On a bright Wednesday morning in the plains of Castilla-La Mancha, two high-speed trains met in a way that no timetable was meant to allow, and by the end of the week dozens of families across more than twenty countries were waiting for names and answers. Spain, a nation that has built its pride on fast and modern rail, now finds that pride shaken, and its government is being asked not only what went wrong but whether the people responsible for keeping the line safe can still be trusted. The question that hangs over Urda is an old human one: when machines are designed to stop themselves, who s
Sánchez Says Trust in Spain's High-Speed Rail Is 'Broken' After Second Deadly Crash This Year
At least 69 people killed and more than 100 injured, including foreign nationals from at least 23 countries.
Two accidents of this magnitude within a single year
Mark
Sánchez said trust in high-speed rail is broken. That's a striking thing for a prime minister to say.
Mimi
It is, and it follows from the pattern. Two collisions in nine months, both involving a Renfe and an Iryo train, and both on the Madrid to Andalucía route. Forty-six dead at Adamuz, at least 69 now near Urda.
Mark
Puente says the evidence points to Adif's control centre. What does that mean in practice?
Mimi
The LZB system, which automatically stops a train if the track ahead is occupied, had gone down. He said that is common, and that when it fails, decisions pass to people.
Luke
Careful, though. He said evidence points to a failure there, and in the same breath said investigators are still clarifying what happened. That's an early official account, not a finding.
Mark
So the blame isn't settled.
Luke
No. And a human-control failure is one reading. Why the system went down, and what the humans were told, we haven't been given.
Mimi
His framing also puts the weight on the state operator, not on the two train companies.
Mark
Is he likely to resign?
Luke
Unknown. He refused to discuss it and said he'd act if failures are shown. Nothing here says he's going.
Mimi
Meanwhile families from 23 countries are waiting for information, and Sánchez said the foreign toll could grow.
El Pulso
- A Renfe train slammed into the back of a stopped Iryo train near Urda, throwing carriages off the track and leaving at least 69 dead and over 100 hurt.
- The crash has struck a country still grieving the Adamuz collision nine months ago, turning a single tragedy into a pattern that demands explanation.
- Transport Minister Óscar Puente faces mounting calls to resign, and he is refusing to step aside while pointing to a failure in Adif's control centre.
- Investigators are racing to determine whether the LZB signalling outage left human controllers without the safeguards they needed, and the answer will decide who bears the blame.
- With at least 51 foreign nationals believed affected, the investigation is now an international matter, and the government's credibility rests on proving it can act.
On a bright Wednesday morning in the plains of Castilla-La Mancha, two high-speed trains met in a way that no timetable was meant to allow, and by the end of the week dozens of families across more than twenty countries were waiting for names and answers. Spain, a nation that has built its pride on fast and modern rail, now finds that pride shaken, and its government is being asked not only what went wrong but whether the people responsible for keeping the line safe can still be trusted. The question that hangs over Urda is an old human one: when machines are designed to stop themselves, who stands ready when they do not?
Just before nine on Wednesday morning, two high-speed trains were travelling from Madrid toward Andalucía when one ran into the back of the other near Urda. One belonged to the state-owned Renfe and the other to the private operator Iryo. The Iryo train had already stopped, and the impact knocked several carriages from the track.
By Friday, at least 69 people had died and more than 100 were injured. The victims came from at least 23 countries, and officials believed around 51 foreign nationals were affected, a number the prime minister said could grow. Pedro Sánchez told the country that trust in high-speed rail had been broken and promised that the state would work to reach families quickly and to find the cause.
The crash followed the Adamuz collision nine months earlier, which killed 46 people on the same network. Sánchez called two such disasters in one year unacceptable and said the task now was not only to investigate but to ensure that such a tragedy never happens again.
Transport Minister Óscar Puente, under growing pressure to resign, refused to discuss his own position. He said his work was to explain what happened and to act if failures were found. He pointed to a failure in the command and control centre of Adif, the state infrastructure operator, after the LZB signalling system, which automatically halts trains when a line is occupied, had gone down. Such outages, he said, are not unusual, and when they occur controllers must make decisions by hand. He said he still had confidence in the system.
The questions that remain are whether the inquiry confirms a breakdown at Adif's control centre, who would be held responsible, and whether Puente will survive the demands that he step down.
Just before 9am on Wednesday, two high-speed trains were heading from Madrid toward Andalucía when one slammed into the back of the other near Urda, in Castilla-La Mancha. One was operated by the state-owned Renfe, the other by the private company Iryo. The Iryo train had already come to a halt when the Renfe train struck its rear, knocking several carriages off the track.
By Friday, at least 69 people were confirmed dead and more than 100 injured. Spain's prime minister, Pedro Sánchez, spoke publicly and said that trust in high-speed rail had been broken. He said the state was working tirelessly to get information to the victims' families as quickly as possible, and that his government was committed to establishing what caused the crash.
The dead and injured come from well beyond Spain. The victims include people from at least 23 foreign countries. Reporting from Friday put the number of foreign nationals believed affected at at least 51, and Sánchez suggested the figure could rise.
This is the second deadly collision on Spain's high-speed network this year. Nine months earlier, 46 people were killed and dozens injured when two trains, again one from Renfe and one from Iryo, collided on the same line near Adamuz in Andalucía. Sánchez called it unacceptable for a country with such a powerful high-speed system to suffer two accidents of this nature and magnitude within a single year. He said the government's task goes beyond investigating causes: it must also offer solutions so a tragedy of this scale does not happen again.
Shortly after the prime minister spoke, Transport Minister Óscar Puente held a press conference. He is under growing pressure to resign, and he dismissed those calls. His duty now, he said, was to solve problems, clarify what happened and give clear explanations, not to discuss whether he stays in his job. If the investigation finds failures of organisation or control, he said, the government will act, and if individuals are found responsible, action will be taken.
Puente again pointed toward the Madrid control centre of Adif, the state infrastructure operator. At the start of the day's briefing he had said that evidence currently points to a failure within Adif's command and control centre, while adding that investigators are still working to clarify exactly what happened. He said that before the crash the LZB signalling system, which automatically halts a train if the line ahead is occupied, had gone down. Such outages, he stressed, are not at all uncommon. Once the system is down, he explained, control and decision-making revert to humans, as in other transport sectors. He said he still has confidence in the system.
The central question now is whether the investigation confirms a failure at Adif's control centre and who, if anyone, is held responsible. The other open question is whether Puente survives the pressure to step down.
Citas Notables
Public trust in the high-speed system has been broken.— Pedro Sánchez, Spanish prime minister
My duty now isn't to talk about whether or not I carry on with my job; it's to solve the problems, clarify what happened and offer clear explanations.— Óscar Puente, transport minister
Quieres la nota completa?
Lee el original en The Guardian ↗
Politics & Governance