For 106 years, a modest stretch of Washington waterfront has offered something quietly democratic: a place where anyone could play golf for the price of a lunch. Now President Trump, who has spent a career building luxury venues, has set his sights on East Potomac Golf Links, calling it 'Trash Island' and announcing plans to remake it into a world-class tournament course. The collision between that ambition and the community that has long called the course home has moved from social media into federal court, where a judge has paused the project and forced a reckoning over how much authority a
Trump's 'Trash Island' Golf Course Overhaul Faces Legal Battle Over DC Public Access
There's no place in the whole DMV you can play 18 holes for that price
Mark
Why does a golf course renovation become a federal case? It's just a course that needs work, right?
Mimi
Because it's not just a golf course. It's one of three public courses in DC, and it's genuinely affordable. A regular person can play there. If Trump closes it for 15 months and then reopens it as a tournament venue, the economics change completely. Private clubs and championship courses don't operate on $29 rounds.
Luke
But we should be careful here. Trump says the seawall is collapsing and the trees are diseased. Are those claims verified, or is that just his characterization? The source doesn't say an independent inspector confirmed those conditions.
Mimi
Fair point. What we know is that Trump made those claims. What we don't know is whether they're accurate or exaggerated. The golfers who play there regularly say it's fine, but they're not structural engineers either.
Mark
So the lawsuit is really about access and affordability, not about whether the course needs work?
Mimi
It's about both. The preservationists and golfers are saying: yes, maybe it needs maintenance, but not a complete overhaul that transforms it into something only wealthy people can access. They're fighting for the course to stay what it is.
Luke
And the judge has already stopped the work. Trump announced the closure and the redesign, but there's a court order in place. So nothing is actually happening right now.
Mark
What happens on October 26?
Mimi
That's when the court order expires. The judge will have to decide whether to extend it or let Trump proceed. That's where the real battle will be fought.
Luke
One more thing: Trump called it "Trash Island." That's inflammatory language. But does the source material actually support that the course is in terrible condition, or is that just Trump's opinion?
Mimi
It's his opinion. The golfers who use it regularly don't describe it that way. Snow said it could use a facelift, but he didn't say it's falling apart. So we're in a situation where the president has one view and the community has another, and the courts have to decide who's right.
Le Pouls
- Trump announced a 15-month closure and full renovation of East Potomac Golf Links, describing the beloved public course as 'old, broken, dilapidated, and of no further use or effect.'
- Regular golfers who pay as little as $29 for 18 holes fear the transformation will permanently price them out, replacing an accessible community anchor with an elite tournament venue.
- The DC Preservation League and two local golfers filed suit to block the project, and tensions spiked when the government began large-scale tree removal without alerting the court or plaintiffs.
- A federal judge responded by ordering all redevelopment work halted until at least October 26, putting the White House's plans in legal limbo.
- The case now sits at the intersection of presidential authority and public trust, with courts tasked with deciding who ultimately controls a shared space in the nation's capital.
For 106 years, a modest stretch of Washington waterfront has offered something quietly democratic: a place where anyone could play golf for the price of a lunch. Now President Trump, who has spent a career building luxury venues, has set his sights on East Potomac Golf Links, calling it 'Trash Island' and announcing plans to remake it into a world-class tournament course. The collision between that ambition and the community that has long called the course home has moved from social media into federal court, where a judge has paused the project and forced a reckoning over how much authority a president holds over a public landmark.
Two miles south of the White House, on a waterfront strip that has welcomed golfers for over a century, a fight is unfolding over who gets to decide what a public space is for. East Potomac Golf Links is one of three National Park Service courses in Washington — modest in its facilities, democratic in its pricing. A 70-year-old regular named Thomas Snow pays $29 for 18 holes and knows there is nowhere else in the metro area that offers the same. Jourdain Yardan plays there twice a week and values it precisely because it asks nothing of him beyond showing up.
President Trump sees the same ground differently. On a Sunday evening post to Truth Social, he called the course 'Trash Island' and announced plans to close it for 15 months, redesigning it to championship standards capable of hosting world-class tournaments. The renovation fits within a broader White House ambition to reshape Washington's landmarks, but for the people who play East Potomac regularly, the scale of that vision is exactly what worries them.
