At Headingley, Joe Root returned to the England captaincy not with a speech but with a result — an innings victory over Pakistan in three days that carried the weight of months of institutional grief. After Ben Stokes' retirement, a coach's dismissal, and a string of defeats, this was the kind of clean, uncomplicated win that allows a team to exhale. Whether it reveals England's true strength or merely Pakistan's present fragility is a question the coming weeks will answer.
Root's England steamroll Pakistan in three days to start captaincy with crushing win
Pakistan simply could not handle the pace and movement
What does a three-day Test win actually tell you about a team's quality?
Almost nothing, if the opposition is as poor as Pakistan was here. England's seamers were brilliant, yes, but Pakistan didn't show up to compete. You can't learn much about yourself when your opponent is broken.
So why does this matter for Root's captaincy?
Because he needed a win. He needed his team to believe something could work again after months of chaos. Whether it's a real win or a gift win, the effect is the same—it stops the bleeding.
Babar Azam was missing. Does that change how we should read this?
It does. Pakistan without their captain and without their best fast bowlers is not the team that should be judged here. It's a weakened version. The real test comes at Lord's if Babar returns.
What about Jordan Cox's 73 in his second Test—is that significant?
That's the one genuinely bright spot for England beyond the bowling. He looked composed, looked like he belonged. That's the kind of thing that suggests there might be something worth building.
England have won only three of their last eleven Tests. Does one win change that trajectory?
Not really. It's a pause, a reset. But the underlying problems—the coaching change, the uncertainty—those don't disappear because Pakistan collapsed. The real work starts at Lord's.
What would a Pakistan comeback look like?
Honestly? Unlikely. They'd need Babar back and firing, they'd need their bowlers to suddenly find accuracy, and they'd need a pitch that doesn't suit England's seamers. It's possible, but it would be remarkable.
Le Pouls
- England's seamers Robinson and Tongue shared 16 wickets between them, reducing Pakistan to 135 in their second innings and ending the match before the weekend had even begun.
- Pakistan arrived without injured captain Babar Azam and never found their footing — their batting was brittle, their bowling wayward, and their fielding loose throughout.
- Root's return to the captaincy came loaded with expectation after months of turmoil: Stokes retired, McCullum was sacked, and England had won just three of their last eleven Tests.
- The victory, though emphatic, felt incomplete — the sparse atmosphere at Headingley and the weakness of the opposition left open the question of how much this result actually means.
- England lead the series 1-0 and travel to Lord's next week with a chance to seal their first series win since 2024, though Babar Azam's potential return could shift the balance.
At Headingley, Joe Root returned to the England captaincy not with a speech but with a result — an innings victory over Pakistan in three days that carried the weight of months of institutional grief. After Ben Stokes' retirement, a coach's dismissal, and a string of defeats, this was the kind of clean, uncomplicated win that allows a team to exhale. Whether it reveals England's true strength or merely Pakistan's present fragility is a question the coming weeks will answer.
Joe Root walked back into the England captaincy at Headingley and was handed the most comfortable of reintroductions: a win by an innings and 103 runs, completed inside three days. It arrived after months of upheaval — Ben Stokes' retirement from Test cricket, Brendon McCullum's dismissal as coach, and a run of results that had left England winning only three of their last eleven matches. This victory, however straightforward, felt like permission to breathe again.
The seamers carried England home. Ollie Robinson took eight wickets across both innings, and Josh Tongue was devastating after lunch on the final day, finishing with eight for 89. Pakistan, missing their captain Babar Azam through injury, could not cope with the pace and movement on offer. Chasing 238 to make England bat again, they folded for 135. Jofra Archer removed the opener from the eleventh delivery of the innings, and the result was settled from that moment.
England's batters had done their part earlier. Harry Brook made 91, Jordan Cox 73 in only his second Test, and Root himself contributed 66 as England posted 409. Root had won the toss and chosen to field, and Robinson trapped the first Pakistan batter lbw with the very first ball of the match — a statement that set the tone for everything that followed.
Yet the victory came with an asterisk. Pakistan were diminished — captainless, wayward with the ball, and loose in the field. The Headingley crowd, usually alive when Pakistan visit, was subdued. This was a win that said little about England's ceiling and rather more about Pakistan's current floor.
Root is now England's most successful Test captain by wins, with 27 victories from 66 matches. England lead the three-match series 1-0 and can secure their first series win since 2024 at Lord's next week. Pakistan have not won a Test series in England in thirty years, and a whitewash looks a real possibility. Babar Azam's return could offer them something, and Lord's may offer a more neutral pitch — but it would take something extraordinary for Pakistan to recover from here.
Joe Root walked back into the England captain's office on a Friday afternoon at Headingley with the kind of welcome any leader would want: his team had just dismantled Pakistan by an innings and 103 runs in three days, a result so complete it barely qualified as a contest. This was Root's second turn at the helm, and it arrived after months of institutional turbulence—Ben Stokes had retired from Test cricket, Brendon McCullum had been sacked as coach, and England had won only three of their last eleven matches. The weight of that chaos made this particular victory feel like something more than just a cricket match.
England's seamers did the real talking. Ollie Robinson finished with eight wickets across both innings for a career-best haul of 80 runs conceded. Josh Tongue took three wickets in two overs after lunch on the final day and ended with eight for 89. Pakistan, arriving without their injured captain Babar Azam, simply could not handle the pace and movement. In their second innings, needing 238 runs to force England to bat again, they managed only 135. Jofra Archer removed Imam-ul-Haq from the eleventh delivery of the innings, and from that moment the outcome was never in doubt.
Root had won the toss and chosen to field. Robinson trapped Azan Awais lbw with the first ball of the match—a statement of intent that set the tone for everything that followed. England's batters had contributed their share: Harry Brook made 91, Jordan Cox 73 in only his second Test, and Root himself 66. The total of 409 gave England's bowlers a cushion they never needed to use. By lunch on Friday, Pakistan were already three wickets down, and it was clear the match would finish before the weekend arrived.
What made this victory feel hollow, though, was the quality of the opposition. Pakistan's batters, stripped of their captain and facing conditions that suited England's four-seamer attack, never competed. Their bowlers were wayward. Their fielding was loose. The atmosphere at Headingley, usually electric when Pakistan visited, was muted—no horns, no flags, barely any chanting in support of the tourists. This was a win, yes, but not the kind that tells you much about where England actually stands. The Stokes-McCullum regime, for all its flaws, would have enjoyed a victory this straightforward.
Root is now the record-holder for most Test wins as England captain. This was his 27th success from 66 matches. Four years after his first stint as captain left him, by his own admission, broken, he could not have asked for an easier reintroduction to the job. England lead the three-match series 1-0 and can secure their first series win since 2024 by winning at Lord's next week. Pakistan have not won a Test series in England in thirty years, and on this evidence, they will be fortunate to avoid a 3-0 whitewash.
There is one small variable that might change the complexion of things. Babar Azam, Pakistan's captain, missed this Test because of a hand injury. He could return at Lord's. Previous pace-bowling weapons like Shaheen Shah Afridi and Naseem Shah are out of the Test picture entirely, so there is limited room for Pakistan to strengthen their squad. The pitch at Lord's could be different—less helpful to England's seamers, more of a leveller. Pakistan have a history of being unpredictable. But it would take a remarkable turnaround for them to recover from this and level the series. For now, Root and England have their win, their breathing room, and a chance to build something from the wreckage of the last few months.
Citations marquantes
Pakistan, without injured captain Babar Azam, were unable to cope with England's seamers— Match analysis