In the final weeks of a pandemic year, a quiet arithmetic of loss is unfolding across American and European households: the number of people asking for jobless aid has jumped to its highest level since September, as renewed shutdowns and wary shoppers pull the economy back toward the edge it crossed in the spring. Behind the figures stand individual lives, such as a New Orleans cook who has lost his car, his footing and his place in a job market that has few doors left open. Governments and central banks are responding with bond purchases and a pending aid package, yet the outcome rests on a l
Pandemic Tightens Its Grip on US and European Economies as Jobless Claims Surge
"I have a really bad hand."
Why does a weekly claims number of 853,000 matter so much?
It's the highest since September and well above the roughly 225,000 typical before March. It also came in larger than most economists expected.
So is this the start of a new downturn?
That's not established. The report says part of the jump may be a rebound from the low Thanksgiving week. One week doesn't make a trend.
True, but the continuing claims rose too, from 5.5 million to 5.8 million, the first rise in three months. That's why economists are uneasy.
Careful with Konkel's point, though. She said December could show a net job loss. That's her projection, not a result.
What does Montrell McGraw's situation show?
What losing the $600 weekly supplement meant. On $222 a week he cancelled car insurance and is behind on rent.
He's one person, so he illustrates the problem rather than measures it. The measured figure is the 9 million-plus who would lose benefits on Dec. 26.
And the ECB and Fed?
They're pushing down long-term rates through bond-buying. The Fed may offer guidance next week, but most analysts think it will hold back bigger changes.
And whether the $908 billion proposal passes is still unknown.
El Pulso
- Weekly jobless claims surged to 853,000, a sharp jolt after weeks of hope that the labour market was steadying.
- More than 9 million workers face losing unemployment benefits on December 26 unless Congress acts before the deadline.
- Consumer spending has faltered, with card spending down nearly 12% from a year earlier, and holiday sales trailing prior years.
- Central banks are moving to cushion the blow, with the ECB expanding bond purchases and the Federal Reserve preparing guidance that could reassure markets.
- A bipartisan $908 billion proposal offers a path forward, but the clock is running and the labour market is still in crisis.
In the final weeks of a pandemic year, a quiet arithmetic of loss is unfolding across American and European households: the number of people asking for jobless aid has jumped to its highest level since September, as renewed shutdowns and wary shoppers pull the economy back toward the edge it crossed in the spring. Behind the figures stand individual lives, such as a New Orleans cook who has lost his car, his footing and his place in a job market that has few doors left open. Governments and central banks are responding with bond purchases and a pending aid package, yet the outcome rests on a legislative deadline that will decide whether millions keep a thin safety net through the winter.
On Thursday, the U.S. government reported that 853,000 Americans applied for unemployment benefits in a single week, up sharply from the week before and the highest since September. Before the coronavirus shut the economy in March, the typical weekly figure hovered near 225,000. The rise reflects companies still cutting staff as states reimpose business restrictions and consumers hold back from shopping, travel and dining out.
Montrell McGraw, 26, of New Orleans, knows this reality well. He lost his cook's job at a Hilton hotel in March, has applied for 35 positions without success, and receives $222 a week in benefits. He has cancelled his car insurance, which means he can no longer drive to interviews, and he has fallen behind on rent. The extra $600 a week from federal aid, which covered his bills, ended in July. "I didn't ask for this," he said, hoping an extension will let him get his car insurance back.
His story echoes across the data. State aid claims rose for the first time in three months, and economists warn the December jobs report could show the first net job loss since April. Card spending has dropped sharply, and restaurants, bars and retailers have cut jobs. Increases appeared in California, Illinois, New York, Georgia and Texas alike.
In Europe, the European Central Bank expanded its bond-buying to keep borrowing affordable, even as Germany recorded its deadliest single day and France closed restaurants, gyms and museums. The Federal Reserve meets next week and may clarify how long its own purchases will last.
