On a Thursday in late October, thousands gathered in Warsaw and more than twenty other Polish cities to mark six years since a court ruling narrowed abortion access still further. Poland has long lived with one of Europe's strictest regimes, a compromise in which the law permits termination only after rape, incest, or real danger to the mother, and so much of what women actually do is pushed into silence. The marchers were not only mourning a past decision but measuring a present promise, the one made by a government that came to power pledging to loosen those limits. Whether that promise surv
Thousands Across Poland Protest Stalled Abortion Reform as Government Faces Accusations of Broken Promise
Activists say tens of thousands of abortions take place outside hospitals each year, and people who help women may face up to three years in prison.
"These are breadcrumbs," said an activist of the two reform bills
Mark
Why did these protests land on this particular Thursday?
Mimi
Two reasons stack up. It's six years since the court ruling that tightened the law, and it's just days after parliament passed two bills easing restrictions.
Mark
So parliament did act. Why are activists angry?
Mimi
Because they expect the president, Karol Nawrocki, to veto both bills. Kinga Jelinska called them "breadcrumbs."
Luke
Worth noting the veto is expected, not confirmed. The reporting says he's backed by PiS, but he hasn't acted yet as far as this account goes.
Mark
And the claim that the government is only posturing for votes?
Mimi
That's the activists' reading: a token gesture a year before the election, because the coalition needs women's votes.
Luke
Right, that's their accusation, not an established motive. What's documented is that coalition disagreements have hampered changes to the law.
Mark
What does the law mean in practice?
Mimi
Legal only for rape, incest, or a threat to the mother's life or health. Most abortions happen in secret. Helpers, including doctors and family, risk up to three years in prison.
Luke
And the figure of tens of thousands outside hospitals each year is the activists' estimate. The source doesn't give an independent count.
Mark
So what do we watch?
Mimi
Whether Nawrocki vetoes, and how the coalition answers before the election.
The Pulse
- Thousands marched through Warsaw and more than twenty cities, placards demanding an end to what protesters call women's hell.
- Two bills easing abortion limits have passed parliament, but a veto from President Nawrocki looms and could leave them dead on arrival.
- Activists dismiss the reforms as breadcrumbs, arguing the government staged action a year before an election to win women's votes.
- Tens of thousands of abortions reportedly happen in secret each year, and those who help women risk up to three years in prison.
- The outcome now rests with the presidency, and the question of Tusk's 2023 pledge is heading into next year's campaign unresolved.
On a Thursday in late October, thousands gathered in Warsaw and more than twenty other Polish cities to mark six years since a court ruling narrowed abortion access still further. Poland has long lived with one of Europe's strictest regimes, a compromise in which the law permits termination only after rape, incest, or real danger to the mother, and so much of what women actually do is pushed into silence. The marchers were not only mourning a past decision but measuring a present promise, the one made by a government that came to power pledging to loosen those limits. Whether that promise survives the veto now waiting on a president's desk will show how far a divided country is willing to move its laws toward the lives people are already living.
On Thursday, thousands of people filled the streets of Warsaw and more than twenty other Polish cities. They carried signs reading "Women's hell continues" and "Men of quality don't fear equality," marking six years since a court ruling tightened an already strict abortion law. The message was aimed squarely at the government now in office.
Abortion in Poland has been legal since 1993, but only in narrow cases: after rape or incest, or when the mother's life or health is at risk. Since the conservative Law and Justice government tightened the rules further, abortion has been permitted in almost none of the cases that once allowed it. In practice, activists say, tens of thousands of women end pregnancies outside hospitals each year. The women themselves are not usually prosecuted, but the doctors and family members who help them can face up to three years in prison.
Prime Minister Donald Tusk came to power in 2023 promising to loosen these restrictions, and that promise remains unkept. Divisions within his coalition have stalled reform, and protesters now say the government has broken its word. The march came just days after parliament passed two bills that would ease the rules, but they are widely expected to be vetoed by President Karol Nawrocki, who is backed by the conservative opposition.
For the activists, the bills are scraps rather than a meal. Kinga Jelinska of the Women Help Women Foundation called them "breadcrumbs," and campaigners see the timing, one year before the next election, as an attempt to win women's votes without real change. If the veto comes, the law stays as it is, and the question of whether Tusk can deliver his pledge will become a central issue in the coming campaign.
On Thursday, thousands of people took to the streets in Warsaw and in more than 20 other Polish cities, carrying placards that read "Women's hell continues" and "Men of quality don't fear equality." The demonstrations marked six years since a landmark court ruling tightened the country's abortion restrictions, and they carried a pointed message for the government now in office.
Poland's abortion law is among the strictest in Europe. Abortion has been legal in the overwhelmingly Catholic country since 1993, though only in narrow circumstances. Today it is permitted when a pregnancy results from a criminal act such as rape or incest, or when it endangers the life or health of the mother. Before 2020, it was also allowed in cases of severe fetal abnormalities.
That changed under the conservative Law and Justice (PiS) government, which tightened the rules further in 2020 and banned abortions on grounds of fetal abnormality. The consequence, according to the reporting, is that most abortions in Poland are now carried out in secret. Activists say tens of thousands take place outside hospitals every year.
The legal burden falls unevenly. Women who end a pregnancy in secret, for instance by taking pills, do not face criminal responsibility. But the people who help them, including doctors and family members, can potentially be prosecuted and face up to three years in prison.
Donald Tusk became prime minister in 2023 after pledging to loosen the restrictions. That promise has not been fulfilled. Disagreements among the members of his governing coalition have hampered efforts to change the law, and protesters now accuse the government of breaking its word.
The timing of Thursday's marches was deliberate. They came just days after Poland's parliament passed two bills that would ease abortion restrictions. Those bills, however, are expected to be vetoed by President Karol Nawrocki, a politician backed by the conservative PiS opposition.
Activists are unimpressed. "These are breadcrumbs," Kinga Jelinska, director of the Women Help Women Foundation and co-founder of the Abortion Dream Team, told the news agency AFP. Campaigners argue that passing draft laws one year before the next parliamentary election is a token gesture with no real chance of becoming law. In their view, Tusk's liberal government is trying to create the impression of action because it needs women's votes.
What happens next turns on the president's desk. If Nawrocki vetoes the two bills as expected, the legal framework stays as it is, and the question of whether the coalition can deliver on its 2023 pledge will move into next year's election campaign.
Notable Quotes
These are breadcrumbs.— Kinga Jelinska, director of Women Help Women Foundation, to AFP
Want the full story?
Read the original at Deutsche Welle ↗
Politics & Governance