At a rally in South Carolina, Donald Trump declared the Strait of Hormuz — a narrow passage through which a third of the world's seaborne oil flows — to be American territory, a claim that stands in direct contradiction to international maritime law and the sovereign reality of the waterway's borders. Iran's deputy foreign minister rejected the assertion without hesitation, insisting the strait answers only to Tehran's authority. The declaration arrives not from a position of diplomatic strength, but from one of stalled negotiations, rising fuel costs, and a conflict with no visible resolution
Trump claims Strait of Hormuz is 'American territory' as Pentagon fires Stars & Stripes leaders
The strait opens only under Iran's authority, not America's
Mark
When Trump says he views the Strait of Hormuz as American territory, is he making a legal argument or a political one?
Mimi
It's almost entirely political. International maritime law is clear—the strait is international waters. What he's doing is staking a claim for domestic consumption, showing his base he's willing to say things no other president would say.
Mark
But doesn't that kind of rhetoric actually make the situation worse? If Iran hears the U.S. president claiming their waters, doesn't that harden their position?
Mimi
Absolutely. It removes any pretense of negotiation. When you declare ownership of something the other side controls, you're not opening a door—you're slamming one shut. Iran has already said the strait opens only under their authority. Trump's language makes it harder for either side to back down.
Mark
So why do it? What does he gain?
Mimi
In the short term, applause at a rally. His supporters like hearing him talk tough. But strategically, it's a sign of weakness. When diplomacy fails, you resort to bluster. The fact that he keeps saying it suggests the actual negotiations are going nowhere.
Mark
Is there any scenario where this works—where the rhetoric actually forces Iran to capitulate?
Mimi
Not realistically. Iran has shown it can absorb pressure. They've closed the strait before. They have leverage Trump doesn't have—they control the geography. Rhetoric alone won't change that calculus.
Mark
What about the global economy? Does this affect oil prices, shipping?
Mimi
It already is. The uncertainty alone drives up energy costs. If tensions escalate further, you could see real disruption to global trade. That's not abstract—it hits grocery stores and gas pumps in America.
Le Pouls
- Trump's claim that the Strait of Hormuz is 'American territory' defies a century of international maritime law and the basic geographic reality that Iran and Oman — not the United States — border the waterway.
- Iran's deputy foreign minister Gharibabadi fired back immediately, making clear that the strait will reopen only under Tehran's authority, not under pressure from presidential declarations.
- The standoff is not abstract: roughly one-third of the world's seaborne oil passes through the strait, and its continued closure is driving fuel prices to record highs with no diplomatic breakthrough in sight.
- Trump's escalating rhetoric — first in New York, then on social media, now in South Carolina — suggests a pattern of reaching for rhetorical dominance precisely because the actual conflict and peace talks remain unresolved.
- Global markets and shipping industries are watching with concrete alarm, as the gap between Trump's assertions and geopolitical reality widens with each rally and each unanswered negotiation.
At a rally in South Carolina, Donald Trump declared the Strait of Hormuz — a narrow passage through which a third of the world's seaborne oil flows — to be American territory, a claim that stands in direct contradiction to international maritime law and the sovereign reality of the waterway's borders. Iran's deputy foreign minister rejected the assertion without hesitation, insisting the strait answers only to Tehran's authority. The declaration arrives not from a position of diplomatic strength, but from one of stalled negotiations, rising fuel costs, and a conflict with no visible resolution — a moment when rhetoric fills the space that strategy has left empty. History has seen empires claim what geography and law do not grant them; the world now watches to see whether words alone can reshape a waterway that nations depend on for survival.
On a Friday night in South Carolina, Donald Trump told a rally crowd something that international law does not permit: that the Strait of Hormuz, one of the planet's most vital shipping corridors, belongs to the United States. "I view the strait of Hormuz as an American territory right now," he said. It was not the first time. Days earlier in New York he had promised to formally designate it a U.S. territory, and on social media he had already claimed America held "total control" over the waterway.
