On a Thursday in late October, the American president said that Starshield, the military version of Musk's satellite network, was back in Ukraine, crediting the tech billionaire with restoring it. The claim lands in a war where a few kilobits of connection can decide whether a drone flies or falls silent, and where the hand that turned the dial remains unnamed. Whether the restoration is real, and who truly pulled the lever, is still waiting for an answer that Kyiv has not yet been given.
Trump Says Musk Restored Starshield in Ukraine as Questions Over Who Ordered the Cap Remain
"The bottom line," Trump said, was that Musk "put it back."
Mark
Trump says Starshield is back in Ukraine. Is that settled?
Mimi
Not entirely. He said Musk put it back, but Kyiv hasn't confirmed the throttling was lifted.
Luke
Right, so the only source for restoration is Trump himself. That's a claim, not a verified fact yet.
Mark
And what did the throttling actually do?
Mimi
According to the Wall Street Journal, the speed cap made some offensive and interceptor drones virtually useless.
Luke
Worth noting that's the Journal's report, citing two unnamed sources. We don't have Ukrainian officials quantifying the damage here.
Mark
Who ordered the cap?
Mimi
That's the unsolved part. Musk says the US military and ultimately the president decided. Trump and Hegseth say the Pentagon directed no changes.
Luke
And one anonymous source says Musk spoke with senior officials, including Trump, beforehand. That's attributed, not confirmed. The accounts flatly conflict.
Mark
What does Ukraine say?
Mimi
A senior European official told AP that Kyiv has had no clear official explanation of who ordered it or why.
Luke
Which is itself a notable gap. Senator Blumenthal's inquiry may fill it, but nothing has come of it yet.
Le Pouls
- A speed cap on Starshield reportedly left Ukrainian offensive and interceptor drones nearly useless in the middle of a war.
- Musk blamed the US military and the president, while Trump and Hegseth flatly denied any Pentagon direction.
- Trump declared the service 'back' yet refused to say whether he had made the call that restored it.
- Kyiv has not confirmed the throttling was lifted, and no clear official explanation has reached Ukraine.
- Senator Blumenthal has opened an inquiry, and the chain of command behind the decision remains tangled.
On a Thursday in late October, the American president said that Starshield, the military version of Musk's satellite network, was back in Ukraine, crediting the tech billionaire with restoring it. The claim lands in a war where a few kilobits of connection can decide whether a drone flies or falls silent, and where the hand that turned the dial remains unnamed. Whether the restoration is real, and who truly pulled the lever, is still waiting for an answer that Kyiv has not yet been given.
On Thursday, Donald Trump told reporters that Starshield, the military-grade version of the Starlink network, was "back" in Ukraine. Asked whether he had personally called Elon Musk to restore it, he would not say. "The bottom line," he insisted, was that Musk "put it back."
The claim followed a Wall Street Journal report that Musk had capped the speeds at which Ukrainian hardware could stay connected. According to the paper, the limit left some offensive and interceptor drones virtually useless, tools Ukraine depends on both to strike Russian targets and to defend against attacks. Two unnamed sources told the Journal that Musk had discussed the decision with Trump and other senior officials before imposing it.
Musk pointed upward, saying the limits were decided by the US military and ultimately the president. Trump and then Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth denied that the Pentagon had directed any change. Ukraine, a senior European official told AP, has received no clear explanation of who ordered the cap or why.
The silence comes amid strained ties between Washington and Kyiv, after Trump called for Zelenskyy's replacement and Kyiv questioned American support. In Washington, Senator Richard Blumenthal has opened an inquiry. For now, the restoration rests on the president's word alone, and the open questions are whether Ukraine's connections are truly back at full speed and whether Musk, the Pentagon and the White House will ever tell a consistent story.
On Thursday, US President Donald Trump told journalists that Starshield, the military-grade version of the Starlink satellite network, is "back" in Ukraine. Asked whether he had been the one to call Elon Musk and get the service restored, he declined to say. Whether he called or somebody else did, he told reporters, made no difference. "The bottom line," he said, was that Musk "put it back."
The question came after a Wall Street Journal report that Trump had asked the tech billionaire to restore the service, which is vital to Ukraine's defense against Russia's invasion. Kyiv has not yet confirmed that the throttling has actually been lifted, so for now the claim rests on the American president's word alone.
The episode began earlier this week, when the Journal reported that Musk had capped the speeds at which Ukrainian hardware could stay connected to the satellite network. According to the paper, the cap rendered some offensive drones and interceptor drones virtually useless. Those are the tools Ukraine relies on to strike Russian targets and to defend against incoming attacks.
The Journal's account relied on two unnamed sources. They said Musk and Trump discussed the Starlink decision on a call soon after the slowdown became public. One of them went further, claiming that Musk spoke with several senior administration officials, Trump among them, before he imposed the speed cap.
Musk answered by pointing upward. He said that any limits on speed or usage of Starshield, which his company SpaceX operates, were "decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS." Washington rejected that. Trump and then Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth both said the Pentagon had not directed any changes.
So the central question remains unresolved: who ordered the cap, and why. A senior European official familiar with the matter told AP on Thursday that Ukraine has received no clear official explanation on either point.
The silence lands amid already strained relations between Washington and Kyiv. Trump recently called for Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to be replaced, after Zelenskyy criticized a US deal that allows more Russian diesel into global markets. Kyiv, for its part, has questioned Washington's support, pointing to intelligence sharing and to speculation that the White House may have ordered the Starshield restrictions.
In Washington, Democratic Senator Richard Blumenthal said on Thursday that he had opened an inquiry into the matter. What to watch next is simple: whether Ukraine confirms that its connections are back to full speed, and whether anyone in the chain, Musk, the Pentagon or the White House, gives a consistent account of who made the original call.
Citations marquantes
Any limits to speed or usage were decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS.— Elon Musk, as cited in the report
I guess the bottom line, he put it back.— Donald Trump, referring to Musk
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur Deutsche Welle ↗
War & Conflict