In the long human pursuit of small domestic pleasures, the frozen dessert holds a particular place — a reward made at home, eaten in quiet. Three new blade-based ice-cream-makers, tested by a New York Magazine writer in the summer of 2026, each promise to shorten the distance between intention and indulgence. The Ninja Creami, the Nutribullet Chill, and the Cuisinart FastFreeze all deliver on that promise, though each asks something different of the person standing at the counter.
Three Ice-Cream Makers Face Off: Ninja, Nutribullet, and Cuisinart
Each machine performed according to expectation based on size and price.
Mark
So these are all the same type of machine—they freeze things fast by using a blade instead of churning?
Mimi
Exactly. The trade-off is that you have to plan ahead and freeze your base for 24 hours, but then the actual processing is just minutes instead of an hour.
Luke
But the source material shows the testing wasn't perfectly controlled, right? Different recipes, different freeze times, the Cuisinart's base got soft while waiting.
Mimi
True. The vanilla test especially was messy—the Ninja used a soft-serve recipe, not ice cream. But even with those variables, the pattern held: Ninja smoothest, Nutribullet second, Cuisinart third.
Mark
And that pattern matched the price and size?
Mimi
Exactly. Biggest, most powerful, most expensive machine produced the best results. Smallest, cheapest, least powerful produced the third-best. It was almost too predictable.
Luke
So if someone has limited space and money, the Cuisinart is the play?
Mimi
If they don't mind holding it with both hands the whole time and doing a bit more cleanup, yes. It's $100 and stores in a drawer.
Mark
What about the Nutribullet—it seems like the middle ground?
Mimi
It is. Compact, intuitive, easy to clean, and over 80 recipes online. The results weren't quite as smooth as the Ninja, but they were very good.
Luke
One thing I'd flag: the writer only tested two recipes. We don't know how these machines handle, say, a really dense custard or a sorbet. The testing was limited.
Mimi
Fair point. But for vanilla ice cream and frozen yogurt—the basics—the results are clear.
Mark
So the Ninja is the one to get if you want the best?
Mimi
If you have the counter space, don't mind the noise, and want the most features and the smoothest results, yes. But for most people, the Nutribullet is probably the sweet spot.
O Pulso
- The central tension is time: these machines demand 24 hours of freezing patience before rewarding you with minutes of whirring transformation.
- The Ninja dominates in size, noise, and smoothness — 22 pounds of ambition with 13 programs and a soft-serve extruder that turns dessert into spectacle.
- The Nutribullet enters the category quietly, offering a compact, dishwasher-friendly design that sacrifices a little texture for a lot of countertop peace.
- The Cuisinart asks the most of its user — two hands, manual attention, fussier cleanup — but costs the least and disappears into a drawer when the moment is over.
- All three machines land in the same place: a homemade frozen treat at midnight, the only real variable being how much machine you're willing to live with to get there.
In the long human pursuit of small domestic pleasures, the frozen dessert holds a particular place — a reward made at home, eaten in quiet. Three new blade-based ice-cream-makers, tested by a New York Magazine writer in the summer of 2026, each promise to shorten the distance between intention and indulgence. The Ninja Creami, the Nutribullet Chill, and the Cuisinart FastFreeze all deliver on that promise, though each asks something different of the person standing at the counter.
There is a particular midnight pleasure in pulling something homemade from the freezer and eating it straight from the container. Three blade-based ice-cream-makers — the Ninja Creami Scoop & Swirl, the Nutribullet Chill, and the Cuisinart FastFreeze — each promise to make that moment possible, and after thorough testing, they mostly deliver.
Unlike older churning machines, these work by freezing a base mixture solid for 24 hours, then using a blade to whip it into ice cream in minutes. The trade-off is planning ahead rather than waiting around — a reasonable bargain for anyone who has ever forgotten to pre-chill a freezer bowl.
The Ninja is the largest and most powerful of the three, standing 17 inches tall and weighing 22 pounds, with 13 programs and a soft-serve extruder that doubles as a party trick. The Nutribullet Chill, the company's first foray into frozen desserts, is compact and intuitive — closer in spirit to its blenders, with five programs and parts that clean easily. The Cuisinart FastFreeze is the smallest and cheapest, shaped almost like an immersion blender, and comes with three half-pint containers.
Testing involved two recipes across all three machines: a vanilla ice cream and a tart frozen yogurt. In both rounds, the Ninja produced the smoothest results, followed by the Nutribullet, then the Cuisinart. Processing times were similar — four to five minutes for the Ninja and Nutribullet, slightly less for the Cuisinart. The Ninja's soft-serve extruder is genuinely fun, though its crevices make cleanup harder. The Nutribullet is the quietest and most streamlined, with most parts dishwasher safe and a QR code linking to over 80 recipes. The Cuisinart requires two hands to operate and doesn't stop automatically, but at $100 it is the most affordable, and its parts store neatly out of sight.
