In the fourth year of a war fought in democracy's name, a former Ukrainian defence minister has broken the political silence around a troubling contradiction: a nation defending its freedom has suspended the very elections that define it. Mykhailo Fedorov, dismissed from his post in July after six months of reform-minded leadership, has publicly demanded that Ukraine find a legal path to hold presidential elections even under martial law — a challenge that lands squarely at President Zelensky's door without ever naming him. The call arrives not as a coup but as a question the war itself has ma
Sacked Ukrainian defence minister demands wartime elections, challenging Zelensky
Democracy cannot be held hostage by Russia
Why does Fedorov's call for elections matter so much right now? Isn't wartime the one time a country needs unified leadership?
That's the argument Zelensky's government would make. But Fedorov is saying the opposite—that suspending democracy for years actually weakens the country because it creates a governance vacuum, breeds corruption, and makes people feel like they're fighting for something that doesn't exist anymore.
So this is really about corruption and accountability, not just elections?
It's both. Fedorov spent his time as defence minister rooting out corruption and trying to make the military more efficient through data and innovation. When he was fired, it looked like the system was rejecting that kind of scrutiny. His call for elections is a way of saying: we need checks on power, even now.
But he was only defence minister for six months. Why did he have so much influence?
Because he actually changed things. The drone gamification system, the Starlink pressure on Musk, the IT Army—these weren't just symbolic gestures. They disrupted Russian operations. People noticed. When he was fired, it felt arbitrary, especially since the tensions were with the military commander, not with him.
What happens if Zelensky ignores this?
That's the real test. Fedorov has already refused other government jobs. He's not going away quietly. If Zelensky doesn't engage with the substance of what he's saying—about governance, democracy, and how to run a war without losing your soul—the pressure will only build.
And the elections themselves? Could they actually happen during martial law?
That's what Fedorov is asking. He's not saying hold them tomorrow. He's saying Ukraine needs to figure out how to do it legally and safely while the war is still on. It's a harder problem than it sounds, but he's right that other democracies have managed it.
Der Puls
- A fired minister breaks wartime political silence, posting a YouTube video that reframes Ukraine's democratic suspension as a contradiction at the heart of the war effort itself.
- Fedorov's dismissal — rooted in deep tensions with army commander Syrskyi — had already triggered nationwide protests, and his refusal of alternative government roles signals he is positioning himself as something more than a disgruntled official.
- Zelensky has not responded, and the absence of any reply to the most direct challenge to his wartime leadership is itself becoming a political fact.
- Meanwhile the war grinds on with lethal symmetry — 17 killed in Ukraine and 9 in Russia in the latest exchanges — as the question of who governs the defence ministry remains unresolved under an acting appointee with little public profile.
- The demand for elections during martial law has no clear legal mechanism yet, but Fedorov's insistence that one must be found is pulling a suppressed national debate into the open.
In the fourth year of a war fought in democracy's name, a former Ukrainian defence minister has broken the political silence around a troubling contradiction: a nation defending its freedom has suspended the very elections that define it. Mykhailo Fedorov, dismissed from his post in July after six months of reform-minded leadership, has publicly demanded that Ukraine find a legal path to hold presidential elections even under martial law — a challenge that lands squarely at President Zelensky's door without ever naming him. The call arrives not as a coup but as a question the war itself has made unavoidable: can a country claim to fight for democracy while indefinitely deferring it?
Ukraine has lived under martial law — and without elections — since Russia's invasion in February 2022. For more than four years, that suspension has gone largely unchallenged in public. On Tuesday, 35-year-old Mykhailo Fedorov ended that silence.
In a video posted to YouTube, the former defence minister argued that democracy cannot be held hostage by war — that Ukraine is fighting precisely to remain a free European state, and that freezing its democratic processes undermines the very cause its soldiers are dying for. He called for a legal, safe, and realistic mechanism to restore elections even during a prolonged conflict. Though he never named Zelensky, the challenge was unmistakable.
