Probation for D.C. Shooting Suspect Sparks White House Attack on City's Youth Sentencing Law

A boy playing basketball at a recreation center was struck in the leg during the shooting.
A boy playing basketball was struck in the leg.
Prosecutors say Darius Drew's gunfire in a Northwest D.C. neighborhood wounded a child at a recreation center.
Mark

Why is this one case drawing a White House statement?

Mimi

Because it fits an argument already underway. Jeanine Pirro asked the D.C. Council in August 2025 to overhaul the Youth Rehabilitation Act, and she cited a similar probation case then.

Mark

What actually happened in the courtroom?

Mimi

Judge Jennifer Di Toro suspended a two-year sentence and ordered 18 months of supervised probation, over prosecutors' objection. They wanted five years.

Luke

Worth noting the shooting details are prosecutors' account. Drew pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license, but the more-than-20-rounds figure and the alley video come from the government's evidence.

Mark

And the boy?

Mimi

He was playing basketball at a recreation center and was struck in the leg. The source says nothing more about his condition.

Luke

Right, so we don't know how he is now.

Mark

What does the law allow?

Mimi

For crimes committed before age 25, sentences below mandatory minimums and possibly set-aside convictions. Murder and the most serious sexual abuse offenses are excluded.

Luke

Pirro's 96% eligibility figure comes from her own office. And the White House claim that crime is down and the 19,000 arrests are its own statements too. The piece offers no independent check.

Mark

Has the judge or Council responded?

Mimi

Fox says it reached out to both. No response is included.

  • Over twenty rounds were fired in a Northwest Washington alley, and a boy at a recreation center was hit in the leg.
  • Prosecutors sought five years in prison, but the judge suspended a two-year sentence over their objection.
  • The White House has called the ruling a sign of soft-on-crime policy and points to its task force's arrests as a counterweight.
  • U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro is again pressing the D.C. Council to overhaul the Youth Rehabilitation Act.
  • The defendant walked free after nearly six months in custody, and the debate over the law is now reignited.

On a May afternoon in Northwest Washington, a young man of nineteen, according to prosecutors, fired more than twenty rounds into a neighborhood where children were playing, and a boy shooting baskets at a recreation center was struck in the leg. Months later, a judge chose mercy under a law the city wrote for people still growing into adulthood, setting aside a prison term the government had sought. The case lands at an old crossing of two convictions: that young offenders can change, and that a community is owed a reckoning for harm. It now stands as a fresh test of how a city balances those claims, and of who gets to decide where the line falls.

On May 11, prosecutors say, a 19-year-old named Darius Drew rode a Lime bike into an alley in Northwest Washington and opened fire on a parked car, then toward a nearby house. Shots were logged by ShotSpotter, and a boy playing basketball at a recreation center was struck in the leg. By the end, prosecutors counted more than twenty rounds. Police arrested Drew on May 22 and later found two firearms, ammunition, and quantities of suspected narcotics and marijuana at his home.

In August, Drew pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license. Prosecutors asked for five years. Superior Court Judge Jennifer Di Toro instead suspended a two-year sentence and imposed 18 months of supervised probation under the Youth Rehabilitation Act, over the government's objection. He walked out after nearly six months in custody.

The White House responded sharply, with spokeswoman Lauren Bis calling the outcome a slap on the wrist and pointing to the Safe and Beautiful Task Force's more than 19,000 arrests as proof of progress. The law at the heart of the fight was expanded by the D.C. Council in 2018. It allows eligible offenders who committed crimes before 25 to receive sentences below mandatory minimums and potentially have convictions set aside, excluding murder and the most serious sexual abuse.

Pirro had warned the Council more than a year earlier, citing another case in which a 19-year-old received probation after shooting someone aboard a Metrobus. Her office noted that 96% of defendants under 25 receiving felony sentences from 2022 through 2024 were eligible under the act. Fox News Digital has sought comment from the Council and the judge's office, and the Drew ruling now becomes another chapter in the debate over whether the law will change.

On May 11, according to prosecutors, a 19-year-old named Darius Drew rode a Lime bike into an alley in Northwest Washington. Surveillance video, they said, captured him firing at a parked car. The ShotSpotter gunfire detection system logged 10 shots. Seconds later, he fired toward a nearby house. A boy playing basketball at a recreation center was hit in the leg.

By the time the shooting ended, prosecutors said, Drew had fired more than 20 rounds into the neighborhood. The government's evidence placed the gunfire at two locations. He was arrested May 22. Investigators later found two firearms, ammunition and large amounts of suspected narcotics and marijuana at his home.

Drew pleaded guilty Aug. 10 to aggravated assault and carrying a pistol without a license. Prosecutors asked for five years in prison. Superior Court Judge Jennifer Di Toro instead suspended a two-year sentence and ordered 18 months of supervised probation. She did so under the Youth Rehabilitation Act, over the government's objection, according to federal prosecutors. They had also opposed his release. He walked out Friday after nearly six months in custody.

The White House reacted sharply. Spokeswoman Lauren Bis told Fox News Digital the case shows "the insanity" of the city's soft-on-crime policies, which she said let adults take a slap on the wrist for dangerous crimes like firing twenty rounds into a community. She added that President Trump's Safe and Beautiful Task Force has driven down violent crime in the capital despite those policies. The White House said the task force has made more than 19,000 arrests, including murderers, sex offenders, drug traffickers and other violent criminals.

The Youth Rehabilitation Act is the center of the dispute. The D.C. Council expanded it in 2018. As U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro described it, the law lets eligible offenders who committed their crimes before turning 25 receive sentences below otherwise applicable mandatory minimums, and potentially have their convictions set aside. Murder and the most serious sexual abuse offenses are excluded.

Pirro had pressed the Council on this more than a year earlier. In an Aug. 6, 2025, letter, she urged lawmakers to overhaul the act, citing another 19-year-old who received probation after shooting someone in the chest aboard a Metrobus. That defendant pleaded guilty to two offenses carrying five-year mandatory minimums and got probation after four months in jail awaiting trial. "This sentence was a legal sentence only because he was sentenced under the YRA," she wrote.

Pirro argued the law needs changes to balance rehabilitation with accountability. Her office reported that 96% of defendants under 25 who received felony sentences in D.C. Superior Court from 2022 through 2024 were eligible for sentencing under the act.

Fox News Digital said it contacted the D.C. Council and Judge Di Toro's office for comment. The Drew ruling now adds a fresh case to the argument over whether, and how, the Council will revisit the law.

The case illustrates the insanity of Washington, D.C.'s soft-on-crime policies.
— Lauren Bis, White House spokeswoman
This sentence was a legal sentence only because he was sentenced under the YRA.
— Jeanine Pirro, U.S. Attorney, in an Aug. 6, 2025 letter
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en Fox News ↗
Contáctanos FAQ