On a Wednesday in mid-May, the United States Senate stood at a familiar threshold: a question as old as the republic, whether a president may wage war without the consent of Congress. By a single vote, 50 to 49, it declined to advance Senator Jeff Merkley's resolution requiring such authorization for the conflict with Iran, though three Republicans joined Democrats in the attempt. The dispute turns on a clock set by the 1973 War Powers law, passed in the wake of Vietnam, which limits unauthorized military action to sixty days, and on whether a claimed ceasefire stopped that clock or whether ho
Senate Blocks Latest Iran War Powers Measure 50-49, but Republican Support Grows
One vote is the distance now.
Mark
Seven failed votes this year. Why does this one feel different?
Mimi
Because of the margin. It failed 50-49, and a third Republican, Susan Collins, Rand Paul and Lisa Murkowski together, voted to advance it. One vote is the distance now.
Luke
Worth being careful, though. It still failed. Closer is not the same as passing, and the reporting doesn't say any other Republican is wavering.
Mark
What is the actual dispute over the 60-day clock?
Mimi
The 1973 law gives a president 60 days before he must end the action, seek authorization, or request a 30-day extension. That deadline hit on May 1. Trump said a ceasefire had terminated hostilities, so he considers the clock moot.
Luke
And Merkley says hostilities continue, citing blockades and attacks on ships. Those are his claims as described in the story. The piece doesn't independently assess what is happening on the water.
Mark
Fetterman voted against his own party here.
Mimi
Yes, the one Democrat who did. It offsets one of the Republican defections, which is why the count stays so tight.
Luke
We don't know why he voted that way, since the report gives no explanation. And whether Democrats can keep forcing weekly votes to real effect is untested.
Mark
What does the White House say?
Mimi
That the actions are legal and within the commander-in-chief's power to order limited operations. Some Republicans call the resolutions partisan.
Luke
Both sides' legal claims are stated, not resolved. Nothing here says a court has weighed in.
Der Puls
- A one-vote margin has left the Senate's war powers fight closer than ever, with the outcome hanging on every seat.
- President Trump's claim that a ceasefire ended hostilities has collided with Democrats' insistence that blockades, strikes, and attacks on shipping prove the war is still underway.
- The May 1 sixty-day War Powers deadline has passed into a contested gray zone, and each side is reading the law to suit its own position.
- Republican defections from Paul, Collins, and Murkowski have turned a party-line block into a fragile majority that could still crack.
- Democrats are preparing a fresh floor vote every week until Congress authorizes the war or the fighting stops, promising sustained pressure rather than a single decisive moment.
On a Wednesday in mid-May, the United States Senate stood at a familiar threshold: a question as old as the republic, whether a president may wage war without the consent of Congress. By a single vote, 50 to 49, it declined to advance Senator Jeff Merkley's resolution requiring such authorization for the conflict with Iran, though three Republicans joined Democrats in the attempt. The dispute turns on a clock set by the 1973 War Powers law, passed in the wake of Vietnam, which limits unauthorized military action to sixty days, and on whether a claimed ceasefire stopped that clock or whether hostilities simply continue under another name.
On Wednesday, May 13, the Senate came within a single vote of forcing a reckoning over the war with Iran. Senator Jeff Merkley, an Oregon Democrat, put forward a resolution that would require congressional authorization for the conflict. Nearly every Democrat backed it. Three Republicans, Rand Paul, Susan Collins, and Lisa Murkowski, crossed over to support it, while Pennsylvania Democrat John Fetterman joined Republicans in blocking it. The final tally of 50 to 49 left the measure defeated, but the Republican defections were the closest the effort has come to success.
At the heart of the fight is a deadline. The 1973 War Powers law, written after Vietnam, allows a president to carry out military action for sixty days before he must end it, seek congressional approval, or request a thirty-day extension citing military necessity while pulling back forces. That sixty-day mark arrived on May 1. The same day, President Trump declared that a ceasefire had "terminated" hostilities, arguing the clock no longer applied.
Democrats reject that account. Merkley insists there has been no real cessation of fighting, pointing to the American blockade of Iranian ports, strikes on Iranian ships, and Iran's own blockade of the Strait of Hormuz and attacks on American vessels and tankers. In his view, the constitutional power to declare war rests with Congress, and the president should either seek authorization or stop. Democrats have also warned that the country may be drawn into a lengthy conflict without a clear plan. Republicans and the White House counter that the operations are lawful exercises of the commander-in-chief's authority, and some have dismissed the resolutions as partisan.
Senate Democrats now plan to bring the measure back next week and every week after, until the war ends or Trump comes to Congress. With three Republicans already aligned, the next votes will test whether one more defection, or a shift among Democrats, can finally tip the balance.
On Wednesday, May 13, the U.S. Senate voted 50-49 against advancing a resolution that would require congressional authorization for the war with Iran. The margin was a single vote, and it was the closest the effort has come to success.
The resolution was sponsored by Senator Jeff Merkley, a Democrat from Oregon. Every Democrat but one supported it. Three Republicans also voted to move it forward: Rand Paul of Kentucky, Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska. Democrat John Fetterman of Pennsylvania crossed the other way and voted with Republicans to block it. The third Republican defection is what moved the measure closer to passage even as it failed.
This was the seventh time this year that Senate Republicans have blocked a similar resolution. It was also the first Senate vote since the conflict reached a 60-day deadline on May 1, the point at which the president is supposed to come to Congress about the war.
That deadline comes from the 1973 War Powers law, passed in response to the Vietnam War. Under it, a president can conduct military action for only 60 days before ending it, asking Congress for authorization, or seeking a 30-day extension on grounds of "unavoidable military necessity regarding the safety of United States Armed Forces" while withdrawing forces.
President Donald Trump said on May 1 that a ceasefire had "terminated" hostilities against Iran, which in his view means the clock no longer applies. Democrats reject that reading and say the conflict is continuing. Merkley told reporters before the vote that there is "not a cessation of war hostilities." He pointed to the U.S. blockade of Iranian ports and U.S. strikes on Iranian ships, along with Iran's blockade of the Strait of Hormuz and its attacks on U.S. ships and tankers. "Both sides are still engaged in hostilities," he said, "and so I don't accept that the 60-day clock is suspended."
Democrats argue that the Constitution gives Congress, not the president, the power to declare war, and they have called on Trump to seek authorization to use military force. They have also warned that he may have pulled the country into a long conflict without laying out a clear strategy. House Democrats have introduced their own war powers resolutions, which Republicans have also blocked.
Republicans and the White House say Trump's actions are legal and fall within his authority as commander-in-chief to protect the country through limited military operations. Some congressional Republicans have accused Democrats of filing the resolutions only out of partisan opposition to Trump.
Merkley and other Senate Democrats said they will bring another war powers resolution to the floor next week, and every week after that until the war ends or Trump comes to Congress for authorization. With a one-vote margin and three Republicans already on board, each new vote will show whether a fourth defection, or a change in the Democratic ranks, tips the result.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Both sides are still engaged in hostilities, and so I don't accept that the 60-day clock is suspended.— Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore.
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei Al-Monitor ↗
Politics & Governance