Suspect in pediatrician's death accused of sexual assault hours before fatal stabbing

Dr. Idris Evans, 46, was killed in the home invasion; his wife was critically injured; two children (ages 8 and 12) were in the home during the attack.
He appeared psychotic and claimed to be God
Evans' wife described the attacker's behavior during the home invasion, according to the police report.
Mark

So this happened in two places, hours apart. The sexual assault in Wilkinsburg, then the home invasion in Edgewood. Are those towns close to each other?

Mimi

Close enough that someone could move between them in a few hours. It's the same general area outside Pittsburgh.

Luke

The timeline matters here. Wednesday morning for the assault, Thursday early morning for the stabbing. That's not "hours apart"—that's more like a full day or more.

Mark

Right, so we're looking at a pattern across a longer stretch of time. Does police think these were connected when they happened, or did they only connect them later?

Mimi

The Wilkinsburg police notified county detectives about the assault, and then detectives investigated both cases together. So it seems like they made the connection relatively quickly.

Luke

But we should be careful about the word "pattern." Two crimes in the same area by the same person, yes. But we don't know if he was planning to go to the Evans home, or if that was random.

Mark

The wife called him by name—"Elijah." That suggests her husband knew him.

Mimi

She did call out that name. But the county authorities said they couldn't confirm whether Evans and Hemingway had any prior relationship. So it's unclear.

Luke

That's a crucial gap. Did Evans know his attacker or not? The wife's statement suggests maybe yes, but official confirmation says no. That's a real open question.

Mark

And Hemingway's story about being invited in—police didn't believe that?

Mimi

They found no stab wound on his back, which he claimed Evans gave him. They couldn't find the bicycle he said he used. His account didn't match the physical evidence.

Luke

So his story fell apart under scrutiny. But we still don't know how he actually got into that house, or whether there was any connection to Evans beforehand.

  • A woman ambushed on a walking path and a pediatrician killed in his bedroom — both allegedly by the same man within hours of each other — signal a rapid and terrifying escalation of violence across two Pittsburgh communities.
  • Two children, ages 8 and 12, fled their home in the middle of the night as their father was being killed and their mother critically wounded, leaving a family shattered in a matter of minutes.
  • Hemingway's account — that he was invited inside, that he was stabbed, that he arrived by bicycle — collapsed under scrutiny when detectives found no wound on his body and no bicycle anywhere near the scene.
  • Court records reveal Hemingway had been released without bail just months earlier on a burglary charge, raising urgent questions about how a man with arrests dating to 2016 remained free to allegedly commit two violent crimes in a single day.
  • Investigators working across jurisdictions linked both incidents through recovered evidence, including the first victim's stolen cell phone, ultimately charging Hemingway with more than ten counts spanning rape, homicide, burglary, and assault.

In the span of two days across neighboring Pittsburgh communities, a 32-year-old man with a documented criminal history allegedly moved from one act of violence to another — sexually assaulting a stranger in Wilkinsburg before fatally stabbing a pediatrician in his own home in Edgewood while his wife and young children were present. The death of Dr. Idris Evans, a healer of children, inside the sanctuary of his family home, raises enduring questions about the systems meant to protect communities from known dangers. What emerges is not only a story of individual violence, but of the gaps between arrest and accountability that leave ordinary lives exposed.

On a Wednesday morning in Wilkinsburg, a woman walking along a path was ambushed by a man who sexually assaulted her and stole her cell phone. That man, Elijah Hemingway, 32, had a criminal record stretching back to 2016. Hours later, in the early darkness of Thursday, he allegedly entered a home in nearby Edgewood while a family slept.

Hemingway made his way to the bedroom of Dr. Idris Evans, a 46-year-old pediatrician, and his wife. The attack that followed left Dr. Evans dead and his wife critically injured. Their two children — ages 8 and 12 — fled the house in terror at their mother's screaming command.

