Trump, Xi and Putin Eye Influence as Asia Hosts Back-to-Back Summits on Trade, Tech and Security

The humanitarian and security crisis in Myanmar remains unresolved, and a pending ICJ judgment could find Myanmar responsible for genocide.
Symbolism itself matters in great-power diplomacy
Xiaoyu Pu on why a Trump-Xi-Putin meeting could matter even if it produces little.
Mark

Why does a trilateral meeting with Trump, Xi and Putin matter if analysts expect little from it?

Mimi

Because the image itself carries weight. Pu says it may be more symbolic than substantive, but he adds that symbolism matters in great-power diplomacy.

Luke

Worth noting that's one analyst's reading of each leader's aims. The piece doesn't report any agenda for the meeting, only that it's confirmed.

Mark

The Yalta comparison keeps coming up. Is that fair?

Mimi

Analysts say a Yalta 2.0 deciding Ukraine and Taiwan without them is unlikely. The comparison is more about optics than expectation.

Luke

Right, and the comparison is something others have made, not a claim about what will happen.

Mark

What are smaller Asian countries doing about the US?

Mimi

Menon says south-east Asian states are seeking deals with each other and the EU to depend less on the US, especially given tariffs.

Luke

That's his assessment. The article doesn't list specific new agreements.

Mark

And Myanmar?

Mimi

The ICJ could find it responsible for genocide on Thursday, while Min Aung Hlaing stays barred from Asean but can send a representative.

Luke

'Could' is the key word. The ruling hasn't come, and we don't know how Asean members will respond.

  • A possible three-way meeting of Trump, Xi and Putin hangs over the Apec summit in Shenzhen, raising fears of a Yalta-style carving up of Ukraine and Taiwan.
  • Trump arrives weaker after midterm losses, while a Nvidia scandal involving an alleged Chinese spy adds an awkward shadow to the trip.
  • Southeast Asian nations scramble to diversify away from US tariffs, seeking deals with each other and with the EU.
  • South China Sea tensions flare as Beijing's outposts and Wang Yi's accusations against Manila sharpen the standoff, with no pact expected soon.
  • Myanmar's reintegration debate collides with a pending ICJ genocide judgment due Thursday, leaving the region divided over how to treat its isolated neighbour.

In the cold season of a changing order, Asia becomes the stage where the old contest between a rising China and an anxious America plays out in a sequence of gatherings: a trade forum in Shenzhen, a regional bloc in Manila, a francophone meeting in Cambodia. The leaders arrive carrying the weight of unfinished wars, disputed waters, and fraying economic bonds, yet the most anticipated encounter, a possible meeting of Trump, Xi and Putin, is widely expected to offer more theatre than treaty. It is a reminder that in great-power politics, the photograph can matter as much as the promise, and that smaller nations, watching closely, are quietly hedging their futures.

Asia is hosting a run of back-to-back summits this week, and each one carries the shadow of the rivalry between China and the United States. The centrepiece is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting opening Wednesday in Shenzhen, China's technology hub. Donald Trump arrives just two weeks after losing midterm elections, and his trip is complicated by a reported affair between the head of Nvidia and a woman US intelligence suspects of being a Chinese spy.

The moment most watched is a confirmed three-way meeting between Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. Some have compared it to Yalta in 1945, when great powers divided postwar Europe without the nations most affected. Analysts doubt anything so sweeping will happen on Ukraine or Taiwan. Xiaoyu Pu of the University of Nevada suggests the meeting may be more symbolic than substantive, though in great-power diplomacy symbols carry real weight.

The gatherings continue in Manila, where the Association of Southeast Asian Nations summit begins Sunday, and where Trump will attend alongside a Quad sideline meeting. A Francophone summit in Cambodia runs alongside them. Across these meetings, the agenda ranges from AI supply chains and tariffs to the green transition, while the South China Sea and a choking haze from Indonesian forest fires press on the region.

Southeast Asian states, wary of Washington's volatility and tariffs, are quietly building ties elsewhere. Analysts argue that deeper integration and diversification are the region's best protection. Beijing, meanwhile, faces tough talks over the disputed waters, where Wang Yi has accused Filipino politicians of smearing China. No South China Sea pact is expected this year.

Myanmar's reintegration is also on the table, even as the International Court of Justice prepares a judgment on Thursday that could find the country responsible for genocide. The diplomacy will continue next month at the G20 in Miami, where Xi is expected to attend if relations remain steady.

