On a night when the SCG roared louder than it had in years, a Sydney side missing five suspended players, in the long shadow of the Pullman Hotel affair, turned a qualifying final against two-time premiers Brisbane into a rout. Observers see in the result something older than the scandal: a club identity that lives in effort and refusal to yield, which persists even when its reputation off the field has frayed. Whether that identity can carry the Swans through September, after a decade-plus of near misses, remains the open question.
Swans show what 'Bloods' culture looks like as depleted Sydney stuns Brisbane in finals
The louder the crowd got, the better the Swans played.
Mark
Why does this win matter beyond the scoreboard?
Mimi
Because the club has spent weeks answering questions about its culture after the Pullman Hotel scandal. This was a public answer, on the field, against the reigning two-time premiers.
Mark
Five players out, including Heeney, Warner and Blakey. How big a loss is that?
Mimi
The article calls them arguably three of the top six players by any metric. Chairman Andrew Pridham said the suspensions torpedoed premiership hopes.
Luke
Careful with "culture," though. This is an analysis piece. One win doesn't prove what the culture is.
Mimi
Fair. The club itself admitted the culture was not what it once was off the field. The argument is only about what showed up on the field.
Mark
What does the on-field version look like?
Mimi
Effort, intensity and a never-say-die attitude whoever is playing. Papley said training was the best of the season, built around pressure, tackling and chasing.
Luke
That's a player's account and the writer's reading. The piece offers no measures like tackle counts or the final margin.
Mark
Does the Adelaide comparison hold?
Mimi
It's a contrast. Adelaide lost Rankine on the eve of finals and went out in straight sets. Sydney did the opposite.
Luke
And what's still unknown is how much Callum Mills's injury will cost them. The article only calls it an added nightmare.
Mimi
Right, and a home preliminary final is two weeks away.
El Pulso
- Five suspensions tore through Sydney's list in the wake of the Pullman Hotel scandal, leaving the Swans without key players and their premiership hopes in doubt.
- Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner and Nick Blakey were all missing, stripping the side of several of its most important players.
- Inside a deafening SCG, crowd and team fed off each other, and Brisbane was overrun as the home side pressed, chased and surged.
- Tom Papley's account of the best training block of the season suggests a group rebuilding around pressure and belief rather than personalities.
- With a home preliminary final ahead and injuries piling up, Sydney has won a battle but must still prove it can win the war.
On a night when the SCG roared louder than it had in years, a Sydney side missing five suspended players, in the long shadow of the Pullman Hotel affair, turned a qualifying final against two-time premiers Brisbane into a rout. Observers see in the result something older than the scandal: a club identity that lives in effort and refusal to yield, which persists even when its reputation off the field has frayed. Whether that identity can carry the Swans through September, after a decade-plus of near misses, remains the open question.
The SCG was as loud as it has been in years when Sydney met Brisbane in a qualifying final, and the home side fed on every decibel. Without five suspended players, the Swans dismantled the two-time reigning premiers in front of that crowd.
The suspensions followed the Pullman Hotel scandal, which chairman Andrew Pridham had said had "torpedoed" the club's premiership hopes. Adelaide's recent collapse offered a warning that finals preparation is delicate, and Sydney's losses looked severe: Heeney, Warner and Blakey were all missing, and few expected much from a team that had been written off as an easy path.
The scandal also raised questions about the club's "Bloods" culture. Off the field, the club admitted it was not what it once was. On the field, the analysis argues, there was little sign of slippage. The crowd and the team built on each other, and Brisbane was swallowed up.
Sydney still had stars in Curnow, Grundy, Gulden and Papley, and many of them were excellent. Papley said the fortnight of training had been the best of the season, built on pressure and belief, and that the job was not done.
The Swans still face an uphill task for the flag, with a home preliminary final in a fortnight. Since their last premiership in 2012 they have lost four Grand Finals, a reminder that a perfect lead-up guarantees nothing.
The SCG was as loud as it has been in years on the night Sydney met Brisbane in a qualifying final, and the home side fed on every decibel. The Swans were without five suspended players, and by the end they had dismantled the two-time reigning premiers in front of that crowd.
The suspensions followed the Pullman Hotel scandal. Club chairman Andrew Pridham had said at the time that the five-player punishment had "torpedoed" Sydney's premiership hopes. The ABC's analysis agrees he was right to say so. Finals preparation is delicate, and the less that changes, the better. Adelaide offered a recent warning: its strong home-and-away season was wrecked last year when Izak Rankine was suspended for a homophobic slur on the eve of the finals, and the Crows went out in straight sets.
Sydney's circumstances looked worse. Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner and Nick Blakey are all missing, arguably three of the club's top six players by any measure. Rivals saw the Swans as an easy path into a deep September run. Brisbane, ahead of Hawthorn on percentage, appeared to have drawn the better qualifying final, while the Hawks travelled to Perth to face Fremantle. One weekend reversed that picture.
The Pullman Hotel affair prompted questions about Sydney's celebrated "Bloods" culture: what it is, what it should look like, and whether it is a PR myth. The club acknowledged that off the field the culture was not what it once was. On the field, the analysis argues, there was little sign of slippage. Whoever is in the line-up or the coaches' box, Sydney brings a baseline of effort, intensity and never-say-die attitude, and that is what the piece identifies as the real on-field culture.
The crowd and the team built on each other. The louder the SCG became, the better Sydney played, and the better they played, the louder it got. Brisbane was swallowed up. It was also a quiet vindication of a season somewhat overlooked: Sydney finished 18-5, the best home-and-away campaign in its history, while attention went to Fremantle's rise as a premiership threat and Brisbane's bid for a threepeat.
The team was not short of stars despite the absences. Charlie Curnow remains the AFL's most feared key forward. Brodie Grundy is arguably the best big man in the competition outside Max Gawn's class. Errol Gulden is a midfielder capable of leading any engine room, and Tom Papley can bend the energy of a match. Many of them were excellent against Brisbane.
Papley told Nine's Sunday Footy Show that the two weeks of training before the game were the best of the season. The drills centred on pressure, closing space, chasing, tackling and surging the ball forward. He said he was proud of his teammates, that the job was not done, and that inside the four walls the group believed.
The analysis concedes Sydney has played and won bigger games, but given the lead-up, and the injury to Callum Mills added on top, it will struggle to find a performance it is prouder of. The Swans still face an uphill task for the flag, even with a home preliminary final in a fortnight. Since their last premiership in 2012 they have lost four Grand Finals, a reminder that a perfect lead-up guarantees nothing on the last day of the season.
Citas Notables
The two weeks of training up to that point, we trained the house down.— Tom Papley, Nine's Sunday Footy Show
Premiership hopes had been torpedoed by the suspensions of five players.— Andrew Pridham, Sydney chairman
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en ABC (Australian Broadcasting Corporation) ↗
Politics & Governance