The right choice comes down to priorities. The Ninja rewards those who want the best results and don't mind the footprint. The Nutribullet suits anyone who values ease and efficiency in a smaller package. The Cuisinart is for the budget-conscious and space-limited, willing to trade a little convenience for a lower price. All three will get you to that frozen moment — the only question is how much machine you want along for the journey.
There's a particular pleasure in standing in front of your freezer at midnight, pulling out a container of something you made yourself, and eating it straight from the pint. That pleasure is what three new ice-cream-makers promise to deliver—and after testing the Ninja Creami Scoop & Swirl, the Nutribullet Chill, and the Cuisinart FastFreeze, it turns out they mostly deliver on that promise, each in its own way.
These machines work differently from the ice-cream-makers your parents might have owned. Instead of a freezer bowl or built-in compressor that churns a liquid mixture into frozen dessert over the course of an hour, these three use a blade system: you freeze your base mixture solid for 24 hours, then the machine whips it into shape in minutes. It's a trade-off between patience and speed, and for anyone who has ever forgotten to chill a freezer bowl, it's a reasonable one.
The Ninja is the heavyweight here—17 inches tall, 13 inches wide, 22 pounds of machine. It comes with 13 different programs, everything from soft-serve to sorbet to frozen custard, plus a soft-serve extruder that turns the whole thing into a kind of party trick. The Nutribullet Chill, released this spring as the company's first entry into the category, is built more like its blenders: compact, intuitive, designed to sit on a countertop without dominating it. It measures about 15 inches high and six inches wide, with five programs and parts that come apart for easy cleaning. The Cuisinart FastFreeze is the smallest and lightest of the three, shaped almost like an immersion blender, measuring just over 16 inches high and four inches wide. It comes with three half-pint containers and costs the least.
To test them fairly, the writer made a simple vanilla ice cream and a tart frozen yogurt in each machine. The vanilla round was admittedly imperfect—the Ninja ended up processing a soft-serve recipe rather than straight ice cream, and the Cuisinart's base got a bit soft while the others were running—but the results were clear. The Ninja produced the smoothest consistency, the Nutribullet came second, and the Cuisinart third. Processing times were comparable: the Ninja and Nutribullet both took four to five minutes, the Cuisinart about two (partly because its base had warmed up). The Ninja has a countdown timer; the Nutribullet has a digital progress ring but no time display.
For the second test, the writer made her go-to frozen yogurt recipe—yogurt, buttermilk, lemon juice, and sugar—across all three machines. This time the Ninja had been frozen the longest, while the Nutribullet and Cuisinart only got about 14 hours instead of the recommended 24. The Ninja took four minutes and needed a one-minute respin to smooth out some icy patches. The Nutribullet took five minutes, the Cuisinart about four. Again, the Ninja's result was the smoothest, though all three were good enough to eat straight from the container.
Each machine revealed its own character in use. The Ninja is loud and takes up real estate, but the soft-serve extruder is genuinely fun and the recipe book includes over 30 options. The hardest part to clean is the extruder itself, which can't be removed and collects residue in its crevices. The Nutribullet is streamlined and easy to use, with most parts top-rack dishwasher safe. It's quieter than the Ninja but produces slightly less smooth results. It comes with five recipes in the manual, but a QR code links to a website with over 80 more. The Cuisinart requires both hands to operate—one to hold the base steady, one to press down on the motor—and it doesn't stop on its own; instead it blinks red when the blade has reached the bottom. The blade stays attached to the base, which can't be submerged, making cleanup a bit more fussy. But at $100, it's the cheapest option, and everything else can be taken apart and stored in a drawer.
The choice, ultimately, depends on what matters most. The Ninja delivers the smoothest results and the most features, but it's a commitment of counter space and a willingness to tolerate noise. The Nutribullet splits the difference: compact, intuitive, efficient enough, with plenty of recipe options online. The Cuisinart is for people who value portability and price over convenience, who don't mind holding a machine steady for a few minutes to save money and space. All three will get you to that midnight moment with a homemade frozen treat. The question is just how much machine you want standing between you and it.
Citações Notáveis
The soft-serve extruder is extremely delightful and a great party trick.— The writer, on the Ninja Creami
It's compact and streamlined and extremely intuitive to use.— The writer, on the Nutribullet Chill
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em New York Magazine ↗
General News