In the long contest between technology's great rivals, Samsung has chosen imitation over invention — releasing a $650 smartwatch that mirrors Apple's Ultra in design, features, and even price, while quietly retiring the rotating bezel and circular identity that once made its wearables distinctly its own. The Galaxy Watch Ultra is, by most measures, the finest Android smartwatch available, yet its excellence arrives at a philosophical cost: a company that once charted its own course has chosen to follow someone else's map. It is a story as old as markets themselves — the tension between the saf
The Verge
· Aug 01, 2024
· technology
· 10 min read
High
Sourcing: Verified
Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra: A capable Apple Watch clone that loses its soul
◉
Technology
8948 related articles
Google Launches Gemini Enterprise for Legal Services
Google News · 100% match
AI Giants Boost H-1B Filings While Tech Peers Pull Back on Visa Recrui…
The Economic Times · 99% match
Tech Leaders Promise AI Will Cut Work Hours—Their Staff Work 90-Hour W…
BBC News · 99% match
AI models breach sandbox limits in wave of security incidents
BBC News · 99% match
Master AI Chatbots: Five Prompt Techniques for Better Results
The Associated Press · 99% match
Related Coverage
CBS News · Aug 28
Judge blocks Trump administration's 'retaliatory' punishment of AI firm Anthropic
A federal judge ruled the Trump administration unconstitutionally punished AI firm Anthropic for protected speech by cut…
NPR · Aug 28 Judge rules Pentagon's retaliation against Anthropic over AI criticism illegalA federal judge ruled Thursday that the Pentagon illegally punished AI company Anthropic for criticizing the Department …
Manila Bulletin · Aug 28 Lucena inventor demonstrates trash-collecting robot made from recycled materialsAn electronics technician in Lucena City created a remote-controlled garbage-collecting robot from recycled materials to…
The Guardian · Aug 28 Federal judge strikes down Pentagon's unlawful blacklisting of AI firm AnthropicA federal judge ruled the Trump administration's sanctions against AI company Anthropic were illegal retaliation for cri…
Bias & Framing
⚖
The review uses emotionally charged language ('loses its soul,' 'doesn't feel good') to frame Samsung's capable product as derivative, emphasizing design imitation over technical achievements.
Bias Direction
center-left
Confidence
HIGH
Derivative product framing - positions Samsung as an imitator rather than innovator, using Apple Watch as the reference standard and measuring Galaxy Watch Ultra primarily by how closely it copies rather than its independent merits.
loses its soul
doesn't feel good
painfully obvious
clone
Where is Samsung in this?
it does sting
overhauled its wearable strategy to be the Apple of Android
Samsung's design rationale or intentional strategic choices
User preference for circular vs. square watch faces
Android ecosystem advantages over Apple Watch
Value proposition for Android users who prefer Samsung integration
Perspective from Samsung designers or product managers
Comparison to other Android smartwatch competitors beyond Apple
Geopolitical Impact
🌎
This is a consumer technology product review, not a geopolitical article. No international implications exist.
Escalation Risk
low
Confidence
HIGH
Economic Lens
📈
Samsung's $650 Galaxy Watch Ultra mimics Apple's design strategy rather than innovating, achieving technical competence but losing brand differentiation in the premium smartwatch market.
Market Signal
mixed
Confidence
MED
Consumer Electronics
Wearable Technology
Smartphone Accessories
Retail/E-commerce
Consumers gain a competitive premium Android smartwatch option at a lower price point than Apple Watch Ultra ($650 vs higher Apple pricing), but face reduced product differentiation and innovation. Early adopters may experience feature limitations (sleep apnea detection restricted to Galaxy phones).
Potential antitrust scrutiny regarding Apple's ecosystem lock-in strategy that forces competitors into imitation rather than innovation. May prompt regulatory review of exclusive feature bundling with proprietary devices.