In the Strait of Hormuz — the narrow passage through which a fifth of the world's energy flows — an oil tanker has burned, two sailors have vanished, and the competing accounts of Iran and the United States reveal something older than any single incident: the way great powers shape reality itself to serve their aims. The El Gaia's fate is both a maritime emergency and a parable about contested truth in a waterway that has become, since late February, a slow-motion theater of war. Twenty-two seafarers have already died across 79 confirmed incidents; the two missing men from the El Gaia are the
Two sailors missing after tanker attacked in Strait of Hormuz amid Iran-US tensions
Two sailors missing from El Gaia attack; at least 22 seafarers killed in 79 confirmed incidents in the Strait of Hormuz and Middle East since late February.
Two missing sailors, 22 dead, and a waterway effectively closed
Mark
So we have two missing sailors and a tanker on fire. But the real story seems to be that nobody agrees on what actually happened.
Mimi
Exactly. Iran says mines, the US says missiles and drones. And the UK says an unknown projectile. Those are three completely different narratives of the same event.
Luke
But here's what we know for certain: the El Gaia caught fire, 23 people were rescued, 2 are missing, and it happened 1.3 nautical miles north of Musandam. Everything else is attribution.
Mark
Why does Iran keep saying mines when the US keeps saying missiles?
Mimi
It matters politically. If Iran admits to attacking ships with missiles and drones, it's an act of war. If ships hit mines, it's almost like an accident—a hazard of the route.
Luke
Though we should note: the UK report says an unknown projectile struck the vessel. That's not confirmation of either side's story. It's just saying something hit it.
Mark
And this has happened before with the Sidr tanker?
Mimi
Yes, same pattern. Two Filipino sailors died. Iran claimed mines again. Saudi Arabia and maritime firms said projectiles.
Mark
So is this a deliberate Iranian strategy, or is the US misinterpreting what's actually happening?
Luke
We can't say. What we can say is that 22 seafarers have been confirmed dead in 79 incidents since late February. That's the solid number from the International Maritime Organization.
Mimi
And the strait is effectively closed now. A fifth of global oil and gas normally moves through there.
Mark
Because of the attacks and the US blockade?
Mimi
Both. Iran won't give up control of the waterway, so they're targeting ships using the southern route through Omani waters to avoid Iranian waters.
Luke
One more thing: on the same day, the US says it destroyed two Iranian fishing boats that tried to steal an American drone. Iran says US drones attacked fishing boats and fishermen are missing.
Mark
So we don't even know what happened in that incident either.
Luke
No. We know the US destroyed two boats. We know Iran reported missing fishermen. The rest is interpretation.
Le Pouls
- The Panama-flagged El Gaia caught fire near the Musandam peninsula after being struck under disputed circumstances, leaving 23 crew rescued and 2 sailors unaccounted for.
- Iran insists the tanker drifted into naval mines; the US military says it was hit by an Iranian missile last month and a drone over the weekend — a clash of narratives that is itself a weapon.
- The same pattern played out weeks earlier when two Filipino sailors died aboard the supertanker Sidr, with each side again offering irreconcilable accounts of mines versus missiles.
- A June ceasefire agreement that briefly promised to reopen the strait collapsed within weeks, and the waterway — carrying roughly a fifth of global oil and gas — remains effectively closed.
- On the same day as the El Gaia attack, Iranian fishing boats were destroyed near Kargan, with Tehran calling it a drone strike and US Central Command describing it as a response to an attempted seizure of an American vessel.
- With 22 seafarers killed across 79 incidents since late February and no resolution in sight, the human cost of this standoff continues to compound in the silence between competing press releases.
In the Strait of Hormuz — the narrow passage through which a fifth of the world's energy flows — an oil tanker has burned, two sailors have vanished, and the competing accounts of Iran and the United States reveal something older than any single incident: the way great powers shape reality itself to serve their aims. The El Gaia's fate is both a maritime emergency and a parable about contested truth in a waterway that has become, since late February, a slow-motion theater of war. Twenty-two seafarers have already died across 79 confirmed incidents; the two missing men from the El Gaia are the latest names added to a ledger that neither side seems willing to close.
Two sailors are missing after the Panama-flagged oil tanker El Gaia caught fire in the Strait of Hormuz, struck 1.3 nautical miles north of the Musandam peninsula. Oman's Maritime Security Centre coordinated the rescue of 23 crew members before the vessel, under tow toward an Omani port, suffered an engine room fire. What caused the initial attack remains fiercely contested: Iran's Revolutionary Guards say the tanker hit naval mines in a restricted corridor; the US military says it was struck by an Iranian missile last month and a drone over the weekend; UK maritime authorities reported an unknown projectile in the early hours of Sunday.
