In the shadow of a war that has reshaped Russia, its richest people have learned a long lesson in silence, and some now quietly weigh a future that might arrive without Vladimir Putin at its center. The memory of the 1990s, when a few men grew vast fortunes and bent politicians to their will, makes that imagined future feel familiar, even alluring, to those who once held sway. Yet for all their private longing, the tycoons remain bound by fear, sanctions and dependence, and few believe they will move while Putin lives. The question left hanging is whether private hopes will ever turn into publ
Russia's Tycoons Quietly Imagine Life After Putin, and a Return to 1990s-Style Oligarchy
They have no cards, they have no game.
Why does it matter what billionaires who stay silent are thinking?
Because they hold nearly $700bn between them, and analysts expect that money to seek political influence once Putin is gone.
What did they actually want, according to the people who talk to them?
Prokopenko says a time when they were listened to, kept their assets and understood the rules. Some also want less repression and more open politics.
Careful, though. This rests on analysts describing private moods. No tycoon is quoted on the record saying this.
Except Melnichenko.
Who didn't call for Putin to go, and whose interview most observers think the Kremlin approved. Why, we don't know.
Ostrovsky insists he was thinking genuinely and speaking for others too, but no one joined him publicly.
And the nickname shift to Ded?
That's one analyst's observation, not a measured trend.
So what's solid?
That they've been silent, that sanctions bite, and that analysts see little chance of action while Putin lives.
El Pulso
- Russia's billionaires sat silent in the Kremlin hall as the invasion of Ukraine began, and that silence has hardened into habit.
- Some tycoons privately dream of a post-Putin order that echoes the freewheeling oligarchy of the 1990s.
- Sanctions and state contracts keep the wealthiest tied to the Kremlin, leaving their money with little political leverage.
- A rare public essay from one magnate hints at change, but no fellow billionaire has dared to back it, and the cash-rich are watched for any move.
In the shadow of a war that has reshaped Russia, its richest people have learned a long lesson in silence, and some now quietly weigh a future that might arrive without Vladimir Putin at its center. The memory of the 1990s, when a few men grew vast fortunes and bent politicians to their will, makes that imagined future feel familiar, even alluring, to those who once held sway. Yet for all their private longing, the tycoons remain bound by fear, sanctions and dependence, and few believe they will move while Putin lives. The question left hanging is whether private hopes will ever turn into public action.
On 24 February 2022, within hours of ordering the invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin gathered Russia's richest men in the Kremlin's Yekaterininsky Hall. They sat bunched along one wall in face masks, pale and sleep-deprived, while Putin sat across the room, keeping his distance. Not one of them spoke on the Kremlin's video.
Their silence reflects decades of lessons. In 2003 Mikhail Khodorkovsky accused Putin of tolerating corruption, and spent a decade in prison. Few have followed him since. Yet some tycoons are now quietly imagining what comes after Putin, a longing shaped by the 1990s, when fortunes appeared overnight and oligarchs steered politicians. Putin tamed them after 2000, and foreign investors recall how those men once swaggered at Davos until he arrived.
Since 2022 the Kremlin has used both carrot and stick. Critics have lost assets, while loyalists have won lavish war contracts. Still, analysts say the money buys them little, since their wealth depends on their ties to Putin. Sanctions keep many from private jets and European harbours. Putin is 74 and shows no sign of leaving, though if he did, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would likely take over as an interim leader.
Analysts see three possible futures: democracy, judged least likely; a harsher autocracy; or a return to elite clans ruling alongside business. Many tycoons, exiles say, would welcome the last. Signs of movement are small, such as befriending security officials, and the wealthiest with liquid cash may be the first to act. A fertiliser magnate, Andrey Melnichenko, recently called for ending one-man rule, though he did not name Putin. No peers publicly joined him. For now, the thinking stays private.
On 24 February 2022, within hours of launching his full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin summoned Russia's richest men to the Kremlin's Yekaterininsky Hall. More than three dozen sat bunched along one wall in Covid face masks; one Russian newspaper reporter called them pale and sleep-deprived. Putin took a seat on the far side of the room, leaving a wide gap between himself and them, and wore no mask. In his usual coded manner, he asked them to show understanding and to work with the government on tools to support production, the economy and jobs. In the Kremlin's own video, not one billionaire spoke.
That silence has become a habit. Over Putin's decades in power, the tycoons have learned what speaking up can cost. In 2003, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then Russia's richest man and a funder of opposition groups, accused Putin of presiding over rampant corruption. He then spent ten years in prison, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement, charges he denied. Few have wanted to follow him.
Yet a BBC analysis, drawing on analysts close to the tycoons' world, suggests some are quietly imagining what comes after Putin. The Economist's Arkady Ostrovsky, who recently spent hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men, says he senses a historic political shift in how the ultra-rich view the country's future.
The nostalgia has a history. After the Soviet collapse in 1991, a class of people grew extraordinarily rich on the end of communism and sought to steer politicians for their own gain. They were called oligarchs, from the Greek for the few who rule. Huge state companies were up for grabs, fortunes appeared almost overnight, and corruption, cronyism and contract killings were common. After Putin was first elected in 2000, he subdued them, helped by a recovering economy and a stronger central government. Bill Browder, once Russia's biggest foreign investor and banned from the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, recalls oligarchs at Davos who strutted around as if they owned the place until Putin arrived, when they turned into subordinate, almost desperate schoolchildren.
Since 2022 the Kremlin has used carrot and stick. Critics of the war have had assets seized; loyalists have received lavish war contracts. Forbes counts 155 Russian billionaires, more than ever, with combined wealth near $700bn (£525bn). Still, analysts say the money buys little. Exiled politician Dmitry Nekrasov says they have no cards and no game, being rich because of their link to Putin rather than the reverse. Abroad, sanctions leave them ostracised: Browder notes they cannot fly private jets or berth yachts in Europe's best harbours.
Putin turned 74 last month and has been in the Kremlin for 25 years. There is no sign of ill health or imminent departure, but asked by Reuters last year whether he would serve until 2036, he said only God knows if his health will hold. If he resigned or died in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would take over, though he has shown no presidential ambitions, probably a reason he was chosen. Analysts see three paths: democracy, which they judge least likely because institutions have been eroded; more autocracy under a successor who would at first be weaker; or a return to 1990s-style oligarchy, ruled by elite clans allied with business. Exiled analyst Alexandra Prokopenko says many tycoons want that last outcome, a time when they were listened to and knew the rules.
Signs of change are small. Nekrasov says some are befriending the right security officials or ministers, but that bolder steps are too dangerous. Those with plenty of liquid cash may play politics; those dependent on state contracts will be too afraid. Prokopenko says tycoons once called Putin Nachalnik (boss), Perviy (first) or VV; now they say Ded, granddad, with a pinch of contempt. She interviewed one who sat on his phone throughout, to frustrate eavesdropping.
A clue came from Andrey Melnichenko, the fertiliser magnate and Russia's eighth richest man, who gave The Economist an interview and wrote an essay this year. He repeated Kremlin lines on the West, but argued for ending one-man rule and engaging more with the world, without calling for Putin to go. Ostrovsky describes tense, heated talks over coffee. Most observers think the Kremlin approved it, in some form, for reasons unknown. No fellow tycoon publicly backed him. Browder says they will not move against Putin while he lives, because they believe he would kill them. For now, the thinking is private, and the test will be whether the cash-rich begin to position themselves.
Citas Notables
They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game.— Alexandra Prokopenko, exiled Russian analyst
They understand that if they were to challenge Putin, he would kill them.— Bill Browder, financier and Putin critic (paraphrased)