Thirty years after Tupac Shakur was shot dead on a Las Vegas street, a courtroom is attempting what time and silence have long resisted: a reckoning with the night of September 7, 1994. On the trial's second day, medical testimony confirmed what the world already knew, while a reluctant witness from Death Row Records' inner circle reminded the jury that some truths are still guarded by old codes of loyalty and fear. The case turns on a question as old as violence itself — whether one man acted alone, or whether he was carried by something larger and darker than himself.
Tupac murder trial: Suge Knight associate testifies as 'hostile witness' amid gang tensions
Tupac Shakur was fatally shot in 1994; multiple people were injured in subsequent gang violence in Compton; Orlando Anderson, whose beating preceded the shooting, died in 1998.
It wasn't really our beef. This was between Suge Knight and Keefe D.
Mark
Why did McDonald keep saying he didn't want to answer questions? He was already on the stand.
Mimi
Because answering certain questions would have forced him to name names and describe who was hunting whom in Compton after the shooting. That's not abstract history—that's identifying people who might still be alive, still in those neighborhoods. He was protecting people, maybe himself.
Mark
But he's testifying in a murder trial. Doesn't he have to answer?
Mimi
Legally, yes. But there's a difference between what the law requires and what a person will actually do when they're sitting there under oath. He made his choice: be hostile, refuse, accept the consequences. He'd rather face contempt than open that door.
Mark
What did he mean when he said the shooting was "between Suge Knight and Keefe D"?
Mimi
That it wasn't random gang violence. That it was personal, rooted in a specific conflict between two men. Everything else—the beating of Orlando Anderson, the retaliation, the gang war in Compton—that was all fallout from something between those two.
Mark
So why does McDonald keep insisting Reggie Wright Jr. had nothing to do with it?
Mimi
Because Wright was there that night, and McDonald knew him. If Wright had been involved, McDonald would have seen something. And logically, it made no sense—Tupac was Death Row's money. Killing him would have destroyed the label. Wright would have had everything to lose.
Mark
McDonald said he'd have killed Tupac if Tupac had hit him. Does that make him a suspect?
Mimi
No. He wasn't there when the shooting happened. He was at the club. But it tells you something about the world he lived in then—a world where a punch meant you had to kill someone or go home and face being called a coward. That's the pressure that shaped everyone involved.
Mark
What's the jury supposed to do with a hostile witness?
Mimi
Decide what parts of his testimony ring true and what parts he's protecting. He confirmed Wright was at the club when they heard about the shooting. He confirmed the gang war happened. He just won't say who did what. The jury has to work with that silence.
Le Pouls
- A medical examiner's autopsy photographs were so graphic that some of Shakur's relatives walked out of the courtroom rather than face them.
- James McDonald, a former Death Row Records security chief, declared himself a hostile witness before a single question was asked, signaling that the trial's pursuit of truth would meet organized resistance from those who lived it.
- McDonald admitted without hesitation that he would have killed Shakur himself under different circumstances — a statement that laid bare the lethal world the jury is being asked to judge.
- When pressed on the gang war that erupted in Compton after the shooting, McDonald refused to elaborate, saying only that people were being hurt and hunted — including the defendant and his nephew.
- The competing narratives sharpening at trial ask whether Duane 'Keefe D' Davis was a lone actor or a soldier in a conflict that swallowed entire communities, with the defense and prosecution each pulling the evidence toward their own answer.
Thirty years after Tupac Shakur was shot dead on a Las Vegas street, a courtroom is attempting what time and silence have long resisted: a reckoning with the night of September 7, 1994. On the trial's second day, medical testimony confirmed what the world already knew, while a reluctant witness from Death Row Records' inner circle reminded the jury that some truths are still guarded by old codes of loyalty and fear. The case turns on a question as old as violence itself — whether one man acted alone, or whether he was carried by something larger and darker than himself.
The second day of the Tupac Shakur murder trial moved between clinical procedure and barely contained tension. A medical examiner confirmed what has been known for three decades — that Shakur died from gunshot wounds — while presenting autopsy photographs so difficult to view that some of his relatives left the courtroom entirely. Former Las Vegas detective Dean O'Kelley described arriving at the scene that September night in 1994, finding shell casings in the street, and placing traffic cones around them one by one — the quiet, methodical work of trying to preserve evidence before the darkness swallowed it.
The day's most charged testimony came from James McDonald, a 61-year-old former associate of Death Row Records founder Suge Knight. McDonald had overseen security at Knight's Las Vegas club the night Shakur was shot, and he made his position clear before questioning even began: he would not cooperate fully. He acknowledged commanding thirty to forty security personnel that evening, separate from the Death Row team, but refused to discuss the gang violence that tore through Compton in the shooting's aftermath. "Me or anybody else bringing up the dead is wrong," he said.
McDonald presented as a man suspended between who he had been and who he was trying to become — raising grandchildren now, he said, and steering them away from his former life. Yet the old self surfaced without apology. Asked hypothetically whether he would have killed Shakur if struck by him, McDonald answered immediately: "I'd have killed him. Him, Suge, and my brother, I'd have shot all three of them if he touched me. That's how I was living."
