In a country where the act of voting has long been a quiet proof of belonging, a revision of India's electoral rolls has begun to unmoor people who held the documents of citizenship in their hands. Reuters' examination of ten families shows relatives removed from the lists being detained, deported, or questioned about where they truly belong, even as their parents and siblings remained on the same registers. The sharpest case lies in West Bengal, where a border drawn in 1947 still runs through family histories, and where a state's electorate was transformed before an election that a new govern
Struck From India's Voter Rolls, Some Muslims Find Themselves Detained and Deported
Removal from the rolls does not itself establish that someone is a foreigner
Why does Fakir's case sit at the center of this?
Because it joins the two threads. She was on West Bengal's rolls since at least 2008, her family goes back to 1952 registers, and she still ended up across the border.
Careful, though. Those records come from her family and her voter ID as seen by Reuters. Mumbai's registration office says she produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate. That dispute is unresolved.
What is the official position on the deportation itself?
Mumbai police told the court she was handed to the Border Security Force and deported through designated authorities. Court filings put her among 149 people removed.
Bangladesh's government didn't respond, and neither did the Home Ministry. So we have her account and court filings, not a full official explanation.
Does deletion from the rolls prove someone is a foreigner?
No, and the report is explicit about it. Yet Amit Shah linked detecting infiltrators, removing them from rolls and expelling them in one sentence.
Ten families is also a small sample. It shows a pattern in those cases, not how many people overall were affected.
What about the 70% figure for Muslims among deletions?
That comes from the Sabar Institute, one source. It's striking, but it's an organization's analysis, and the BJP denies targeting legitimate citizens.
And the detention accounts conflict too. Sheikh describes a jail-like hall; state lawyers say there are no permanent camps.
Le Pouls
- Ten families describe relatives taken from their homes or cells despite holding valid Indian identity documents.
- Some 2.7 million names were cut in West Bengal, and Muslims made up roughly 70 percent of those deletions while being about 27 percent of the population.
- A Home Minister's rally promise to pick out infiltrators 'one by one' has turned an electoral review into a deportation campaign in the public mind.
- Petitions in the Supreme Court and Calcutta High Court argue that deletion cannot prove foreignness, but the tribunals hearing appeals move slowly and detainees wait in custody.
In a country where the act of voting has long been a quiet proof of belonging, a revision of India's electoral rolls has begun to unmoor people who held the documents of citizenship in their hands. Reuters' examination of ten families shows relatives removed from the lists being detained, deported, or questioned about where they truly belong, even as their parents and siblings remained on the same registers. The sharpest case lies in West Bengal, where a border drawn in 1947 still runs through family histories, and where a state's electorate was transformed before an election that a new government then won. The courts in Calcutta and New Delhi now hold the question of whether a name lost from a list can be made to mean a person lost from a country, and that answer has not yet been given.
On July 19, Sahida Fakir left her home in Mumbai to buy vegetables, telling her younger son she would be back in minutes. More than three months later, the 38-year-old is living in a village in Bangladesh, separated from her husband and sons. She says plainclothes officers seized her phone, which held copies of her documents, and forced her over an unfenced stretch of the border in the middle of the night. A farmer found her crying in the mud and took her in.
Hers is one of ten cases Reuters examined. In each, relatives were dropped from India's revised electoral rolls and then detained, deported, or questioned about their citizenship, though all ten families held Indian identity documents, and parents or siblings stayed on the lists. The revision has become entangled with a wider campaign to find and expel suspected illegal immigrants, even though removal from a roll does not by itself make anyone a foreigner. In West Bengal, where around 2.7 million names were deleted, Muslims were roughly 70 percent of those removed while making up about 27 percent of the population. Home Minister Amit Shah has openly tied the process to expulsions, and the BJP, which denies targeting legitimate citizens, went on to win the state.
Fakir's family records trace her parents and grandparents as voters in Swarupnagar from 1952, and her own voter ID shows her on the rolls since 2008. Mumbai authorities say she produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate and lacked credible proof of citizenship. She disputes this, saying she never had the chance to show the copies on her seized phone. "My home, my grandparents and my entire family lineage are rooted in India," she said. Her husband is now fighting her case in court.
Nasiruddin Sheikh, a utensil hawker, tells a similar story. Held in Chhattisgarh with 22 others, hundreds of kilometres from home, he spent 32 days in custody after his name was deleted while appeals were still pending. Nineteen of the group were freed after 14 days, once their names were found on the revised rolls. "A policeman told me, 'Your name is not in the voter list. You are a Bangladeshi,'" he recalled. Activists say millions of challenges are waiting in tribunals that are moving slowly, and for families like Fakir's, the Supreme Court and Calcutta High Court are where their claims will finally be tested.
