On a Saturday afternoon in north London, Manchester United were overwhelmed 6-1 by Tottenham, a defeat the Manchester Evening News places among the most painful in the club's Premier League history. Fernandes gave the visitors an early lead, but a side that had seemed in control quickly lost its shape, and the collapse of composure that followed tells a familiar story about how fragile a team's confidence can be. Against a backdrop of one of the most storied rivalries in English football, the afternoon raises the older question of whether a squad can recover its footing once the game has slipp
Tottenham thrash Man United 6-1 as Mourinho secures joint-worst Premier League-era defeat for United
United folded like cards
Six-one is a heavy scoreline. What does the paper say actually went wrong?
Mostly the defence and the speed of Tottenham's counter-attacks. Maguire, Shaw, Bailly and Wan-Bissaka are all marked down for errors, and Matic was taken off at half-time for lacking mobility.
And the red card?
Martial was sent off for reacting to Lamela when it was 2-1. The paper says United folded after that, and he is suspended for three league games.
Worth saying these are one paper's ratings. The 0 for Shaw and 1 for Maguire are opinions, not measurements.
Fair, but the scoreline is not an opinion.
Agreed. The 6-1 and the sending-off are facts. Calling it the joint-worst Premier League-era defeat is the paper's framing, and the piece doesn't say which other result it matches.
The verdict on Solskjaer is interesting. The selection is called logical, yet he is faulted for not reacting while Spurs ran riot.
That is a judgment about what he should have done. The piece doesn't say what he said or changed, so we don't know his side.
So what should a reader watch?
How United line up without Martial, and whether the defensive errors repeat.
Der Puls
- Bruno Fernandes opened the scoring, then United's lead dissolved as Tottenham poured forward at pace.
- Maguire, Shaw and Bailly were left chasing Son, Kane and Ndombele as the defence unravelled.
- Anthony Martial's red card at 2-1 turned a difficult afternoon into a rout, with United folding around him.
- Solskjaer's team selection was judged sound, but his in-game response now faces hard questions and a three-game Martial absence looms.
On a Saturday afternoon in north London, Manchester United were overwhelmed 6-1 by Tottenham, a defeat the Manchester Evening News places among the most painful in the club's Premier League history. Fernandes gave the visitors an early lead, but a side that had seemed in control quickly lost its shape, and the collapse of composure that followed tells a familiar story about how fragile a team's confidence can be. Against a backdrop of one of the most storied rivalries in English football, the afternoon raises the older question of whether a squad can recover its footing once the game has slipped away.
Manchester United went to Tottenham expecting a contest and left having lost 6-1, a result the Manchester Evening News calls one of the joint-worst defeats of the Premier League era for the club. Its player ratings, published the morning after, make bleak reading, with only Donny van de Beek reaching a 5 out of 10.
The afternoon opened brightly when Bruno Fernandes scored the first goal for United. Tottenham then took over. Fernandes gave up possession repeatedly and was taken off at half-time, rated a 3. The heaviest criticism fell on the defence. Harry Maguire, rated 1, struggled to keep pace with Son Heung-min, Harry Kane and Tanguy Ndombele, while Luke Shaw, rated 0, was said to have abandoned his position again and again.
The turning point came at 2-1, when Anthony Martial was sent off for reacting to Erik Lamela. United collapsed after that, and Martial now faces a three-match league suspension. Solskjaer, rated 2, was judged to have picked a logical team, but the paper argues he did little to respond once Tottenham began to run riot. With Martial out, the manager's in-game decisions are now under scrutiny.
Manchester United lost 6-1 to Tottenham, a scoreline the Manchester Evening News describes as the club's joint-worst defeat of the Premier League era. The paper's player ratings, published on the Monday morning after the match, make for hard reading: only one of United's players, Donny van de Beek, scored as high as a 5 out of 10.
The afternoon began with Bruno Fernandes scoring the opener for United. From there, in the paper's account, Tottenham took control. Fernandes ceded possession repeatedly, the ratings say, and Spurs were too quick-witted for him. He was substituted at half-time and given a 3.
The centre of the criticism falls on the defence. Harry Maguire is rated 1, described as the nadir of his United career, with haphazard defending and clumsy tackling, and too cumbersome to keep up with Son Heung-min, Harry Kane and Tanguy Ndombele. Luke Shaw gets a 0. The ratings say he abandoned his station time and again, that Tottenham scored a couple of goals down his side, and that he should have been sent off. Eric Bailly, back in the team after what the paper calls a deserved return, got a 2 and was said to be all over the place for some of the goals. Aaron Wan-Bissaka also got a 2, with Son riding roughshod over him and the right-back described as out of form since coming back.
In midfield, Nemanja Matic was hooked at the interval and rated 2. The paper says Tottenham preyed on his immobility and he could not keep pace with their fast breaks. Paul Pogba, who got a 1, was bulldozed by his compatriot Ndombele and conceded a penalty. The ratings say he did not vindicate his place in the starting eleven after performing midweek at Brighton.
The turning point came at 2-1. Anthony Martial was sent off for reacting to Erik Lamela, an act the paper calls stupid, and United folded like cards, in its words. Martial, rated 2, will now serve a three-match league suspension.
At the other end of the pitch, Marcus Rashford hit the post but was eventually flagged offside, and the ratings call him out of sorts yet again and unable to reinvigorate United. Mason Greenwood could not get into the game amid Tottenham's counter-attacking and received a 3; the paper adds that it is just as well he has a two-week rest. David de Gea got a 4. He was not visibly at fault for any of the goals, the paper says, but was left exposed behind a defence it likens to William Prunier impressionists.
Fred and Scott McTominay, both given 4, came on and did not excel in what the paper calls the damage-limitation exercise. Van de Beek, on for the closing stages, came on late enough not to be tarred with the same brush.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, rated 2, receives a mixed verdict. The paper judges his team selection logical enough and says he was let down by individual errors. But it says he did nothing as Spurs ran riot in the first half, and by then the game was over.
What comes next is a reshuffled attack without Martial for three league games, and a manager whose in-game response is now the focus of the questions.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
The team Solskjaer selected was logical enough and he was let down by individual errors, but he did nothing as Spurs ran riot in the first half.— Manchester Evening News player ratings (paraphrased)