Also testifying was Reggie Wright Jr., former head of Death Row Records security and a onetime Compton police officer who had grown up two blocks from Suge Knight in Mob Piru gang territory. Wright said he had heard of defendant Duane "Keefe D" Davis during his time on the force but had never known him personally. McDonald, for his part, dismissed the theory that Wright had orchestrated Shakur's murder — Tupac was the label's financial lifeline, he reasoned, and betraying Knight in that way would have brought consequences Knight would never have stayed silent about.
When the defense pressed McDonald on the altercation between Shakur and Davis's nephew Orlando Anderson at the MGM Hotel earlier that evening — the incident prosecutors say ignited the shooting — McDonald refused to elaborate. He acknowledged that Anderson and Davis had both been targeted in the violence that followed, but would go no further. Glancing toward the defendant, he offered one concession: "I don't want to send him to prison, even though we don't like each other." Davis sat expressionless. The trial continues, with both sides working to answer whether he acted alone or as part of something that was already in motion long before that night.
The second day of testimony in the Tupac Shakur murder trial unfolded with the kind of friction that comes when the past refuses to stay buried. A medical examiner walked the jury through autopsy photographs and confirmed what had been known for three decades: Shakur died from gunshot wounds. Some of his relatives left the courtroom rather than look at the images. Others simply turned away.
Former Las Vegas detective Dean O'Kelley described arriving at the scene on the night of September 7, 1994, finding shell casings scattered across the street, and methodically placing traffic cones around them to preserve the crime scene until investigators could take over. It was the kind of procedural detail that anchors a story in time and place—the small, deliberate work of trying to hold onto evidence before the night consumed it entirely.
But the day's real tension came from James McDonald, a 61-year-old former associate of Death Row Records founder Suge Knight, who took the stand with visible reluctance. McDonald had been working security at Club 662, Knight's Las Vegas establishment, on the night Shakur was shot. He made clear from the outset that he would not cooperate fully. "I told every attorney that tried to get me in here, you'd better treat me as a hostile witness," he announced to the court. He was willing to offer some details—he had roughly thirty to forty security personnel working under him that night, separate from the Death Row Records security team—but when pressed on the gang tensions that erupted in Compton after the shooting, he refused to elaborate. "Me or anybody else bringing up the dead is wrong," he said.
McDonald's testimony revealed a man caught between two worlds. He was older now, he explained, raising grandchildren and trying to teach them not to follow his path. "I changed my life," he said. "I'm not proud of that, I'm not proud of that at all." Yet he was also a man who had lived by a code that demanded violent response to disrespect. When prosecutor Binu Palal asked hypothetically whether McDonald would have killed Shakur if the rapper had struck him, McDonald didn't hesitate. "I'd have killed him," he testified. "I'm being honest with you and everybody else. I said it on my podcast show. Him, Suge, and my brother, I'd have shot all three of them if he touched me. That's how I was living."
Reggie Wright Jr., the former head of security for Death Row Records, also testified. Like his father before him, Wright had been a Compton police officer. He had taken medical retirement in 1996 and had grown up with Suge Knight, living just two blocks away in what was considered Mob Piru gang territory. Wright said he had heard of Duane "Keefe D" Davis during his time as a police officer but did not know him personally. Davis, he testified, had been known variously as a crackhead and later as a drug dealer, but Wright had not enforced against him at the narcotics level.
When the defense attorney for Duane Davis—the man on trial for Shakur's murder—began cross-examining McDonald, the witness grew visibly agitated. He refused to detail what had happened between Shakur and Davis's nephew, Orlando Anderson, at the MGM Hotel earlier that evening, an altercation that prosecutors argue triggered the shooting. McDonald would only say that when he and others returned to Compton after the shooting, "it was a gang war. People were getting hurt. People were being sought." He acknowledged that Orlando Anderson and Davis himself were among those being hunted, but he would not say more. "I don't want to send him to prison, even though we don't like each other," McDonald said, apparently gesturing toward Davis, who sat in the courtroom with a grim expression and no visible reaction.
McDonald did offer one clear statement: it was "impossible" that Reggie Wright Jr. had coordinated Shakur's murder. If Wright had killed Tupac, McDonald reasoned, Death Row Records would have collapsed—Tupac was the label's financial engine. And if Wright had betrayed Suge Knight in such a way, Knight would have said something by now. "People say what they want to say," McDonald concluded. The trial continues to build competing narratives around whether Davis acted alone or as part of the broader gang conflict that consumed Compton in the weeks after Shakur's death.
Citations marquantes
I told every attorney that tried to get me in here, you'd better treat me as a hostile witness.— James McDonald, Death Row Records associate
It wasn't really our beef. This was between Suge Knight and Keefe D.— James McDonald
Impossible that Reggie Wright Jr. was involved in Shakur's killing, because if he had killed Tupac, Death Row would have collapsed and Suge Knight would have said something.— James McDonald
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur The Guardian ↗
Crime & Justice