In the rural reaches of Queensland's Whitsunday region, a cattle grazier named Darryl Young shot four of his neighbours at his property gate in 2022, killing three. A jury found him guilty on all counts, and the court responded with what is believed to be the longest sentence in Queensland's legal history — three life terms with a 40-year non-parole period. Now, within hours of that sentence being handed down, Young has lodged an appeal, asking the Court of Appeal to reconsider both the verdict and the punishment. The case sits at the intersection of rural isolation, lethal violence, and the o
Triple murderer Darryl Young appeals conviction in Queensland shooting case
Three neighbours killed and one shot and wounded in the shooting at Bogie cattle station in 2022.
Three life sentences with a 40-year non-parole period
Mark
So Young was convicted just last week, and he's already appealing. How quickly does that usually happen?
Mimi
In Queensland, you can lodge an appeal notice almost immediately after sentencing. It's a right, not a favour. The actual hearing date is a different matter—that takes time to schedule.
Luke
Right, and we should be clear: lodging an appeal doesn't mean the court thinks there's merit to it. It just means the process has begun. We don't know yet what his legal team will argue.
Mark
What could they possibly argue? A jury found him guilty. He shot four people.
Mimi
Appeals can challenge the conviction on grounds of law, evidence, or trial conduct. They can also argue the sentence is disproportionate, even if the conviction stands.
Luke
And that's important to note—those are two separate questions. The conviction and the sentence can be appealed independently. One could be upheld while the other is modified.
Mark
Is a 40-year non-parole period really the longest ever in Queensland?
Mimi
That's what the reporting says—Justice Johnstone's sentence is believed to be the longest. But "believed to be" is doing some work there. It's not definitively confirmed.
Luke
Exactly. It's a striking claim, but it's attributed to belief, not to a definitive record search. Someone would need to check Queensland's sentencing database to confirm that.
Mark
What happens now? Does the appeal automatically go to a hearing?
Mimi
No. The appeal is filed, but the Court of Appeal has to schedule it. That could take months. In the meantime, Young remains in custody.
Luke
And we should note: we don't know the grounds of appeal yet. The filing happened, but the legal arguments haven't been made public.
Le Pouls
- Three neighbours were killed and a fourth wounded at a cattle station gate in 2022 — a single afternoon of violence that shattered a rural community near Bogie in north Queensland.
- A four-week Townsville Supreme Court trial ended in guilty verdicts on all counts, with Justice Christopher Johnstone then imposing what is reportedly the most severe sentence ever handed down in Queensland's history.
- Young's legal team filed notice of appeal on the very morning of sentencing, signalling they intend to contest both the conviction itself and the unprecedented 40-year non-parole period.
- The grounds for appeal remain undisclosed, leaving open whether the challenge will target questions of law, the conduct of the trial, the sufficiency of evidence, or the proportionality of the sentence.
- No hearing date has been set, meaning the families of Mervyn Schwarz, Maree Schwarz, and Graham Tighe — and the surviving Ross Tighe — now face an uncertain wait before the legal process reaches any finality.
In the rural reaches of Queensland's Whitsunday region, a cattle grazier named Darryl Young shot four of his neighbours at his property gate in 2022, killing three. A jury found him guilty on all counts, and the court responded with what is believed to be the longest sentence in Queensland's legal history — three life terms with a 40-year non-parole period. Now, within hours of that sentence being handed down, Young has lodged an appeal, asking the Court of Appeal to reconsider both the verdict and the punishment. The case sits at the intersection of rural isolation, lethal violence, and the outer limits of how a justice system measures the weight of three lives taken.
Darryl Valroy Young, a 63-year-old Queensland grazier and coal miner, was found guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder following a four-week trial in Townsville's Supreme Court. The killings took place in 2022 at the gate of his cattle station near Bogie, in the Whitsunday region of north Queensland. On that afternoon, Young shot four of his neighbours. Mervyn Schwarz, 71, Maree Schwarz, 59, and her son Graham Tighe, 35, were all killed. Graham's brother Ross Tighe, 36, was shot but survived, escaping the property with a bullet wound.
Justice Christopher Johnstone sentenced Young to three concurrent life sentences with a 40-year non-parole period — a punishment believed to be without precedent in Queensland's legal history. The severity of the sentence reflected the court's assessment of the gravity of the crimes: three lives taken, a fourth person wounded, in a single act of rural violence.
Young's legal team moved immediately. On the same morning the sentence was handed down, they filed a notice of appeal with the Court of Appeal, challenging both the conviction and the length of the punishment. A Queensland Courts spokesperson confirmed the filing, though no hearing date has yet been scheduled. The specific grounds of appeal have not been made public, leaving open whether the challenge will focus on questions of law, the conduct of the trial, the evidence presented, or the proportionality of a sentence that has already entered the record books. The case now passes into the appellate system, where both the verdict and Queensland's most severe sentence will face fresh examination.
Darryl Valroy Young, 63, walked into the Court of Appeal this week with a single purpose: to overturn the verdict that a jury delivered against him just days earlier. The Queensland grazier and coal miner had been found guilty of three counts of murder and one attempted murder. Now, having received what is believed to be the longest sentence ever imposed in Queensland—three life sentences with a 40-year non-parole period—he is asking the court to reconsider.
The crimes took place in 2022 at the gate of Young's cattle station near Bogie, a rural pocket of the Whitsunday region in north Queensland. On that day, he shot four of his neighbours. Three did not survive. Mervyn Schwarz, 71, was killed. So were Maree Schwarz, 59, and her son Graham Tighe, 35. Graham's brother Ross Tighe, 36, was shot but managed to escape the property with a bullet wound.
A four-week trial in Townsville's Supreme Court laid out the details of what happened that afternoon. The jury deliberated and returned guilty verdicts on all counts. Justice Christopher Johnstone then handed down the sentence: three concurrent life sentences, with Young ineligible for parole for 40 years. The severity of that punishment—reportedly unprecedented in Queensland's legal history—underscored the gravity of what the court found Young had done.
But conviction and sentence are not the end of the process. Young's legal team filed notice of appeal on Monday morning, the same day he was sentenced. The appeal challenges both the conviction itself and the length of the punishment imposed. A Queensland Courts spokesperson confirmed the filing, though no date has yet been set for when the Court of Appeal will hear the case.
What grounds Young's legal team will argue remain unclear. Appeals in murder cases can turn on questions of law, the sufficiency of evidence, the conduct of the trial, or the appropriateness of the sentence given the circumstances. In a case this severe—with three lives taken and a fourth person wounded—the court will have significant material to examine. The appeal process will now move forward in the appellate system, where Young's conviction and the historic sentence will face fresh scrutiny.
Citations marquantes
Young lodged an appeal against his conviction and sentence this morning in the Court of Appeal— Queensland Courts spokesperson
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur ABC News & Headlines – Australian Broadcasting Corporation ↗
Crime & Justice