The dispute is not incidental — it mirrors almost exactly what happened earlier in September, when two Filipino sailors died aboard the Saudi supertanker Sidr. Iran again cited mines; Western sources again described projectile strikes north of Musandam. The repetition of these opposing narratives points to something deliberate: each side is working to cast the other as the aggressor in a waterway that has become a proxy battleground.
The toll is accumulating quietly. Since late February, when US and Israeli military operations against Iran began, at least 22 seafarers have been killed across 79 confirmed incidents, according to the International Maritime Organization. On the same day the El Gaia burned, Iranian fishing boats near the port of Kargan were destroyed — Tehran called it an enemy drone attack; US Central Command said its forces had sunk the boats after Iranian vessels tried to seize an American unmanned surface vessel.
The Strait of Hormuz, normally the passage for roughly a fifth of the world's oil and gas, is effectively closed. A ceasefire reached in June collapsed within weeks as Iranian strikes resumed and the US reinstated its naval blockade. Iran has made clear it intends to retain leverage over the strait and has deliberately targeted ships using southern Omani waters — a detour meant to bypass Iranian-preferred lanes. The two missing sailors from the El Gaia are the latest human measure of a standoff with no resolution in sight.
Two sailors have vanished in the Strait of Hormuz after an oil tanker caught fire under contested circumstances, adding to a mounting toll of maritime casualties in one of the world's most critical shipping lanes. The Panama-flagged El Gaia was struck 1.3 nautical miles north of the Musandam peninsula, according to Oman's Maritime Security Centre, which coordinated the rescue of 23 crew members on Tuesday. The vessel was being towed to an Omani port when the fire broke out in its engine room.
What caused the attack remains a matter of sharp dispute between Tehran and Washington. Iran's Revolutionary Guards claimed the tanker hit naval mines while traversing what they characterized as a restricted and unsafe corridor. The US military flatly rejected this account, stating instead that the El Gaia was struck by an Iranian missile in the previous month and then targeted again by a drone over the weekend. The UK Maritime Trade Operations centre offered a third version, reporting that an unknown projectile had struck the vessel in the early hours of Sunday as it transited the strait.
This latest incident follows a nearly identical pattern from earlier in September, when two Filipino sailors died aboard the Saudi-owned supertanker Sidr. Iran's Revolutionary Guards again attributed the fire to a naval mine strike. Saudi authorities and maritime security firms countered that the vessel had been hit by projectiles north of Musandam. The consistency of these conflicting narratives—Iran invoking mines, Western sources describing missile and drone attacks—suggests a deliberate strategy by each side to frame the other as the aggressor in a waterway that has become a proxy battleground.
The human cost has been severe. Since late February, when the US and Israel began military operations against Iran, at least 22 seafarers have been killed across 79 confirmed incidents in the Strait of Hormuz and surrounding waters, according to the International Maritime Organization. The two missing sailors from the El Gaia represent the latest addition to this grim accounting.
On the same day as the El Gaia attack, Iran's semi-official Fars news agency reported that "enemy drones" had targeted two fishing boats near the Iranian port of Kargan, roughly 50 miles northeast of Musandam. The deputy governor of Hormozgan province said several fishermen were reported missing and that search-and-rescue efforts were underway. The US military's Central Command later offered its own explanation: Iranian small boats had attempted to seize an American unmanned surface vessel, and Centcom forces had destroyed the two boats in response, according to Captain Tim Hawkins.
The Strait of Hormuz, through which roughly a fifth of the world's oil and gas normally flows, has been effectively closed by the escalating violence. Iranian missile and drone strikes on commercial shipping, combined with a US naval blockade of Iranian ports, have choked off transit. A preliminary agreement reached in June to end hostilities and reopen the waterway collapsed within weeks after Iranian attacks on shipping resumed and the US reinstated its blockade. Iran has made clear it will not relinquish some degree of control over the strait and has deliberately targeted vessels using a southern route through Omani waters—a detour designed to avoid Iranian-preferred shipping lanes. The missing sailors and the mounting death toll reflect the cost of this standoff, one with no clear resolution in sight.
Citations marquantes
Iranian small boats recently attempted to take possession of a US unmanned surface vessel, but they were unsuccessful after Centcom forcefully responded.— Captain Tim Hawkins, US military's Central Command
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur BBC News ↗
War & Conflict