Evans' wife told investigators that the intruder appeared "psychotic" and claimed to be "God." During the struggle, she called out the name "Elijah" — raising the possibility that her husband may have recognized him — though authorities could not confirm any prior relationship between the men. Hemingway was found wearing only underwear when he entered the home.

His version of events unraveled quickly. He claimed Evans had invited him inside, that Evans had attacked him with a knife, and that he had arrived by bicycle. Detectives found no stab wound on his body and no bicycle near the scene.

Police working across jurisdictions pieced the two incidents together, recovering the first victim's stolen cell phone among other evidence linking Hemingway to the Wilkinsburg assault. He now faces charges including rape, sexual assault, robbery, criminal homicide, aggravated assault, and burglary.

Court records showed that despite his history of arrests, Hemingway had been released without bail just months earlier on a separate burglary charge — free in the community when both attacks allegedly occurred. For the Evans family, that detail arrived too late. A man who spent his life caring for children was gone, and two of his own were left to carry what they witnessed in their home that night.

On a Wednesday morning in Wilkinsburg, a woman was walking along a path that connects to an alley when she was ambushed. The man who attacked her, later identified as Elijah Hemingway, a 32-year-old with a criminal record stretching back to 2016, sexually assaulted her and stole her cell phone. She did not know him. Hours later, in the early morning darkness of Thursday, Hemingway allegedly entered a home in nearby Edgewood while a family slept. He made his way to the bedroom where Dr. Idris Evans, a 46-year-old pediatrician, and his wife were lying down. What happened next left one person dead and another critically injured, and sent two children—ages 8 and 12—fleeing from their home in terror.

The sequence of events emerged slowly as police pieced together the two incidents. Wilkinsburg officers responded to the sexual assault report and notified Allegheny County detectives, who began investigating both cases in tandem. Detectives recovered multiple items linking Hemingway to the assault in Wilkinsburg, including the victim's stolen cell phone. Following consultation with the district attorney's office, authorities filed additional charges against him: rape, sexual assault, and robbery.

But the more serious charges came from what happened in Edgewood. According to the police report, Hemingway entered the Evans home and attacked the couple while wearing only underwear. Evans' wife told investigators that he appeared "psychotic" and claimed to be "God." As the couple fought back against their attacker, she screamed for their children to leave the house. During the struggle, she called out the name "Elijah"—suggesting her husband may have recognized him—though county authorities later said they could not confirm whether Evans and Hemingway had any prior relationship. Evans' wife also told police she did not know the suspect and was uncertain how he had gained entry to their home.

Dr. Evans was rushed to a hospital but was pronounced dead. His wife survived, though she was critically injured. The two children escaped the house as their mother had commanded.

Hemingway's account of the night differed sharply from what police found. He claimed that Evans had invited him to the home hours earlier and let him inside. He also said that Evans had attacked him with a knife and that he sustained a stab wound to his back. When detectives examined Hemingway, they found no such wound. They also could not locate the bicycle he claimed to have used to reach the home. His story did not hold.

Authorities charged Hemingway with seven counts in connection with the Thursday attack: criminal homicide, aggravated assault, burglary, and trespassing, among others. Combined with the charges from the Wilkinsburg assault, he faced a substantial criminal case. Court records revealed that despite his history—arrests dating back to 2016—Hemingway had been released without bail in July in connection with a February burglary charge. He was free when he allegedly attacked the woman on Wednesday and entered the Evans home on Thursday.

The case raised questions about how a man with his record remained in the community without bail, and how two violent incidents separated by hours could unfold in the same geographic area. For the Evans family, the questions came too late. A pediatrician was dead, his wife was fighting for her life, and two children had witnessed violence in their own bedroom in the middle of the night.

Evans' wife told police the attacker appeared psychotic and claimed to be God during the incident
— Police report, as described by Evans' wife
Evans called the attacker Elijah, as though he knew him, though county authorities could not confirm whether the two had any pre-existing relationship
— Police report and county authorities
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en Fox News ↗
Contáctanos FAQ