In a bunker office in Kherson, humanitarians sit down to work out how to reach people who have chosen to remain near the frontline, and the UN's Matthias Schmale reflects on what that work now demands. As Russian strikes on civilians and power grids intensify ahead of winter, the old tension of aid in war, between being close enough to understand people and keeping those who help them from paying too high a price, grows sharper. The UN has said it will stay and keep supporting Ukrainians, and the coming months will show whether that commitment can be carried out without asking others to bear r
UN Ukraine Chief Says Aid Workers Must Stay Close to Frontline Communities, Managing Risk Responsibly
In a country under attack, you cannot work without risk.
Why does a UN official bring up pets in a piece about frontline risk?
Because it shows what closeness buys you. Schmale says some people refuse to evacuate if their dog or cat can't come. Without being near people, you'd never plan for that.
And the risk side? Who is actually exposed?
Mostly national staff and volunteers. He says they carry the greatest risk, and that international colleagues, himself included, have only felt it from time to time, like running from drones at a bakery in Kherson.
Worth noting this is a first-person account, so it's his view and his anecdotes. The piece doesn't give casualty figures for aid workers or numbers for evacuations.
He says attacks are intensifying before winter. Is that backed up here?
It's his assertion. He says power grid attacks threaten heating, water and services, but no specific outages or data are cited in the text.
What about the governor's remark, give it to the military?
He calls it sensitive. It's listed among last-resort channels, not a plan. Handing aid to a military raises obvious questions for humanitarian neutrality.
And the piece doesn't say whether it's been tried. We only know a governor suggested it about one area.
So what is firmly committed?
A core UN presence for as long as physically possible, and a pledge to avoid passing risk to partners, though how is still an open question he poses himself.
Der Puls
- Russian attacks on civilians and energy infrastructure are intensifying just as winter approaches.
- Strikes on power grids threaten heating, water supplies and essential services for people already in a severe crisis.
- Volunteers and national staff, who carry most of the danger, are evacuating people from the front line and running from drones.
- The UN is trying to keep a core presence in Ukraine through drone detection, insistence on international law, and cautious last-resort channels, and is landing on a fragile balance between closeness and caution.
In a bunker office in Kherson, humanitarians sit down to work out how to reach people who have chosen to remain near the frontline, and the UN's Matthias Schmale reflects on what that work now demands. As Russian strikes on civilians and power grids intensify ahead of winter, the old tension of aid in war, between being close enough to understand people and keeping those who help them from paying too high a price, grows sharper. The UN has said it will stay and keep supporting Ukrainians, and the coming months will show whether that commitment can be carried out without asking others to bear risks that should be shared.
In a bunker office in Kherson, a small group of humanitarians, some from volunteer organizations with very few resources, gathers to plan how to help people who have chosen to stay near the frontline. Matthias Schmale, the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine, describes this scene as one of the images that stays with him when he thinks about aid in the country today.
He describes a war that is growing more dangerous and less predictable. Russian attacks on civilians and energy infrastructure are intensifying before winter, putting heating, water and essential services at risk. Even so, he says the UN will stay and keep supporting Ukrainians.
Schmale also points to the Ukrainian volunteers and staff who evacuate people from the front line at great personal risk, doing so with remarkable dedication and a sense of humour. He insists that proximity is essential: aid workers must know people's needs, speak their language and understand their customs. He was surprised by how much pets and farm animals matter to evacuees, some of whom refuse to leave without them.
The hardest question, he says, is who carries the risk. Most aid is delivered by national staff and volunteers, who are the most exposed. Schmale has felt that danger himself, once running from drones during a visit to a bakery in Kherson. He asks how aid can continue without pushing risk onto partners.
His answer is that work in a country under attack cannot be risk-free, so the task is to manage risk responsibly. That means pressing for respect for international humanitarian law, and using tools such as drone detection. Military channels remain a last resort and a sensitive one. He also rejects the idea that anyone should be expected to act as a hero. As UN leadership, he says, they intend to keep a core presence as long as it is physically possible, and as winter closes in, the test will be whether that balance holds.
In a bunker office in Kherson, a handful of humanitarians, some from very small volunteer-based groups, sit down to work out how to help people who have chosen to stay near the frontline. Matthias Schmale, the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine, says it is one of the images that comes to mind when he thinks about aid delivery in the country today. He set out his reflections in a first-person account published by UN News.
Schmale describes a war that is growing more dangerous and less predictable. Russian attacks on civilians and on energy infrastructure are intensifying ahead of winter, he says. The targeting of power grids puts heating, water supplies and essential services at risk, deepening a humanitarian crisis that was already severe. Even so, he states that the UN will stay and continue to support Ukrainians.
The second image he offers is of Ukrainian volunteers and staff evacuating people from the front line, at great risk to themselves. He says they do it with remarkable dedication and a sense of humour. Between the evacuations on one side, and the delivery of essential supplies and advocacy for people in occupied areas on the other, he sees the shape of the work.
He argues that proximity is not optional. You cannot understand people's needs and aspirations, he says, if you are not close to them, do not speak their language and do not understand their customs. His example is one that surprised him: how much pets and larger farm animals matter to evacuees. Some people refuse to leave if their dog or cat cannot come along. The more he has thought about it, he says, the more he reads animals as a tie to home and to land that people are unwilling to give up.
The harder question is who carries the risk. Most humanitarian aid, Schmale notes, is delivered by staff and volunteers of national organizations, and they are the most exposed. He has felt some of that danger himself, as have other UN and international colleagues. On a visit to a bakery in Kherson, his group had to run from drones. He asks how aid can be delivered in wartime without shifting risk onto implementing partners, and how frontline workers can be protected.
His answer starts from a plain premise: in a country under attack, work cannot be free of risk, so the question is how to take it responsibly. He says that means continuing to press for adherence to international humanitarian law, because wars have rules. It also means weighing practical tools to keep people safe, such as drone detection and drone scrambling equipment.
Beyond those lies what aid agencies call measures or channels of last resort, including the military. Schmale recalls a conversation with a governor about an area the UN could not reach for security reasons, despite huge needs there. When he asked how aid could get in, the governor answered spontaneously, "give it to the military." Schmale calls that sensitive, and does not present it as a settled solution.
He is also wary of heroics. Nobody, he says, should be expected to act as a hero when the risk to their life is too great. As head of the UN in Ukraine, he says he and others in the leadership are determined to keep a core presence for as long as that is physically possible, taking risks that are responsible rather than stupid. With winter approaching and the grid under attack, the test will be whether that balance between closeness and caution holds.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
We are not taking stupid but responsible risks.— Matthias Schmale, UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine
We shouldn't expect anyone to be the hero if we know the risk to their life is too big.— Matthias Schmale, UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine