At the pilgrimage site of Lourdes, Pope Leo XIV placed two of the deepest wounds of contemporary Catholicism side by side: the question of how societies should accompany the dying, and the question of how an institution reckons with the harm it has caused its own faithful. Speaking before the sick and disabled who gather there in hope, he argued that legality and morality are not the same thing — a distinction that cuts in more than one direction. His presence in France was at once a proclamation of human dignity and an encounter with the long shadow of institutional failure.
Pope Leo XIV Condemns Assisted Dying as 'False Compassion' During Lourdes Visit
An independent 2021 report estimated 330,000 children were abused over 70 years by approximately 3,000 priests and church workers in France.
What is legal is not necessarily moral.
Mark
So the pope went to Lourdes to talk about assisted dying, but ended up having to reckon with the abuse crisis. How much of his visit was actually about each?
Mimi
The assisted dying message was the prepared one—that's what he came to say. But the abuse meetings and the Rupnik case were unavoidable. You can't visit a major Catholic shrine in France right now without confronting what happened.
Luke
The numbers matter here. 330,000 children abused over 70 years—that's from an independent 2021 report. The compensation system has paid out over 20 million euros. But we should note: the report's methodology was criticized, and we don't have a final total on what the church will ultimately pay.
Mark
Why did the pope only meet with seven survivors?
Mimi
The Vatican said it was to create an intimate setting where he could actually listen. But victims saw it as the church controlling the narrative—picking which survivors got heard.
Luke
That's fair, but we should be precise: the victims' advocates wanted him to meet with more people and to acknowledge institutional responsibility. The seven who did meet said he was sincere, though they disagreed on some points. That's what the reporting shows.
Mark
And Rupnik—the mosaic artist. His work is literally on the basilica.
Mimi
Right. So Leo is standing in a building decorated by someone accused of abusing more than two dozen women, whose case was hidden for thirty years. The victims wrote to him saying that silence itself was violence.
Luke
The trial is ongoing in Vatican court. Rupnik hasn't been convicted. But the cover-up by his Jesuit superiors is documented, and Francis did eventually order the trial after media pressure. That's the institutional pattern the victims are pointing to.
Mark
So what does Leo actually do with all this?
Mimi
That's the open question. He praised the bishops' compensation work and said the priesthood needs to be "welcomed, accepted, and loved" again. But he didn't resolve the fundamental conflict the victims named—that the church is both judge and defendant in its own abuse cases.
Luke
And on assisted dying, his message was clear: legal doesn't mean moral. But that's a statement of principle, not a policy proposal. France has already passed the law.
O Pulso
- Leo's condemnation of assisted dying as 'false compassion' landed in a country that had only recently passed end-of-life legislation, sharpening a direct collision between Catholic moral teaching and European democratic consensus.
- The pilgrimage setting — filled with the sick, the disabled, and the grieving — gave his words an immediate human weight, but also raised the stakes of every gesture he made toward abuse survivors.
- Only seven survivors were selected by the church itself to meet the pope, a fact that victims' advocates seized upon as evidence that the institution still controls the terms of its own accountability.
- An open letter published in Libération on the day of Leo's arrival demanded the church surrender its dual role as both spiritual authority over priests and judge of their crimes — a structural conflict the Vatican did not directly answer.
- The Marko Rupnik case — a Jesuit artist accused by more than two dozen women, whose mosaics decorate the very basilica Leo visited — made the institutional failures he was asked to address physically present in the stones around him.
- Survivors described the papal meeting as sincere but incomplete, with hope offered in words while the deeper question of systemic reform remained, in their telling, still unanswered.
At the pilgrimage site of Lourdes, Pope Leo XIV placed two of the deepest wounds of contemporary Catholicism side by side: the question of how societies should accompany the dying, and the question of how an institution reckons with the harm it has caused its own faithful. Speaking before the sick and disabled who gather there in hope, he argued that legality and morality are not the same thing — a distinction that cuts in more than one direction. His presence in France was at once a proclamation of human dignity and an encounter with the long shadow of institutional failure.
Pope Leo XIV traveled to Lourdes on Sunday carrying two of the heaviest burdens of modern Catholicism at once. At the famous pilgrimage shrine in southwestern France — a site where millions of sick and disabled faithful gather each year in search of healing — he delivered a pointed rejection of assisted dying laws, telling the crowd that what is legal is not necessarily moral. France had recently passed legislation allowing adults with terminal illness to receive lethal medication, and Leo made clear that Catholic teaching on the sanctity of life from conception to natural death would define his entire visit. Speaking directly to those in wheelchairs and on crutches, he told them their suffering was not an obstacle but a place of full dignity — dignity that no law or algorithm could erase.
Yet Lourdes also forced Leo to face a different kind of wound. He met privately with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse, a gathering that survivors' advocates immediately questioned: the group was small, and chosen by the church itself. An independent 2021 report had found that roughly 330,000 children were abused over seven decades by approximately 3,000 priests and church workers in France. The French bishops had since created a compensation system recommending payouts exceeding 20 million euros, and Leo praised their efforts — while also acknowledging that the priesthood had become an object of suspicion for many French Catholics, and that vocations had suffered as a result.
