Seoul Revives 10-Year Fixed Mortgage Plan as Borrowers Flee Rate Locks

Fixed-rate loans fell from 91.5% of new mortgages to 34.2% in a year
Bank of Korea data show borrowers moving sharply toward variable rates despite rising interest rates.
Mark

Why is the FSC bringing this back now?

Mimi

Two Bank of Korea hikes this year raised borrower costs. The plan was meant to launch early this year but got pushed aside by real estate stabilization measures like curbs on multi-home owners.

Mark

And borrowers aren't choosing fixed rates today?

Mimi

Not much. Fixed loans were 91.5% of new mortgages a year earlier and 34.2% in September. Variable rose from 8.5% to 65.8%.

Luke

That tells us what people chose, not why. The cost gap is the likely explanation, but the data doesn't establish it.

Mimi

Fair. The gap is visible at Shinhan, though: 10-year fixed at 4.69%–6.09% against 4.43%–5.84% for six-month variable.

Mark

What would banks get out of offering these?

Mimi

Incentives are under review: exclusion from lending caps, easier capital rules, and lighter early repayment fees for same-bank refinancing.

Luke

Those are options under discussion, not decisions. The FSC itself says it hasn't been decided whether banks will accept its plan.

Mark

Is there doubt about the product itself?

Mimi

One bank official questioned how meaningful a 10-year fix is at current rate levels, though it would have helped when rates were very low.

Luke

That's one unnamed official's view. What's firm is the December timing is described as possible, and the FSC expects a conclusion next month.

  • Borrowers are rushing toward variable-rate loans just as rates climb, leaving them exposed to every new hike.
  • Fixed-rate share collapsed from 91.5% to 34.2% in a single year, a sharp shift that alarms regulators.
  • Ten-year fixed loans price above variable ones, so banks hesitate and most offer only five-year structures.
  • The FSC is weighing lending-cap exclusions and capital relief to coax banks into the market, with a conclusion expected next month.
  • Some bankers doubt the product will matter much at today's rate levels, leaving its success uncertain.

Across South Korea, a familiar question is returning to the table: how a household can plan its life when the cost of its home keeps shifting with the tide of interest rates. The Financial Services Commission has called banks back to revive talks on mortgages that hold their rate for a decade or more, a shelter the market has largely left unbuilt. Its promise rests on a hard arithmetic, since longer certainty costs banks more to fund and so is priced higher, and borrowers, drawn by the lower immediate rate, have turned toward variable loans as the risk quietly grows. Whether the banks will accept the incentives meant to close that gap, and whether a blueprint will take shape in December, remains an open question that will determine how much of the rate risk ordinary families are asked to carry.

On November 11, working-level officials from South Korea's major banks were summoned by the Financial Services Commission to restart a task force on long-term fixed-rate lending. The subject is a mortgage that locks its interest rate for ten years or more, an idea that first aimed at an early-year launch but stalled while the government focused on curbing real estate speculation. Two base-rate hikes from the Bank of Korea this year have since pushed borrowers' payments higher, and the question has returned to the agenda.

The market still leans on shorter products. Most bank mortgages are five-year hybrid or cyclical loans, and only a few lenders, including Shinhan Bank and IBK, offer a ten-year fix. Policy loans reach fixed terms of up to fifty years, which has drawn criticism that private banks lag far behind. The obstacle is price: a decade-long rate must match how banks fund themselves, so it costs more. On November 15, Shinhan's ten-year fixed loan ran 4.69% to 6.09%, while its variable and five-year options sat lower.

Borrowers have voted with their wallets. In September, fixed loans made up just 34.2% of new bank mortgages, down from 91.5% a year earlier, while variable loans climbed to 65.8%. The average variable rate rose to 4.76%, and every further hike adds to what households owe. Long-term fixed loans would move that risk from borrowers onto banks, easing defaults across the system.

