Republicans Block Impeachment Push Against Hegseth; Pentagon Claims 'Total Victory'

These are not high crimes. This is the job, and it's the job well done.
Hegseth rejected the impeachment articles at a press conference after the House referred them to committee.
Mark

So the impeachment didn't fail on the merits, did it? It was referred to committee.

Mimi

Right. The 211-204 vote sent Massie's eight articles to the Judiciary Committee, which keeps them from reaching a floor vote. The Pentagon calls that total victory.

Luke

Worth saying plainly: a referral isn't an acquittal. Trump's word "exoneration" is his characterization, not what the vote decided.

Mark

Hegseth says every operation was lawful. Is that established?

Mimi

It's his account. He says each was ordered, notified to Congress and carried out properly. The articles allege the opposite on the constitution.

Luke

And this reporting doesn't adjudicate that. We have two assertions, not a finding.

Mark

Democrats lost by seven. Eleven didn't vote.

Mimi

Yes, and some were frustrated. Stansbury says she was held up by a traffic incident and a police bus escort and arrived as the vote closed.

Luke

Though we don't know why the others were absent. Ocasio-Cortez herself said she didn't know. And absences alone don't prove the outcome would have flipped.

  • A seven-vote margin decided whether a sitting defense secretary would face a floor impeachment vote, and several Democrats were absent when it mattered.
  • Massie's eight articles accuse Hegseth of constitutional violations in the Iran war and other operations, and the Pentagon calls them baseless and a sham.
  • The articles were sent to the Judiciary Committee, where the Pentagon says it will end the matter, but the referral is procedural and carries no verdict.
  • Trump celebrated the outcome as an exoneration, while Democrats, who take the House in January, face the uncomfortable sting of absences that reshaped the vote.

On a Tuesday in November, the House of Representatives chose not to bring Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth before a floor vote on impeachment, sending Thomas Massie's eight articles of charges to committee by a 211-204 margin. The articles accused him of repeatedly breaking the constitution through the war with Iran and other military operations, and Hegseth answered that these actions were lawful, ordered and reported, and simply the work of soldiers doing their duty. The procedural step settles nothing about guilt, yet it marks a moment where a question of accountability for war-making was pushed into quieter rooms, while the larger contest over who will govern the House in January waits just beyond the horizon.

On Tuesday the House voted 211-204 to send Thomas Massie's eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee. The motion effectively blocked, for now, any floor vote on removing him. The articles charged that Hegseth had repeatedly violated the constitution in his conduct of the Iran war and other conflicts.

The Pentagon moved quickly. Spokesman Sean Parnell called the referral a total victory and described the articles as baseless, promising that facts would prevail once the matter reached committee. Hegseth himself rejected the charges, insisting that the operations against Iran, the cartels, Maduro and Yemen were lawful, ordered by the commander-in-chief, notified to Congress and carried out by American troops. These were not high crimes, he said, but the job, well done. President Trump celebrated online, declaring that Democrats had miserably failed.

The margin was narrow, and Democrats were left frustrated that several of their own did not vote. Some were held up by a traffic incident and a police escort on the way to the Capitol, arriving after the vote had closed. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said a vote decided by attendance is hard and hurts. Strictly speaking, the vote was only a procedural referral, not a judgment on the charges.

The same day brought other shifts on Capitol Hill. House Republicans chose Jim Jordan to lead them next Congress, and Democrats prepare to take the House in January. For Hegseth, the articles now rest in committee, where the Pentagon expects them to end.

On Tuesday, the House of Representatives voted 211-204 to send Thomas Massie's eight articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to the Judiciary Committee. The motion to refer effectively killed, for now, any chance of a floor vote on removing him. The articles accused Hegseth of repeatedly violating the constitution in his handling of the Iran war and other conflicts around the world.

The Pentagon wasted no time. Spokesman Sean Parnell called the referral "total victory" for Hegseth, the Department of War and the American warfighter. He described the articles as baseless and said the Pentagon looks forward to ending what he called a sham impeachment in the committee room, where, he said, facts will prevail and the distraction can be put to rest.

Hegseth himself held a press conference and rejected the charges. Iran, the cartels, Maduro and Yemen, he said, were all lawful operations, ordered by the commander-in-chief and then by himself, notified to Congress and carried out by American troops. He said the military destroyed the capabilities of terror regimes, sank boats carrying drugs toward American communities, and put a narco dictator in handcuffs. In his words, these were not high crimes but the job, well done.

President Trump celebrated on social media, writing that the Democrats' attempt had "miserably FAILED" and that every Republican except Massie, whom he called a major loser, had voted for Hegseth. He credited victories in Venezuela and Iran and strong military recruitment numbers, and called the outcome an exoneration of a great American patriot. Strictly speaking, the vote was a procedural referral, not a verdict on the charges.

The margin was seven votes, and Democrats were frustrated that several of their own did not cast ballots. CNN's Jake Tapper listed eleven who did not vote: Julia Brownley, Lou Correa, Chris van Hollen, Steven Horsford, Jonathan Jackson, Nancy Pelosi, Brittany Pettersen, Melanie Stansbury, Haley Stevens, Marilyn Strickland and Frederica Wilson. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez told reporters she did not know why people were absent, noting that someone might have a health issue, but that a vote decided on attendance is hard and "hurts." Stansbury's office said she and other members were blocked from reaching the Capitol by a traffic incident and a police escort of a bus. By the time she reached the chamber, the vote had closed, and she filed a report of her "NO" vote, documented in the Congressional Record.

The day brought other shifts on Capitol Hill. House Republicans chose Jim Jordan of Ohio as their leader for the next Congress, 106-73 over Steve Scalise in a closed-door vote. Jordan will lead the GOP from January, when Democrats take control of the House, and he succeeds Speaker Mike Johnson, who did not run and praised Jordan as a longtime friend and a mentor from his early days in Congress. In the Senate, Republicans re-elected John Thune of South Dakota unopposed as minority leader, while Democrats prepare for a majority of at least ten seats.

Elsewhere, nine members of the Kennedy family sued the Trump administration to stop a 250-foot triumphal arch planned near Arlington National Cemetery. Their complaint says it would obstruct the Kennedy gravesites and the JFK Eternal Flame, and cast shadows on the graves in the early morning, when the family traditionally visits. A federal judge on 6 November barred construction from starting for 14 days. Separately, a federal judge allowed Trump's $10bn defamation suit against the BBC to proceed.

For Hegseth, the articles now sit in the House Judiciary Committee, where the Pentagon expects them to end. Democrats take the House in January.

The referral of these baseless impeachment articles to the House Judiciary Committee marks total victory for Secretary Hegseth.
— Sean Parnell, Pentagon spokesman
These are not high crimes. This is the job, and it's the job well done.
— Pete Hegseth, defense secretary
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte? Das Original lesen bei The Guardian ↗
Kontakt FAQ