Yardan put the fear plainly: big-league golf brings big-league prices. He worries that even a promised return to public access will mean a course that no longer belongs to the community that sustained it. Snow, who supports some improvements, called Trump's characterization of the course a gross overstatement. Neither man wants to lose what the place has quietly been — not a destination, but a habit, a ritual, a place where the game remains within reach.
The legal challenge arrived quickly. The DC Preservation League and two golfers filed suit, with Democracy Forward arguing the renovation would strip a community jewel from the people it serves. When the government began removing trees without notifying the court, a federal judge ordered all work stopped until at least October 26. The outcome will settle more than the fate of one golf course — it will draw a line around how far presidential authority extends over the public spaces a city shares.
Two miles south of the White House, on a strip of waterfront that has hosted golfers for 106 years, a conflict is taking shape that will test how much power a president holds over a public space. East Potomac Golf Links sits in the nation's capital as one of three public courses run by the National Park Service—a modest, accessible place where a 70-year-old can play 18 holes for $29 and a regular player can show up twice a week without needing membership or wealth. On Monday evening, President Donald Trump called it "Trash Island" on Truth Social. By Sunday, he had announced plans to close it for 15 months and transform it into what he described as "one of the Best and Most Spectacular Golf Courses anywhere in the World."
For Jourdain Yardan, who plays at East Potomac twice weekly, the course represents something increasingly rare in the Washington metropolitan area: a place where golf remains genuinely affordable. "Anyone from any walk of life, whether they're starting to play golf or whether they're a seasoned golfer, they can come out here and play golf at a pretty reasonable rate," he told the BBC while putting on the course. Thomas Snow, a 70-year-old regular, pays that $29 rate and knows the math well. "There's no place in the whole DMV that you can play a nice 18 holes for that price point," he said. The course offers food court-style dining, not white tablecloth restaurants. The facilities are modest. The experience is democratic.
Trump, who owns more than a dozen golf courses and has spent decades building luxury private venues, sees something different. In his Sunday post, he described the current course as "old, broken, dilapidated, and of no further use or effect." He cited falling trees, disease-infested growth, and a collapsing seawall. His vision would keep the course open to the public while redesigning it to championship standards, capable of hosting world-class tournaments. The renovation is part of a larger presidential effort to reshape Washington's landmarks—a new White House ballroom, a 250-foot arch, and other changes to longstanding sites. For Trump, the golf course is a smaller piece of that ambition. For the people who play there, it is something closer to a community anchor.
Snow, who is not part of any lawsuit, acknowledged the course could use improvement. But he called Trump's description "a gross overstatement." The legal challenge came from the DC Preservation League and two golfers who filed suit to stop the renovation. Democracy Forward, representing the plaintiffs, stated that the litigation was "intended to protect this community jewel for the people and communities it serves." The dispute escalated this month when the government began large-scale tree removal without notifying the court or the plaintiffs. A federal judge responded by ordering the Trump administration to halt redevelopment plans until at least October 26.
Yardan's worry cuts to the heart of what the lawsuit is really about. "Anytime you hear about big league, big golfers, that also includes big prices," he said. He fears that transformation into a tournament-capable venue will inevitably price out the people who sustain the course now. "The biggest thing that I like about this golf course is that it's affordable," he said. He also worried that clearing the landscape to rebuild it would strip away something less tangible but equally real. "You start to clear everything out and it just starts to become an empty plot of land that you just hit golf balls on; I think it gets rid of the culture of the golf course," he said. A temporary closure, even one promised to be temporary, would be a "huge dent" in DC culture.
The courts will now mediate between the White House's vision and the community's stake in what the space has been. The legal fight will test whether a president can unilaterally reshape a public landmark, even one he believes needs reshaping. The outcome will determine not just the future of East Potomac, but the boundaries of presidential authority over shared spaces in the nation's capital.
Citations marquantes
Anyone from any walk of life, whether they're starting to play golf or whether they're a seasoned golfer, they can come out here and play golf at a pretty reasonable rate.— Jourdain Yardan, 35-year-old regular golfer at East Potomac
There's no place in the whole DMV that you can play a nice 18 holes for that price point.— Thomas Snow, 70-year-old golfer
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur BBC News ↗
Politics & Governance