On a Saturday in November, a steel spacecraft returned from orbit and was gently gathered by mechanical arms back onto the same pad it had left a day earlier, a first in the long human effort to make rockets reusable. The victory was shadowed by the loss of its booster, which broke apart over the Gulf of Mexico when its engines fell silent too soon, leaving the company to ask why. Taken together, the day marks a meaningful step on the road toward returning people to the moon and, further off, to Mars, even as the unanswered question of the lost booster reminds everyone how hard that road remai
Starship Returns From Orbit and Is Caught by Launch Pad Arms, Though Booster Is Lost in the Gulf
Caught in midair by giant mechanical arms where its journey began
Mark
Why does catching the spacecraft matter so much, if the booster was lost?
Mimi
Because it's the first time a Starship coming back from space has been caught by the arms. SpaceX says it shows full reusability, which the moon and Mars plans depend on.
Luke
Worth being careful there. "Demonstrates full reusability" is SpaceX's framing. One catch is one catch. The reporting doesn't say how quickly the ship could fly again.
Mark
And the booster? What went wrong?
Mimi
The engines stopped firing too soon on the way down. The guidance system sensed the booster was out of position and sent it into the Gulf and destroyed it.
Luke
That part is attributed to SpaceX's Kate Tice, and the root cause is still under investigation. We know the symptom, not the reason.
Mark
So was the flight a success?
Mimi
The spacecraft did 14 laps, released 26 Starlink satellites, and the heat shield appeared to work well. That's a big step up from the last mission's one or two laps.
Luke
"Appeared to work well" is also SpaceX's own report. Independent assessment isn't in this account.
Mark
What does this mean for NASA?
Mimi
NASA is paying billions for Starship to land Artemis astronauts, with Artemis IV targeted as soon as 2028. Artemis III will practice docking with Starship and Blue Moon in Earth orbit.
Luke
And 2028 is a target, not a commitment. The Florida launches are expected within months, but that's also an expectation, not a date.
Le Pouls
- A booster's engines cut out too early on its way down, and the guidance system destroyed it over the Gulf of Mexico, shattering the hope of a double catch.
- The spacecraft released 26 Starlink satellites, circled the planet 14 times, and then descended into the arms of the launch tower, a catch never before achieved on a returning Starship.
- Engineers are racing to pinpoint the cause of the early engine shutdown while wreckage sits cordoned off by buoys in the Gulf.
- Operations are shifting toward Kennedy Space Center in Florida, with launches expected within months to support NASA's Artemis III orbital lander tests.
- A possible crewed moon landing as early as 2028 now hangs on closing the gap exposed by this flight.
On a Saturday in November, a steel spacecraft returned from orbit and was gently gathered by mechanical arms back onto the same pad it had left a day earlier, a first in the long human effort to make rockets reusable. The victory was shadowed by the loss of its booster, which broke apart over the Gulf of Mexico when its engines fell silent too soon, leaving the company to ask why. Taken together, the day marks a meaningful step on the road toward returning people to the moon and, further off, to Mars, even as the unanswered question of the lost booster reminds everyone how hard that road remains.
On Saturday, a stainless steel, bullet-shaped spacecraft lowered itself upright over the Texas launch pad it had left 22 hours earlier, and a pair of giant mechanical arms closed around it in midair. It was the first time SpaceX had caught a returning Starship, and the company's commentator answered the moment with a shout: "Can you believe it?"
The catch was the finale Elon Musk and his team had hoped for, though not the whole show. They had wanted both the booster and the spacecraft snagged by the tower. Shortly after Friday's liftoff, the booster exploded, and its wreckage stayed in the Gulf of Mexico, cordoned off by buoys, while the spacecraft made its way home.
The upper stage had separated cleanly before trouble began. It climbed into orbit, released 26 Starlink satellites, and circled the Earth 14 times, far more than on its previous mission. Everything aboard, including the vital heat shield, appeared to perform well. The booster's engines, however, stopped firing too soon on the way down, and its guidance system sent it into the sea. Engineers are still working out why.
NASA welcomed the result, having committed billions to Starship as a lunar lander. Next comes Florida, where launches from Kennedy Space Center are expected within months. Artemis III will test landers in orbit, and crewed moon landings could follow as early as 2028. The booster investigation remains the open question to watch.
On Saturday, a stainless steel, bullet-shaped spacecraft lowered itself upright over the launch pad where it had lifted off 22 hours earlier, and a pair of giant mechanical arms closed around it in midair. It was the first time SpaceX had ever caught a Starship returning from space, and the company's commentator, Dan Huot, answered it with a shout: "Can you believe it?"
The catch was the finale Elon Musk and his team had been hoping for, though not the whole show. They had wanted a double catch, with the first-stage booster and the spacecraft both snagged by the tower. That did not happen. Shortly after Friday's liftoff from SpaceX's Starship base in Texas, near the U.S.-Mexican border, the booster exploded. Its wreckage stayed in the Gulf of Mexico, cordoned off by buoys, while the spacecraft made its way home.
The vehicle is the world's largest and most powerful rocket, 407 feet (124 meters) tall. It left the pad late Friday afternoon. The upper-stage spacecraft separated cleanly from the booster before the trouble began, then climbed into orbit and released 26 advanced Starlink satellites. It stayed up at about 165 miles (265 kilometers), with live views of itself and Earth streaming down over Starlink. In all, it completed 14 laps around the planet, far more than the one or two of the previous mission. SpaceX reported that everything aboard, including the vital heat shield, appeared to work well.
The booster's story was different. SpaceX's Kate Tice said its engines stopped firing too soon on the way back down. Its guidance system sensed it was not in the right position and automatically sent it into the water and destroyed it. Engineers are still investigating what caused the early shutdown. SpaceX noted that it had already caught boosters three times before, which it says validated the technique, even though Friday's attempt failed.
This was SpaceX's 15th flight of a full-scale Starship since 2023, and only its second trip to orbit. Company officials said Saturday's catch demonstrates the full reusability of a vehicle meant for travel to the moon and Mars.
NASA welcomed the result. The agency is paying billions of dollars for Starship to land Artemis astronauts on the moon later this decade and to help build a permanent lunar base. Musk's ambitions go further: he wants a fleet of Starships to build a city on Mars.
The next steps point to Florida. SpaceX expects to begin launching Starships from Kennedy Space Center within the next few months. That is also the starting point for NASA's next Artemis mission, Artemis III, which will skip the moon and stay in orbit around Earth so crews can practice with lunar landers. Its four astronauts will try to dock their capsule with both Starship and Blue Origin's Blue Moon, since the two companies will take turns delivering crews to the lunar surface. NASA is targeting as soon as 2028 for Artemis IV, which would be humanity's first moon landing since the Apollo era more than half a century ago. The booster investigation is the open question to watch.
Citations marquantes
Can you believe it?— Dan Huot, SpaceX commentator
The booster's engines stopped firing too soon on the way down, and its guidance system automatically triggered its self-destruction.— Kate Tice, SpaceX (paraphrased)
Envie de l'histoire complète ?
Lire l'original sur BayToday ↗