On July 19, Sahida Fakir left her home in Mumbai to buy vegetables. She told her younger son she would be back in a few minutes. More than three months later, the 38-year-old is living in a village in Bangladesh, apart from her husband and her two sons.
Fakir says plainclothes officers grabbed her, seized her phone, which she says held copies of her identity documents, and eventually forced her over the border. Court filings identify the officers as belonging to the Mumbai police crime branch, which did not respond to Reuters' request for comment. "Someone grabbed my hand from behind and ordered me to get into the vehicle," she told Reuters in Satkhira, Bangladesh. She says she was pushed across at 1 a.m. from an unmanned, unfenced stretch of the frontier, and that she walked for hours, caked in mud, until a farmer found her crying and took her in.
Her case is one of ten that Reuters examined. In each, relatives were detained, deported or questioned about their citizenship after being dropped from India's revised electoral rolls. All ten families had Indian identity or family documents, and in each, relatives such as parents and siblings stayed on the voter lists. The cases show a voter-roll revision becoming entangled with a separate campaign to find and expel suspected illegal immigrants, though removal from the rolls does not by itself establish that anyone is a foreigner.
The revision has set off large protests and accusations that the BJP is reshaping the electorate in its favour. The party denies targeting legitimate citizens. In West Bengal, where the process has gone furthest, around 9 million names were removed before state elections earlier this year. After a closer review, 2.7 million names were deleted, and the Kolkata-based Sabar Institute says Muslims were about 70% of them, though they make up 27% of the population. The BJP won and took control of the state for the first time. The institute's founder, Sabir Ahamed, said anti-incumbency played a part, but that the deletions "played a big role" in the result.
Home Minister Amit Shah drew the link himself at a November 5 rally in Haryana. The BJP's resolve, he said, was to detect infiltrators, remove them from the electoral rolls, and then "pick them out one by one and expel them from the country." The Home Ministry, Prime Minister's Office and Election Commission did not respond to requests for comment. Citizenship is especially charged in West Bengal, where the 1947 Partition border split the region in two, and where millions crossed during that upheaval and again during Bangladesh's 1971 war, leaving families straddling the line.
Mumbai police told a court that Fakir was handed to the Border Security Force on the Assam border and later deported to Bangladesh through designated authorities. Court filings show she was among 149 people deported in that operation after being identified as Bangladeshi nationals. Her husband, Jumman, is now fighting her case in court. A petition her family filed in the Supreme Court in August argues that deletion from a roll cannot determine citizenship and that she could not be removed on an "untested executive assertion." Family records reviewed by Reuters show her parents and grandparents were registered voters in Swarupnagar, West Bengal, from the 1952 national election, and appeared on the 2002-03 rolls, the benchmark the revision uses to decide who can stay without extra paperwork. Her own voter ID shows her on West Bengal's rolls since at least 2008.
Mumbai's Foreigners Regional Registration Office told the Calcutta High Court that Fakir produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate during an inquiry and offered no valid or credible documentary proof of Indian citizenship. Fakir disputes this, saying her phone was taken and she had no chance to show the copies on it. Indian law does not require citizens to carry valid identification at all times. "My home, my grandparents and my entire family lineage are rooted in India," she said.
Another Calcutta High Court petition involves utensil hawker Nasiruddin Sheikh and four others, who say they were detained after their names were deleted even though appeals were pending before special tribunals. Sheikh says police held him and 22 others in Chhattisgarh, hundreds of kilometres from home. Nineteen were freed after 14 days, when their names were found on the revised rolls. Sheikh and three others stayed in custody for 32 days. "A policeman told me, 'Your name is not in the voter list. You are a Bangladeshi,'" he said. He described a hall with beds for over 60 people, with medical exams and biometric registration on arrival: "a jail in every sense." Police and state lawyers have told the court West Bengal has no permanent detention camps. Reuters reporters visiting a holding centre in Murshidabad saw clothes hanging inside, faces at windows, and an ambulance and covered police bus in the guarded compound. A neighbour, Mosami Ray, said she saw people brought there two months ago and families weeping outside.
Millions of challenges to the deletions are pending, and activist Kirity Roy says the tribunals are slow. "We are hopeless with what is going on," he said. The Supreme Court and Calcutta High Court cases are where Fakir's and Sheikh's claims will be tested.
Citations marquantes
We will detect infiltrators, remove them from the electoral rolls, and after that, we will pick them out one by one and expel them from the country.— Home Minister Amit Shah, November 5 rally in Haryana
My home, my grandparents and my entire family lineage are rooted in India.— Sahida Fakir