The strait — a narrow channel between Iran and Oman through which roughly a third of the world's seaborne oil travels — has been closed by Tehran, which is using the closure as leverage in peace negotiations that have produced nothing. Iran's deputy foreign minister Kazem Gharibabadi responded to Trump's latest claim without ambiguity: the strait would reopen only under Iran's authority, and presidential threats would not change that calculus.
The legal reality is straightforward. The Strait of Hormuz is international waters. No single nation holds sovereignty over it, and no declaration — however forceful — can alter that without the mechanisms of international law and the cooperation of the nations that actually border it. Trump's assertion is not a negotiating position so much as a statement of pure will, disconnected from the legal or practical means by which it could be realized.
What the rhetoric does reveal is the pressure bearing down on the administration: a war with Iran that grinds on, fuel costs climbing to record levels, and no diplomatic path clearly in view. Whether Trump intends to follow through on a formal territorial designation or whether the language is aimed primarily at his domestic base remains uncertain. What is not uncertain is the risk — escalating claims in an already destabilized region send a signal to Tehran that Washington sees dominance, not diplomacy, as its only remaining tool, and the global markets that depend on the strait's stability are left to absorb the consequences.
At a campaign rally in South Carolina on Friday night, Donald Trump made a sweeping territorial claim that cut against a century of international maritime law. Speaking to supporters gathered to back Darline Graham's Senate bid, he declared the Strait of Hormuz—one of the world's most critical shipping channels—to be American territory. "I view the strait of Hormuz as an American territory right now," he said flatly. "It's an American territory."
The statement was not new. Trump had signaled the same position days earlier during a speech in New York, where he said he would "pretty soon" designate the waterway a U.S. territory. On social media, he had already claimed the U.S. held "total control" over it, adding, "I think we will keep it." The rhetoric reflects a pattern of escalating language as his administration grapples with a grinding conflict with Iran, stalled peace negotiations, and gas prices climbing to record levels. The strait, a narrow passage between Iran and Oman through which roughly one-third of the world's seaborne oil flows, has become a flashpoint in the broader war. Tehran has refused to reopen it, using the closure as leverage in talks that show no signs of progress.
Iran's response came swiftly and unambiguous. Kazem Gharibabadi, the country's deputy foreign minister, rejected Trump's claims outright, saying Tehran would not be intimidated by presidential threats. The strait, Gharibabadi made clear, would open only under Iran's authority—not America's. The standoff underscores a fundamental gap between Trump's assertions and geopolitical reality. The Strait of Hormuz is international waters under no single nation's sovereignty. Iran and Oman border it; neither the United States nor any other power can simply declare it their own territory, regardless of military presence or political will.
The timing of Trump's remarks reveals the pressure his administration faces. With the Iran war dragging on, fuel costs rising, and no diplomatic breakthrough in sight, the president appears to be reaching for rhetorical dominance where diplomatic solutions have failed. His language has grown more grandiose and more detached from what international law permits. The claim that America "owns" the strait is not a negotiating position—it is a statement of pure assertion, untethered from the legal or practical mechanisms by which such a thing could occur.
What remains unclear is whether Trump intends to follow through on the designation he has promised, or whether the rhetoric serves primarily as domestic political theater—a way to project strength to his base while the actual conflict remains unresolved. Either way, the escalating language risks further inflaming tensions in a region already destabilized by war, and it signals to Iran that the Trump administration sees no path forward except through assertion of dominance. For global markets and shipping routes that depend on the strait's stability, the stakes are concrete and immediate.
Citations marquantes
I view the strait of Hormuz as an American territory right now. It's an American territory.— Donald Trump, at a South Carolina campaign rally
Tehran will not be intimidated by the president's threats, and the strait of Hormuz will only be opened under Iran's authority.— Kazem Gharibabadi, Iran's deputy foreign minister (paraphrased)
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur The Guardian ↗
Politics & Governance