For the second time in as many years, the walls of JK Lon Hospital in Kota have witnessed what no institution devoted to new life should witness: the deaths of infants who had barely drawn breath. Nine newborns, none older than four days, died within a span of forty-eight hours, reopening wounds that had never fully healed after 107 such deaths at the same facility the year before. The Rajasthan government has moved to investigate, but the deeper question the tragedy poses is one that committees and directives alone cannot easily answer — how a pattern of loss becomes permissible enough to rep
Rajasthan orders probe into deaths of 9 newborns at Kota hospital
Nine newborns aged 1-4 days died at the hospital within 48 hours; the same facility recorded 107 infant deaths in the previous year.
Nine infants died in 48 hours at a hospital where 107 had died the year before.
Mark
Why is this happening again at the same hospital? Didn't they investigate last year?
Mimi
They did investigate, but clearly the problems weren't fixed. The government is now looking at staffing, equipment, medicines—the basic infrastructure of care.
Luke
We don't actually know what killed these nine babies yet. The committee hasn't visited. We're seeing a response, but not an explanation.
Mark
What was different this time that prompted such a fast government response?
Mimi
The repetition itself. A year ago, 107 deaths. Now nine more. It became impossible to ignore or delay.
Luke
Though we should note—107 deaths in a year at a hospital is a different scale than nine in 48 hours. Both are serious, but the comparison doesn't quite work the same way.
Mark
What does the Human Rights Commission visit add that the government committee doesn't?
Mimi
Independence, theoretically. They're not part of the health ministry. They can talk to police, administrators, everyone.
Luke
Can they, though? Or do they have the same access and constraints as any other state body? The source doesn't tell us their actual power.
Mark
And the BJP committee—is that just politics?
Mimi
It's partly politics, yes. But it's also a way to keep pressure on the government, to make sure the investigation doesn't disappear quietly.
Luke
It's worth noting the BJP is using the 107 figure from last year to make a political point. That's fair criticism, but it's also a political move, not an independent investigation.
O Pulso
- Nine infants between one and four days old died at Kota's JK Lon Hospital within a single day and a half, reopening a crisis the state had promised to address after 107 deaths at the same facility just a year prior.
- The recurrence has exposed a system under strain — questions of understaffing, missing equipment, and medicine shortages now hang over not just one hospital but Rajasthan's entire medical education network.
- The state government scrambled to project urgency: a four-member probe committee was dispatched with a three-day deadline, and every medical college principal in Rajasthan was put on notice to tighten newborn care.
- The Human Rights Commission is set to descend on the hospital December 14, broadening scrutiny to include police, administrative, and municipal officials — a signal that accountability is being sought beyond the ward.
- The opposition BJP, pointing to the grim arithmetic of 107 deaths followed by nine more, formed its own parallel committee and accused the ruling Congress government of failing to learn anything from the previous tragedy.
For the second time in as many years, the walls of JK Lon Hospital in Kota have witnessed what no institution devoted to new life should witness: the deaths of infants who had barely drawn breath. Nine newborns, none older than four days, died within a span of forty-eight hours, reopening wounds that had never fully healed after 107 such deaths at the same facility the year before. The Rajasthan government has moved to investigate, but the deeper question the tragedy poses is one that committees and directives alone cannot easily answer — how a pattern of loss becomes permissible enough to repeat itself.
Nine newborns died at JK Lon Hospital in Kota between Wednesday night and Thursday afternoon — five in a single evening, four more by the following day. All were between one and four days old. The deaths carried the weight of repetition: just a year earlier, the same hospital had drawn national attention when 107 infants died within its walls.
By Friday, the Rajasthan government was moving to contain the damage. Health Minister Raghu Sharma announced a four-member investigative committee, led by medical education commissioner Shivangi Swarnkar, with a mandate to examine staffing, equipment, and medicine availability at the hospital. The committee was given three days to report back. Sharma also issued a directive to the principals of every medical college in the state, signaling that the problem was being treated as systemic rather than isolated.
The Human Rights Commission of Rajasthan announced it would visit the hospital on December 14, with plans to meet not only hospital staff but a wide range of district and state officials — an unusually broad sweep of administrative accountability.
The opposition BJP was unsparing. Party chief Satish Poonia drew a direct line between the 107 deaths of the previous year and the nine of this week, accusing the Congress-led government of having learned nothing. The BJP assembled its own visiting committee, and the political contours of the crisis sharpened: a government racing to demonstrate action, an opposition demanding answers, and nine brief lives at the center of it all.
Nine newborns died at JK Lon Hospital in Kota between Wednesday night and Thursday afternoon—five in the darkness of one evening, four more by daylight the next day. All were between one and four days old. The deaths arrived like a recurrence, a pattern the state had seen before: a year earlier, the same hospital had become a national story when 107 infants died within its walls.
On Friday, the Rajasthan government moved to contain the crisis. Health Minister Raghu Sharma announced the formation of a four-member investigative committee, led by medical education commissioner Shivangi Swarnkar, tasked with visiting the hospital and examining each infant death. The committee's mandate was broad: to assess staffing levels and availability, to inventory medical equipment, to verify that medicines were on hand and accessible. Sharma gave them three days to report back to the state.
The investigation was not the only response. Sharma also issued a directive to every principal of every medical college in Rajasthan, instructing them to exercise heightened vigilance in the care of newborns. The message was clear: this was not a problem confined to one facility. The state's entire medical education apparatus was being put on notice.
Parallel to the government's action, the Human Rights Commission of Rajasthan announced its own visit. Commission secretary B L Meena and registrar Omi Purohit would arrive at the hospital on December 14, and they would not limit themselves to the ward. They planned to meet with the divisional commissioner, the inspector general of police, the district collector, the superintendent of police, the chief municipal health officer, and other officials—a broad sweep of the state's administrative machinery.
The opposition BJP seized on the moment. Party chief Satish Poonia pointed to the arithmetic of failure: 107 infants dead in the same hospital just twelve months prior, and now nine more in a single day and a half. He accused the Congress-led state government of learning nothing from the previous tragedy. The BJP formed its own committee—deputy Leader of Opposition Rajendra Rathore, state general secretary and MLA Madan Dilawar, MP Jaskaur Meena, and MLA Sandeep Sharma—and announced they too would visit the hospital. The political dimension of the crisis had crystallized: a government scrambling to demonstrate action, an opposition demanding accountability, and nine dead infants at the center of the argument.
Citações Notáveis
The government took no lessons from last year's deaths, and now nine infants have died again— Rajasthan BJP chief Satish Poonia
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em The Indian Express ↗
Politics & Governance