Prabowo Apologises to Malaysia and Singapore as Indonesian Haze Crosses Borders

Sixteen firefighters died and many more were injured battling the fires; the haze has affected communities in Malaysia and Singapore.
Sixteen people died, and two helicopters were lost, he said.
Prabowo described the cost of fighting fires that have burned for nearly four months.
Mark

An apology at a summit is unusual. Why does this one matter?

Mimi

Because it comes with specifics. Prabowo named the haze's reach into Malaysia and Singapore and paired the apology with numbers on company enforcement and firefighting.

Mark

What were the numbers?

Mimi

Seventeen concessions revoked, 26 companies under investigation, 11 charged, 23 more slated for charges, and 104 under police investigation overall.

Luke

Those figures are Prabowo's own, as relayed by Kompas.com. The report doesn't independently verify them, and it doesn't explain how the 26 and the 104 relate.

Mark

And the human cost?

Mimi

He said 71,000 firefighters were deployed, 16 died, many were injured, and two helicopters were lost.

Luke

Again, that's his account. We don't know how the injured are counted, or the financial cost, which the report calls heavy without a figure.

Mark

What about the prevention plan?

Mimi

A new agency and new programmes, aimed at moving away from reliance on firefighting.

Luke

It's a stated intention. No timeline, budget or powers are given, so it's too early to say what it will change.

  • Fires have burned for nearly four months, and their smoke has crossed into Malaysia and Singapore, forcing an apology on the regional stage.
  • Sixteen firefighters have died, two helicopters have been lost, and 71,000 forest firefighters have been deployed in the struggle to contain the blaze.
  • Authorities have revoked 17 company concessions, charged 11 companies, and placed 104 under police investigation, with 23 more slated for charges.
  • Indonesia is moving to create a new agency and prevention programmes to shift away from reliance on firefighting, though its timing and details are still unclear.

On a Sunday in Manila, at the plenary of the 49th ASEAN Summit, Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto did something that neighbours rarely hear from a head of state: he said sorry. Before leaders including Malaysia's Anwar Ibrahim and Singapore's Lawrence Wong, he acknowledged that smoke from months of forest and land fires in Indonesia had drifted across borders and into the lives of people in two neighbouring countries. The apology arrives as a reckoning, with a tally of companies held to account and a turn toward prevention, though how far that turn will go remains to be seen.

On Sunday, November 15, at the plenary session of the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila, Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto turned to two of his neighbours and apologised. The haze from forest and land fires in Indonesia had drifted across the borders of Malaysia and Singapore, and he said so plainly, in front of Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, Prime Minister Lawrence Wong, and the Sultan of Brunei. The fires, he explained, have been burning for nearly four months, and his government's efforts, despite their scale, had not kept the smoke from reaching people's homes.

Much of his speech was a ledger of accountability. Indonesia, he said, would not tolerate corporations implicated in the blazes. Seventeen concessions have been revoked, eleven companies charged, and 104 placed under police investigation. The cost of the response has been severe: 71,000 forest firefighters deployed, sixteen dead, many more injured, and two helicopters lost.

Prabowo also argued that the country must change its approach. Rather than relying mainly on firefighting once blazes have started, Indonesia should invest in preventing them. A new agency and prevention programmes are being prepared to that end. The report does not say when the agency will be established. What to watch is whether the companies on the charging list are actually charged, and whether the prevention body takes shape before the next dry season.

On Sunday, Nov 15, at the plenary session of the 49th Asean Summit in Manila, Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto spoke directly to two of his neighbours. He apologised to Malaysia and Singapore for the haze drifting across their borders from forest and land fires in Indonesia. His remarks were reported by the Indonesian news portal Kompas.com.

The room was a full one. Malaysian Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was there, as were Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong and the Sultan of Brunei, Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah, along with leaders and representatives of other Asean member states.

Prabowo said his government was doing everything it could to bring the fires under control. By his account they have been burning for nearly four months. He acknowledged that, despite the scale of the effort, the smoke had crossed national boundaries and was affecting communities in both Malaysia and Singapore.

A large part of his intervention was a tally of enforcement action against the companies he holds responsible. Indonesia, he said, would not tolerate corporations implicated in the fires. He listed the figures: 17 company concessions revoked, 26 companies under investigation, 11 companies charged, and another 23 on the list to be charged. In total, he said, 104 companies are under investigation by Indonesian police.

He also described what the response has cost. Indonesia has deployed 71,000 forest firefighters. Sixteen people died, he said, and many more were injured while fighting the blazes. Two helicopters were also lost. The operations, as the report puts it, have come at a heavy human and financial price.

Prabowo then turned to what he called the need for a more systematic approach. Indonesia, he said, should put greater weight on preventing forest and land fires rather than relying mainly on firefighting and mitigation after they start. To that end, the government is preparing to set up a new agency and introduce programmes aimed at strengthening wildfire prevention.

The measures are expected to improve Indonesia's ability to stop future fires and to limit their effects on neighbouring countries. The details of the new agency, including when it will be established, were not given in the report. What to watch next is whether the prosecutions move from the list of companies to be charged into actual charges, and whether the prevention agency takes shape before the next dry season.

We have deployed 71,000 forest firefighters. We lost 16 people who died, and many more were injured while battling the fire. We also lost two helicopters.
— Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto
Contact Us FAQ