The decisive test now lies with Congress. Nearly half of the 19 million people relying on some unemployment support could lose it on December 26. A bipartisan $908 billion proposal would extend the programs for four months, and many economists believe a vaccine-driven recovery is coming next year, but they agree that relief is needed urgently to bridge the gap.
On Thursday, the U.S. government reported that 853,000 Americans applied for unemployment benefits last week, up from 716,000 the week before and the most since September. Before the coronavirus shut down the economy in March, weekly claims typically ran around 225,000. The jump showed that many companies are still cutting workers as states reimpose business shutdowns and consumers stay away from shopping, travel and restaurants.
One of those people is Montrell McGraw, 26, of New Orleans. He lost his job as a cook at a Hilton hotel in March, just after the virus arrived in the United States. He has applied for 35 jobs without success. His experience is in restaurants, few of which are hiring, and most openings he sees are in trucking or offshore oil rigs, which require certifications he cannot afford. His unemployment benefit is $222 a week. He has just cancelled his car insurance, so he can no longer drive, which will make job hunting harder, and he is behind on rent. He covered his bills when the federal government added $600 a week in jobless aid, but that program ended in July. He has also worked with the advocacy group Step Up Louisiana to press for an extension of benefits. "I didn't ask for this," he said, adding that he is playing a bad hand. If Congress extends aid, he said, "maybe then I can get my car insurance back."
The broader data point the same way. The number of people receiving state unemployment aid rose for the first time in three months, from 5.5 million to 5.8 million, a sign some employers have pulled back on hiring. AnnElizabeth Konkel, an economist at the job site Indeed, said this suggests the December jobs report, due in early January, could show a net loss of jobs for the first time since April. She called Thursday's report the first overt signal of a backward slide and said the labour market is still in crisis. Gus Faucher of PNC Financial said the virus is affecting consumers, the labour force and businesses, and that there are reasons for concern.
Consumer spending is soft. Opportunity Insights, a research centre affiliated with Harvard and Brown, found debit and credit card spending fell nearly 12% in the week ending Nov. 29 compared with a year earlier, after a drop of just 2.3% the week before. Card data show holiday spending trailing prior years. In November, U.S. employers added jobs at the slowest pace since April, and restaurants, bars and retailers all cut jobs.
The claims increase was widespread. New applications rose by more than 47,000 in California, 31,000 in Illinois, 17,000 in New York and 13,000 in Georgia. Texas, which has generally not imposed stricter business rules, saw claims climb by nearly 20,000 to 45,000. Part of the rise may be a rebound after Thanksgiving week, when applications had fallen, but the increase was far larger than most economists expected.
In Europe, the European Central Bank announced it will expand its bond-buying program to hold down long-term interest rates and encourage borrowing and spending. The decision came on the day Germany, Europe's largest economy, recorded its highest single-day virus death toll, and as France shut restaurants, bars, gyms, movie theatres and museums.
The U.S. Federal Reserve meets next week. It may give more detailed guidance on how long its own bond-buying will continue, which could reassure markets, and it could shift purchases toward longer-term bonds, though most analysts expect it to hold that step in reserve.
The larger deadline falls on Congress. More than 19 million people depend on some form of unemployment benefit, and nearly half could lose it in just over two weeks, on Dec. 26, when two federal programs expire. One covers the self-employed and contract workers; the other extends aid for 13 weeks. A bipartisan group of senators has proposed a $908 billion package that would extend both for four months; without it, more than 9 million people would lose benefits. Many economists expect a strong rebound next year as a vaccine nears approval, but most say another relief package is urgently needed to carry workers, small businesses and state and local governments until then.
Citas Notables
Today's report is the first overt signal of a backward slide. It's evident the labour market is still in crisis.— AnnElizabeth Konkel, economist at Indeed
I didn't ask for this — no one asked for this pandemic.— Montrell McGraw, laid-off cook in New Orleans