Fedorov had been fired in late July, just six months into the job, in a dismissal that surprised many and sparked protests across the country. During his tenure he had built a reputation as a modernizer: pushing anti-corruption reforms inside the defence ministry, using data to evaluate frontline performance, and championing high-tech warfare. He had previously founded Ukraine's volunteer cyber unit, orchestrated a major drone fundraising campaign, and even contacted Elon Musk to disrupt Russia's use of Starlink — a move credited with meaningfully affecting Russian operations.
His removal was widely attributed to tensions with army commander Oleksandr Syrskyi, who was himself later replaced. Zelensky appointed a low-profile intelligence official as acting defence minister and offered Fedorov several alternative roles, including deputy prime minister for military innovation. Fedorov refused them all, saying he would return only as defence minister — a condition that has kept him outside government entirely.
He has not announced any political ambitions, but his public refusal of compromise and his direct call for wartime elections represent the sharpest challenge to Zelensky's leadership since the invasion began. The president has not responded. The drones, meanwhile, keep flying in both directions — 17 people killed in Ukraine and 9 in Russia in the latest exchanges — as the question of democratic legitimacy settles over a country still very much at war.
Ukraine has lived under martial law since Russia's invasion in February 2022, which means elections have been frozen in place for more than four years. On Tuesday, Mykhailo Fedorov, the 35-year-old former defence minister, posted a video to YouTube that upended the political silence around this fact. "Democracy cannot be held hostage by Russia," he said, arguing that Ukraine is fighting precisely to remain a free European state—and that suspending democratic processes contradicts the very thing the country is defending.
Fedorov was fired from his post in late July, just six months after taking the job. The dismissal was unexpected and sparked protests across the country. While he did not name Zelensky in the video, the challenge was unmistakable: he called for a legal, safe, and realistic mechanism to restore full democratic processes even during a prolonged war. He also spoke plainly about what he saw as a systemic crisis of governance and a country afraid of change, with corruption eating away at the war effort itself.
The tensions that led to his removal appear to have run deep. During his tenure, Fedorov had earned a reputation as a reformer and modernizer. He pushed hard against corruption within the defence ministry, used data to analyze and improve frontline performance, and became known for his focus on high-tech warfare and innovation. Before becoming defence minister, he had served as minister of digital transformation and founded the "IT Army of Ukraine," a volunteer cyber unit that launched attacks against Russian targets in the early days of the invasion. Later, he orchestrated a successful fundraising campaign for drones and introduced a gamification system that awarded Ukrainian military units credits for hitting Russian targets. He even reached out to Elon Musk to stop Russia from using Starlink satellites for drone attacks—a move credited with disrupting Russian operations significantly.
But Fedorov's dismissal was widely understood to stem from tensions with Oleksandr Syrskyi, the army commander-in-chief. Weeks of public pressure eventually led to Syrskyi's replacement as well. Zelensky has since appointed Yevgeniy Khmara, a career intelligence official with little political profile, as acting defence minister. The president also offered Fedorov other positions—deputy prime minister for military innovation among them—but Fedorov refused. He said he would return only as defence minister, a condition that effectively kept him out of government.
Fedorov has given no indication of his own political plans, but his refusal to accept alternative roles and his public call for elections during wartime represent the most significant challenge to Zelensky's leadership since the war began. Zelensky has not yet responded to the video. Meanwhile, the fighting continues. Ukraine has intensified long-range attacks across Russia in recent weeks, launching hundreds of drones at oil refineries and warehouses. On Saturday night, about 600 drones struck Moscow in what regional officials called one of the most massive drone attacks in recent memory. Nine people were killed and 23 injured, including a child. In the latest Russian attacks on Ukraine on Tuesday morning, 17 people were killed. The question of who leads Ukraine's defence ministry—and whether the country can hold elections while at war—now sits at the center of a deepening political crisis.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
Ukraine is fighting precisely because we want to remain a free European state— Mykhailo Fedorov, in his YouTube video calling for wartime elections
The country faces a systemic crisis of governance and is scared of change— Mykhailo Fedorov, describing Ukraine's political condition