Each summer, the freezer aisle becomes a quiet battleground between pleasure and intention. A registered dietitian, Lucy Diamond of the NHS weight management provider Oviva, offers a measured guide through that tension — not by forbidding ice cream, but by illuminating the choices that allow enjoyment without abandoning one's health. In a culture that tends toward extremes of indulgence or denial, her counsel is a reminder that wisdom often lives in the middle: read the label, shorten the ingredient list, and treat the treat as a treat.
Six healthier ice cream picks for guilt-free summer treats, according to dietitian
Healthier doesn't mean unlimited consumption is advisable
Mark
So the dietitian is saying ice cream is fine, just pick the right kind. But how much difference does it actually make if someone's eating ice cream regularly?
Mimi
It makes a real difference. A Halo Top serving is 127 calories versus 250 for Ben & Jerry's—that's almost double. Over a week, if someone's having ice cream three times, that's 375 calories saved. For someone trying to lose weight, that's meaningful.
Luke
But we should note—the source doesn't say how often people should eat ice cream, or what "moderation" actually means in servings per week. The dietitian says treat it as a treat, but that's vague.
Mark
What about the processed ingredients in the low-calorie brands? That seemed like a real concern.
Mimi
It is. The dietitian points out that when you remove fat, manufacturers add stevia, emulsifiers, and other additives. So you're trading one problem for another—fewer calories, but more processing.
Luke
Right, and she doesn't quantify the health impact of those additives. She flags it as something to watch, but there's no data in the piece about whether those chemicals are actually harmful at the levels used in ice cream.
Mark
What surprised me most was the sorbet warning. That seems counterintuitive.
Mimi
Exactly. People see "fruit" and assume it's healthy. But sorbet is basically frozen sugar water with fruit flavoring. Some sorbets have more sugar than ice cream because there's no fat to balance it out.
Luke
Though the source doesn't give us a specific comparison—we don't see a sorbet's nutrition label next to an ice cream's. It's asserted but not demonstrated.
Mark
So the practical takeaway is: read the label, pick gelato or low-calorie brands if you want to indulge more often, and treat premium ice cream and sundaes as rare occasions.
Mimi
And frozen yogurt or fruit lollies if you want something that actually has some nutritional benefit—probiotics, lower calories, less sugar.
Luke
As long as we're clear that "healthier" here means lower in calories and sugar relative to traditional ice cream, not that any of these are nutritionally dense foods. They're all treats.
O Pulso
- Ice cream is engineered to be irresistible, and a single serving can consume a quarter of a person's daily calorie allowance — making mindless indulgence a genuine health risk over time.
- Premium brands like Ben & Jerry's and Magnum bars can deliver 250–280 calories per serving with high saturated fat, while loaded sundaes can breach 800 calories with almost no nutritional return.
- Gelato, low-calorie high-protein brands like Halo Top, and no-added-sugar options like Yeo Valley offer meaningfully lower calorie and fat counts — but come with their own caveats around heavy processing and misleading portion labelling.
- Frozen yogurt lollies, plant-based alternatives, and fruit-based ice lollies extend the range of lighter choices, with some options as low as 42 calories per serving.
- The navigation toward resolution is not abstinence but literacy — shorter ingredient lists, honest portion awareness, and the understanding that even 'healthier' options require moderation.
Each summer, the freezer aisle becomes a quiet battleground between pleasure and intention. A registered dietitian, Lucy Diamond of the NHS weight management provider Oviva, offers a measured guide through that tension — not by forbidding ice cream, but by illuminating the choices that allow enjoyment without abandoning one's health. In a culture that tends toward extremes of indulgence or denial, her counsel is a reminder that wisdom often lives in the middle: read the label, shorten the ingredient list, and treat the treat as a treat.
Ice cream arrives in summer like an old friend — and for most people, refusing it entirely is neither realistic nor desirable. The real question is whether it's possible to indulge without quietly undermining your health. Lucy Diamond, a registered dietitian and clinical director at the NHS weight management provider Oviva, believes it is — but only with intention.
Her starting point is philosophical: food should not be demonised. Ice cream is woven into how people live, from beach trips to holiday desserts. The goal is smarter choices, not elimination. That means understanding which options offer more nutrition per calorie — and which ones quietly deliver a quarter of your daily allowance in a single scoop.
Gelato is her first recommendation. Made with more milk than cream and typically from natural ingredients, it contains less fat and sugar than traditional ice cream. A 100ml serving of Remeo pistachio gelato runs to 132 calories and 5.6g of fat, compared to 165 calories and 11.2g of fat in a comparable luxury dairy ice cream. Low-calorie, high-protein brands like Halo Top offer another route — a 100g serving contains 127 calories against Ben & Jerry's 250 — but Diamond urges caution: these products are heavily processed, and their marketing habit of listing 'calories per tub' is designed to make eating the whole thing seem acceptable.
No-added-sugar options, frozen yogurt lollies, plant-based alternatives, and fruit-based ice lollies round out the lighter end of the spectrum. A Tesco Rocket Lolly contains just 42 calories. A strawberry frozen yogurt lolly delivers probiotics and calcium alongside its 46 calories. These are not deprivation foods — they are genuine alternatives for people paying attention.
