UN Ukraine chief: aid workers must balance closeness to people with the risks of frontline work

Civilians on the frontline face attacks and loss of heating and water as power grids are targeted, while national aid workers and volunteers face the greatest risk while evacuating people.
In a country at war, you cannot work without risk.
Schmale says aid in Ukraine must be delivered responsibly, not heroically, as winter attacks on infrastructure grow.
Mark

Schmale talks about balancing closeness and risk. What's the tension, exactly?

Mimi

To understand people you have to be near them, speaking their language, knowing their customs. But near the frontline means drones and shelling, and winter is coming with attacks on the power grid.

Luke

Worth noting this is an opinion-style piece in his own voice. The claim that attacks are intensifying is his assessment; the text gives no figures.

Mark

He mentions pets. Why does that matter?

Mimi

It shows what closeness buys you. Some people won't evacuate without a dog or cat. He reads that as attachment to home and land, something you'd miss from a distance.

Mark

And who is actually taking the risk?

Mimi

Mostly national staff and volunteers. He says that plainly, and says the question is how to avoid shifting danger onto partners.

Luke

He doesn't claim to have solved it. Drone detection and scrambling gear are things to consider, not announced programmes.

Mark

The governor's 'give it to the military' remark is striking.

Mimi

He calls it sensitive, and he frames the military as a channel of last resort, not a plan.

Luke

Right, and we don't know whether anything came of that conversation. The piece doesn't say.

  • Russian strikes on power grids are intensifying just as winter approaches, threatening heat, water and essential services for civilians already living in crisis.
  • Frontline aid workers, mostly Ukrainian staff and volunteers, are being exposed to drones and shelling while evacuating people from danger zones.
  • Aid teams are weighing drone-detection and drone-scrambling equipment to protect their people while trying to keep delivering supplies.
  • The UN is debating whether military channels, once a last resort, could become a route to reach areas where security makes access impossible.
  • The UN says it will hold a core presence in Ukraine for as long as physically possible, accepting risks it calls responsible rather than reckless.

In Ukraine, as winter approaches and attacks on civilians and power grids grow more frequent, the United Nations' humanitarian coordinator, Matthias Schmale, describes a work defined by nearness to suffering and the risk that nearness brings. Aid is carried largely by Ukrainian staff and volunteers, who bear the heaviest danger as they move people out of harm's way and bring supplies toward the front. Schmale's reflections place this moment within a long human pattern: the stubborn attachment of people to home, and the old principle that even war has rules. The question that remains open is how far a responsible presence can be sustained, and at what point the cost to those who carry the work becomes too great.

In a bunker office in Kherson, a small group of aid workers, some from modest volunteer networks, sits down to plan how to help people who have chosen to remain near the frontline. For Matthias Schmale, the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine, this scene and another one define the work: Ukrainian volunteers and staff pulling people out of dangerous areas, often with courage and even humour.

Schmale describes a conflict growing more dangerous and unpredictable. Russian attacks on civilians and energy infrastructure are intensifying ahead of winter, and strikes on power grids threaten heating, water and essential services. Still, he says, the UN will stay.

He insists that closeness to the people being helped is a necessity. Understanding needs requires being near people, speaking their language and knowing their customs. He has been surprised by how much evacuees care about their pets and farm animals, some refusing to leave without them, a sign of a bond to home and land they are not ready to surrender.

The hardest question, he admits, is who bears the danger. Most aid is delivered by national staff and volunteers, who face the greatest exposure. Schmale himself has run from drones during a visit to a bakery in Kherson. His response combines advocacy for international humanitarian law, practical protection tools, and a reluctant consideration of military channels as a last resort. He warns against heroics and says no one should be asked to risk their life beyond reason. The open questions remain which protections will be used and whether military routes will ever be accepted.

In a bunker office in Kherson, a handful of aid workers, some from very small volunteer-based groups, sit down to work out how to help people who have chosen to stay close to the frontline. That scene is one of two images that Matthias Schmale, the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine, says come to mind when he thinks about aid delivery in the country today.

The other is of Ukrainian volunteers and staff pulling people out of frontline areas at great risk to themselves. Schmale says they do it with dedication and a sense of humour. Between them, the two images sketch the work as he sees it: evacuations on one side, and on the other, getting essential supplies to the front and speaking up for people living in occupied areas.

He describes the conflict as increasingly dangerous and unpredictable. Russian attacks on civilians and on energy infrastructure are intensifying ahead of winter, he says. Strikes on power grids threaten heating, water supplies and essential services, deepening a humanitarian crisis that was already severe. Even so, he says the UN will stay and keep supporting Ukrainians.

Schmale argues that closeness to the people being helped is not a courtesy but a requirement. You cannot understand people's needs and aspirations, he says, if you are not near them, do not speak their language and do not understand their customs. His own example surprised him: how much pets and larger farm animals matter to evacuees. Some people refuse to leave if their dog or cat cannot come along. He has come to read this as a tie to home and to land that they are unwilling to give up.

The harder question is who carries the risk. Most humanitarian aid, Schmale notes, is delivered by staff and volunteers of national organisations, and they are the most exposed. He has had a taste of it himself, as have other UN and international colleagues: during a visit to a bakery in Kherson, his group had to run from drones. In a country at war, he says, you cannot work without risk. The issue is how to do it responsibly, and how to deliver aid without simply passing that danger on to implementing partners.

His answer has several parts. One is continued advocacy for adherence to international humanitarian law; wars, he says, have rules. Another is looking at practical tools for keeping people safe, such as drone detection and drone-scrambling equipment. A third is what he calls measures or channels of last resort, including the military.

He recalls a conversation with a governor about an area the UN could not reach for security reasons, despite huge needs there. When Schmale asked how aid could get in, the governor answered spontaneously: give it to the military. Schmale calls that, understatedly, sensitive.

He is wary of heroics. Aid organisations, he says, should not inappropriately play the hero, and should not expect anyone to be one when the risk to their life is too great. As head of the UN in Ukraine, he says he and other leaders are determined to keep a core presence for as long as that is physically possible, taking risks he describes as responsible rather than stupid. The open questions are which protective tools will be used and whether military channels will ever be accepted as a route for aid.

We are not taking stupid but responsible risks.
— Matthias Schmale, UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator in Ukraine
We shouldn't expect anyone to be the hero if we know the risk to their life is too big.
— Matthias Schmale
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei UN News ↗
Kontakt FAQ