Asia becomes the stage for world politics this week, as leaders travel to a run of back-to-back summits shaped by the contest for influence between China and the United States.

The centrepiece is the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec) leaders' meeting, which opens on Wednesday in Shenzhen, China's southern technology hub. Beijing hosts, and Donald Trump arrives two weeks after losing midterm elections. The trip also follows an awkward revelation: the head of Nvidia, the US chipmaker that was long the world's most valuable company, was reported to be having an affair with a woman US intelligence suspects was a Chinese spy. Apec members account for more than 60% of global GDP, and the forum has mainly promoted free trade and multilateralism.

This year's meeting may be defined by something else: a confirmed three-way meeting between Trump, Chinese president Xi Jinping and Russia's Vladimir Putin. Some have likened it to Yalta, where in 1945 Franklin D Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin met in Crimea to carve up postwar Europe. Analysts say a 'Yalta 2.0' that issues edicts on Ukraine and Taiwan without their involvement is unlikely. Xiaoyu Pu, an associate professor of political science at the University of Nevada, said the meeting might be more symbolic than substantive, though symbolism matters in great-power diplomacy. In his reading, Trump appears interested in nuclear arms control and denuclearisation, Xi wants a stable relationship with Washington while keeping China's strategic partnership with Russia, and Putin wants to preserve his bargaining leverage over Ukraine.

Apec follows the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) summit in the Philippines, which starts on Sunday and which Trump will attend. While he is in Manila, US officials will hold a sidelines meeting of the Quad: Australia, India, Japan and the US. Meanwhile a Francophone summit is under way in Cambodia, with Canadian prime minister Mark Carney and French president Emmanuel Macron among those attending. Across the gatherings, the agenda includes AI supply chains and governance, tariff reductions and the green energy transition. Regional concerns include the South China Sea, where Beijing has built large military outposts in disputed waters, and an enormous haze from Indonesian forest fires blanketing the region. Myanmar's crisis and the status of Taiwan, which China does not recognise, are perennial issues. Taiwan is sending the founder of hardware company Acer as its envoy to Apec.

Washington's attention to the region has long been coloured by China's rise. In 2011 Barack Obama told Australia's parliament the US was 'a Pacific power, and we are here to stay', launching the 'pivot to Asia'. Joe Biden continued it with intense diplomacy and trade deals, hoping to gather allies who wanted to balance ties with both superpowers. Some analysts see Trump's transactional style as a continuation. Yet his volatility has unsettled smaller nations, which regard China as the more predictable partner.

Jayant Menon, an economist at Singapore's Iseas-Yusof Ishak Institute, says south-east Asian countries have been laying groundwork for reduced dependence on the US by seeking deals elsewhere, including with each other and the EU. Writing this month in the East Asia Forum, he argued that with an administration determined to levy tariffs by any legal means, the region's ability to withstand another round depends on deeper integration and diversification beyond the US market.

Predictability does not make Beijing welcome. Chinese premier Li Qiang could face tough talks in Manila, especially over the South China Sea. Foreign minister Wang Yi recently urged Manila to rein in Filipino politicians he said had repeatedly 'smeared' Beijing, after public outcry over the disputed waters. Brunei, China, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan and Vietnam have long-running territorial standoffs there, over a busy waterway that may hold oil and gas. Washington has sent ships on freedom of navigation operations, though crises involving Iran, Ukraine, Venezuela, and Israel and Palestine have absorbed its focus in Trump's second term. A long-sought South China Sea pact is not expected at this summit; talks continue next year when Asean's chair passes to Singapore.

Myanmar, which is seeking reintegration, is also on the agenda, and each member is weighing how to handle its isolated neighbour. On Thursday the International Court of Justice is due to issue a judgment that could find Myanmar responsible for genocide. Coup leader Min Aung Hlaing remains barred from Asean but may send a representative.

The diplomacy continues next month at the G20 in Miami, Florida, which Xi is expected to attend if US-China relations stay steady.

A three-way meeting might be more symbolic than substantive, although symbolism itself matters in great-power diplomacy.
— Xiaoyu Pu, University of Nevada
South-east Asian countries have been laying the groundwork for a future with reduced dependence on the United States.
— Jayant Menon, Iseas-Yusof Ishak Institute
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei The Guardian ↗
Kontakt FAQ