On the other side of the ledger, Diamond flags premium brands, chocolate-coated bars, loaded sundaes, and — perhaps surprisingly — sorbets, which can carry more sugar than ice cream itself despite their fruit-forward reputation. A loaded ice cream sundae can easily exceed 600 to 800 calories with little nutritional value to show for it.
The through-line is moderation and awareness. Check the label. Favour shorter ingredient lists. Treat even the better options as occasional pleasures rather than dietary staples. Summer doesn't require guilt — but it does require paying attention.
Ice cream arrives in summer like an old friend—cold, smooth, and almost impossible to refuse. But that moment of pleasure often comes with a whisper of guilt, especially if you're paying attention to what you eat. The problem is straightforward: most ice cream is engineered to be irresistible, which means it's usually loaded with sugar, fat, and calories that add up fast. A single serving can contain a quarter of your daily calorie allowance, and most people don't stop at one serving.
Lucy Diamond, a registered dietitian and clinical director for innovation at the NHS weight management provider Oviva, doesn't believe in deprivation. Ice cream, she points out, is woven into how people live—a treat at the beach, a way to cool down after a hot day, part of holiday desserts. The goal isn't to eliminate it but to make smarter choices when you do indulge. "If you're hoping to take more control of your health and feel confident, happy and healthy, it's not about demonising food," she says. The key is treating ice cream as an occasional pleasure, not a dietary staple, and knowing which options give you more nutrition for your calories.
Gelato is a straightforward upgrade. Made with more milk than cream and typically from natural ingredients, gelato contains less sugar and fat than traditional ice cream. A 100ml serving of Remeo pistachio gelato, available at major UK supermarkets for around £6, contains 132 calories, 5.6g of fat, and 13g of sugar. Compare that to M&S Collection Pistachio Luxury Ice Cream at 165 calories, 11.2g of fat, and 10.5g of sugar per 100ml, and the difference becomes clear. The trade-off is price—gelato costs more, so Diamond suggests watching for sales and treating it as a genuine indulgence.
Low-calorie, high-protein brands like Halo Top and Oppo Brothers market themselves as alternatives for people watching their intake. These products often use stevia instead of refined sugar, which can be useful for people managing blood sugar levels or dealing with pre-diabetes. A 100g serving of Halo Top Gooey Brownie contains 127 calories, 3.8g of fat, and 11g of sugar, compared to Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie at 250 calories, 13g of fat, and 27g of sugar. But Diamond raises an important caution: lower calories don't automatically mean healthier. These products are heavily processed, and manufacturers often replace fat with processed alternatives and chemical additives. She also warns against the marketing trick of listing "calories per tub"—it's designed to make people think eating the whole thing is acceptable, which it isn't.
No-added-sugar options like Yeo Valley Organic rely on the natural sweetness of vanilla or fruit instead of added sugars. The strawberry variety contains 76 calories, 1.3g of fat, and 13g of sugar per 100ml. Diamond's advice here is simple: read the ingredient list. The shorter it is, and the more recognizable the components, the better. Frozen yogurt offers a different angle—brands like Claudi & Fin Greek Style Frozen Yogurt Lollies or supermarket own-brand options contain probiotics that support gut health, plus calcium and protein. A single Tesco Strawberry and Yoghurt Lolly has just 46 calories and 1.6g of fat. Plant-based options like Jude's work for people avoiding dairy, though they're not necessarily lower in calories or sugar than dairy ice cream—a Jude's Mint Chocolate contains 152 calories and 15g of sugar per 100ml. Finally, fruit-based ice lollies are often the lowest-calorie option: Tesco Rocket Lollies contain just 42 calories and less than 0.1g of fat.
On the flip side, Diamond identifies several options worth limiting. Premium brands like Ben & Jerry's are calorie-dense—a single serving of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough contains around 280 calories, 15g of fat, and 25g of sugar, which is a substantial chunk of a daily intake. Magnum bars and similar chocolate-coated ice creams combine rich ice cream with a sugary chocolate shell, typically delivering 250 to 280 calories, 16 to 18g of fat, and 20 to 24g of sugar per bar. Ice cream sundaes and loaded cones, while undeniably fun, can easily exceed 600 to 800 calories per serving with little nutritional value. Perhaps most surprisingly, sorbets—which sound healthy because they're fruit-based—are often extremely high in sugar, sometimes more so than ice cream itself. They should be treated as treats, not as a health-conscious alternative.
The through-line in Diamond's advice is moderation and awareness. Ice cream doesn't have to be off-limits, but it requires intentionality. Check the nutrition label, choose options with shorter ingredient lists and lower sugar content, and remember that "healthier" is relative—even the better options should be enjoyed in measured portions as part of a balanced diet. Summer doesn't require guilt, but it does require paying attention.
Citações Notáveis
If you're hoping to take more control of your health and feel confident, happy and healthy, it's not about demonising food.— Lucy Diamond, registered dietitian at Oviva
These options can be enjoyed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. Always check the nutrition label, as even healthier options can vary significantly in their nutritional content.— Lucy Diamond
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em The Sun ↗
Health & Medicine