Survivors who attended described the encounter as careful and, in moments, hopeful. One said the pope had spoken of the need to 'reopen hope' and had responded positively to concrete proposals. But on the day Leo arrived in Paris, a group of survivors had published an open letter demanding the church relinquish its position as both judge and party in abuse proceedings — a structural conflict the Vatican did not resolve. The visit was further shadowed by the ongoing Vatican trial of Rev. Marko Rupnik, a Jesuit artist accused by more than two dozen women of decades of abuse, whose mosaics appear on one of the Lourdes basilicas. Five of his accusers wrote to Leo before the trip, praising the decision to cover the mosaics but condemning three decades of institutional silence as a continuous violence in itself. The pope arrived in Lourdes preaching dignity — and found the failures of his own institution woven into the walls around him.
Pope Leo XIV arrived in Lourdes on Sunday to confront two of the most fraught questions facing the modern Catholic Church: the right to die and the church's reckoning with decades of sexual abuse by its own clergy.
At the shrine in southwestern France, famous for pilgrims seeking miraculous cures, the pontiff delivered a direct rebuke of assisted dying laws that have spread across Europe and beyond. "It is precisely in the name of this inalienable dignity of the human person that we must reject the temptation to cause death under the guise of false compassion," he told a crowd that included many in wheelchairs and walkers. "What is legal is not necessarily moral." The distinction mattered. France itself had debated end-of-life legislation for years before recently passing laws that allow adults with incurable illnesses to receive lethal medication. Leo's visit marked his third day in the country, and he had already made clear that Catholic teaching on protecting life from conception to natural death would frame his entire time there.
Lourdes itself amplified the message. The pilgrimage site draws millions each year, many of them sick and disabled, drawn by the Catholic Church's official recognition of visions of the Virgin Mary reported by a young girl in 1858. The church has authenticated 72 miraculous cures at the location. In his homily, Leo spoke directly to those suffering: "Your crutches, your wheelchairs and your hidden tears are not obstacles; instead, they are the very place where you are fully respected and welcomed." He visited a care center for the sick on the shrine's grounds, emphasizing that those living in severe pain retain an inherent dignity that no law or algorithm could diminish.
But the visit also forced Leo to confront a different kind of institutional failure. On Sunday, he met with seven survivors of clergy sexual abuse—a small group that itself became a point of contention. An independent report in 2021 had estimated that 330,000 children were abused over seven decades by roughly 3,000 priests and church workers in France alone. The French bishops' conference had since established an independent compensation system that has recommended payouts exceeding 20 million euros, or $22.7 million. Leo praised this response during a morning meeting with the bishops and urged them to continue, yet he also acknowledged a harder truth: the priesthood itself had become suspect in the eyes of many French Catholics, and vocations had cratered partly because of the scandal.
The survivors who met with Leo described the encounter as sincere, though complicated. Jérôme Guillement told a local French television station that the pope had chosen his words carefully and that they had discussed abuse prevention at multiple institutional levels. "There are different opinions, but from his point of view, there is a systemic dimension that still exists," Guillement said. Olivier Mardi, another survivor, reported that Leo had responded positively to concrete proposals and had spoken of the need to "reopen hope." Yet the very fact that only seven survivors were selected to meet the pope—chosen by the church itself—drew criticism from victims' advocates. On the day Leo arrived in Paris, a group of abuse survivors had published an open letter in the newspaper Libération calling on him to acknowledge the church's institutional responsibility and to end what they saw as a fundamental conflict of interest: bishops serving simultaneously as spiritual fathers to priests and as judges when those priests committed abuse. "The Church must relinquish its position as both judge and party to the proceedings," they wrote. The Vatican's spokesperson, Monsignor Pierre-Antoine Bozo, defended the small group size as necessary for genuine listening, but the tension remained unresolved.
The visit also brought into sharp focus a case Leo had inherited from his predecessor. One of the Lourdes basilicas features a façade designed by Rev. Marko Rupnik, a Jesuit mosaic artist currently on trial in a Vatican court. More than two dozen women have accused Rupnik of psychological, spiritual, and sexual abuse dating to the 1990s, including during the creation of his artworks. His superiors in the Jesuit order had covered up the allegations for three decades, and Pope Francis himself had been suspected of protecting his fellow Jesuit until media pressure forced a canonical trial in 2024, which remains ongoing. In a letter to Leo before his trip, five women who said they were abused by Rupnik praised the decision to cover the mosaics but condemned the Vatican's handling of their case and the three decades of silence. "This prolonged and loud silence has been experienced by us, the victims, as a further, continuous violence," they wrote. Leo's presence in Lourdes, then, was shadowed by the very institutional failures he was being asked to address—a church that had long protected its own at the expense of those it had harmed.
Citações Notáveis
Your crutches, your wheelchairs and your hidden tears are not obstacles; instead, they are the very place where you are fully respected and welcomed.— Pope Leo XIV, in his homily at Lourdes
This prolonged and loud silence has been experienced by us, the victims, as a further, continuous violence.— Five women who said they were abused by Rev. Marko Rupnik, in a letter to the pope
Quer a matéria completa?
Leia o original em CBS News ↗