees and European seats at future talks, with any territorial deal requiring a Ukrainian public vote.
In the long and bloody story of Europe's largest war since 1945, a new and uncomfortable question has surfaced: whether a territorial price might be attached to Ukraine's path into NATO. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky reports that Washington, after two days of talks in Abu Dhabi that ended without a breakthrough, asked Kyiv whether it would withdraw from Donbas if it joined the alliance, the first time such an exchange has been framed to him that way. He has neither accepted nor rejected it, saying that any answer must rest on concrete Western guarantees and ultimately on the consent of Ukrainians themselves.
On Friday, after meeting European leaders in Denmark and Ireland, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky described two days of talks in Abu Dhabi that had produced no breakthrough. His most striking claim was that the United States had, for the first time, asked whether Ukraine would give up Donbas in exchange for joining NATO. The account rests on Zelensky's word alone; there is no public US confirmation of the exchange.
He did not answer the question. Zelensky said Ukraine is seeking specific security guarantees from NATO and the EU, and that if those were confirmed he would put the matter to Ukrainian society. He insisted that such a decision was not his alone to make.
The talks, brokered by Washington with envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, brought Ukrainian and Russian delegations together, and the US envoys later met Putin and Zelensky separately. All sides agreed European officials should join future rounds.
Zelensky also said Moscow rejected a ceasefire on energy targets, which he attributed to Russia wagering on this winter's campaign. He called Putin's proposed humanitarian mission to Kostiantynivka a ploy to draw Kyiv out so Russian forces could occupy the city. Ukraine says fighting there continues, and Russia's advances in Donetsk have not yet taken the whole region.
He closed by warning that Russia's demands to rewrite Europe's security order are dangerous, and that the EU and NATO remain the continent's only real security.
On Friday, after stops in Denmark and Ireland where he met European leaders, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky spoke to reporters about what had happened at two days of talks in Abu Dhabi. His remarks were held under embargo until Saturday. The most striking claim: for the first time, he said, the United States had raised the idea of Ukraine giving up land to Russia in return for a place in NATO.
Zelensky described the question as the Americans put it to the Ukrainian side. What if Ukraine joins NATO, would it then withdraw from Donbas? He stressed that this was the first time the proposal had been put to him in that form. The account comes from Zelensky himself; the source material does not include a US confirmation or description of the exchange.
He did not say yes. Zelensky said Ukraine is discussing specific security guarantees from NATO and the EU, and that if Western countries confirmed them, he would put the matter to Ukrainian society and ask whether it accepts or not. He said he has no right to make that decision alone.
The Abu Dhabi talks were brokered by the United States and brought Ukrainian and Russian delegations together. US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff attended, and afterward met Vladimir Putin and Zelensky separately. The talks ended without a breakthrough in what is Europe's worst war since World War II. All sides did agree that European officials should be included in future negotiations.
Zelensky also said Russia turned down a proposed ceasefire on attacks against energy targets. He put it bluntly: the Russians do not want it. He argued that Russia is betting everything on this winter's campaign, a reading that fits a refusal to pause strikes on energy infrastructure, though that link is his interpretation.
He was equally skeptical of a Putin proposal for a humanitarian mission to Kostiantynivka, a city in the Donetsk region. In Zelensky's telling, it is a ploy to get Kyiv to pull out so Russian forces can walk in and occupy the whole city. Russia said earlier this year that it had seized the town, but Ukraine says fighting there continues. Since the invasion began in February 2022, Moscow's troops have inched westward but have not taken all of Donetsk.
Zelensky closed with a warning about Russian demands to review Europe's security arrangements. He called the EU and NATO the continent's only real security, and said Moscow's effort to renegotiate that order is dangerous, because exactly this kind of thing leads to wars or escalation.
What to watch next: whether Washington confirms or clarifies the Donbas question, whether NATO and the EU put specific guarantees on the table, and when European officials take their seats in the next round. Any deal along these lines would, by Zelensky's account, have to go to Ukrainians for their answer.
Citazioni salienti
I have no right to make that decision on my own.— Volodymyr Zelensky, on putting any NATO-for-Donbas deal to Ukrainians
On the proposal for an energy ceasefire: the Russians don't want it.— Volodymyr Zelensky
Vuoi la storia completa?
Leggi l'originale su Bangkok Post ↗