To win banks over, the FSC is considering exempting ultra-long fixed loans from lending caps or easing capital rules, and the Korea Institute of Finance has proposed a wider set of changes, including relief on early repayment fees that might otherwise let borrowers refinance cheaply after three years. Some bankers remain skeptical about the product's value at current rates. The FSC expects a conclusion next month, and the design of the incentives will decide whether the product truly arrives and how much it eases the burden on families.

On the afternoon of November 11, working-level officials from South Korea's major banks were called in by the Financial Services Commission to restart a task force on promoting long-term fixed-rate lending. The subject was a mortgage that locks the interest rate for 10 years or longer. According to sources who confirmed the meeting, the discussion centered on how banks could supply such loans. The FSC says a concrete blueprint could emerge as early as December.

The idea is not new. The product was originally aimed at an early-year launch, but talks stalled while the government put real estate stabilization first, including loan curbs on people who own multiple homes. Two Bank of Korea base-rate hikes this year have since pushed up what borrowers owe, and the issue is back on the agenda.

The current market leans on shorter structures. Most bank mortgages in South Korea are five-year hybrid or five-year cyclical products. Only a few lenders, among them Shinhan Bank and IBK Industrial Bank of Korea, offer a 10-year fixed rate. Policy loans, by contrast, include fixed-rate products running up to 50 years, which has drawn criticism that the private sector lags far behind.

Pricing is the obstacle. A rate fixed for over a decade has to match how banks fund themselves, so it costs more than six-month variable or five-year fixed loans. As of November 15, Shinhan Bank's 10-year fixed mortgage ran 4.69% to 6.09% a year. Its six-month variable rate was 4.43% to 5.84%, and its five-year fixed rate was 4.42% to 5.83%. At the top of the range, only the 10-year product crossed 6%.

Borrowers have responded accordingly. Bank of Korea figures show fixed-rate loans made up 34.2% of new mortgages from deposit-taking banks in September, down 57.3 percentage points from 91.5% a year earlier. Over the same period, variable-rate loans rose from 8.5% to 65.8% of the total. Demand has leaned heavily toward the lower immediate rate even as rates rise.

That tilt carries risk. The average rate on new variable-rate mortgages was 4.76% in September, up 0.53 percentage point from 4.23% in May. If rates keep climbing, borrower burdens rise with them. Long-term fixed loans move rate-hike risk from borrowers to banks, which would help reduce default risk across the financial system.

To win bank cooperation, the FSC is weighing incentives. Options include excluding ultra-long-term fixed loans from total lending caps, or counting only a portion of them, and easing capital rules such as risk weights. The Korea Institute of Finance has urged regulatory changes too. In data the FSC submitted to People Power Party Rep. Shin Dong-wook, the institute proposed measures on covered bonds, including a higher recognized limit in loan-to-deposit ratio calculations, a lower discount rate in liquidity coverage ratio calculations, investment incentives under K-ICS, and larger issuance limits. It also proposed a real estate sectoral countercyclical capital buffer with differentiated accumulation requirements, and a higher income deduction cap on interest paid on long-term fixed-rate mortgages.

Early repayment fees are also under review. They are typically waived after three years, so a borrower with a 10-year fixed loan could refinance at a cheaper rate then, defeating the product's purpose. The institute argued for reducing or waiving fees on refinancing within the same institution, which would let banks retain customers while encouraging a move from variable to long-term fixed rates.

Some in banking are doubtful. One bank official said a 10-year fix could have benefited consumers when rates were very low, but questioned how meaningful it would be at current levels. An FSC official said an incentive plan has been prepared internally, but it is undecided whether banks will accept it. The FSC plans more meetings this month and next, with a conclusion expected next month after consultations. In a market where even a 0.1 percentage-point gap can sway choices, the incentive design will decide whether banks join and how much borrowers' burdens actually ease.

We have an incentive plan prepared internally, but it has not been decided whether the banks will accept it.
— FSC official
It's questionable how meaningful a 10-year fixed product would be at current rate levels.
— Bank official
Contattaci Domande frequenti