Padres Force Game 4 With Dramatic 4-3 NLDS Win Over Brewers

The season was still alive.
After avoiding elimination with a 4-3 win, San Diego forced a Game 4 with Milwaukee's series lead cut to 2-1.
Mark

So the Padres were facing elimination and they won 4-3. That's the headline. But what actually changed between Game 2 and Game 3?

Mimi

The biggest thing was Mason Miller wasn't available. He'd thrown 40 pitches closing out Game 2, and then he went on the paternity list. That removed Milwaukee's best closer from the equation.

Luke

But hold on—Miller was already in question for availability even before the paternity list. The source says his availability was "already in question." So we don't know if he would have pitched anyway.

Mimi

Fair point. But what we do know is that San Diego got a matchup advantage with Pivetta against May, and they actually capitalized on it early. Pivetta was sharp, and the offense finally broke through in the third inning.

Mark

Manny Machado had been struggling the first two games. What changed?

Mimi

He just came through with a single that drove in a run in the third. Sometimes in baseball it's that simple—the moment finds you and you deliver.

Luke

But one hit doesn't erase two games of struggle. We're talking about one at-bat in one inning. The narrative of "finally coming through" is real, but it's one moment.

Mark

What about Cronenworth's home run? That seemed to be the turning point.

Mimi

It was huge. After Milwaukee tied it 2-2 in the fifth, Cronenworth went deep to right field to put San Diego back up 3-2. That's the kind of swing that changes momentum in a playoff game.

Mark

And then Michael King closed it out?

Mimi

He pitched two innings and stranded the tying run in the ninth. That's the kind of performance you need when your season is on the line.

Luke

The source says he "stranded" the tying run, which means there was a runner in scoring position with a chance to tie. We don't know exactly how close it was or what the situation looked like. But yes, he got the job done.

  • Facing elimination after dropping the first two games on the road, the Padres entered Game 3 with their entire season compressed into a single night at Petco Park.
  • Milwaukee struck back each time San Diego pulled ahead, with William Contreras launching a towering homer and Jackson Chourio's sacrifice fly knotting the game at 2-2 and threatening to extinguish the home crowd's hope.
  • Jake Cronenworth answered Milwaukee's equalizer with a solo shot to right field in the fifth, and a Brewers throwing error in the sixth gave San Diego the two-run cushion they desperately needed.
  • Michael King, pitching in relief across the final two innings, stranded the tying run in the ninth to preserve the 4-3 victory and force a Game 4 the Padres had no guarantee of ever reaching.
  • The series now returns to Petco Park with Milwaukee still holding the advantage at 2-1, but San Diego has reclaimed both momentum and the right to keep playing.

In the compressed theater of October baseball, the San Diego Padres refused the quiet exit that elimination demands, defeating the Milwaukee Brewers 4-3 in a Game 3 that reminded observers why playoff sport endures as a human ritual. Facing a sweep at their own Petco Park, the Padres found contributions from unexpected corners — a timely homer, a clutch reliever, an opponent's error — the small accumulations that separate survival from surrender. The series, now 2-1 in Milwaukee's favor, moves forward with San Diego's season still breathing, proof that in sport as in life, the story rarely ends where we expect it to.

The San Diego Padres arrived at Game 3 of the NLDS having already lost twice in Milwaukee, one defeat away from an early exit. The series had already offered its share of heartbreak — a Ty France homer in Game 1 thwarted by a roof support structure, and a Mason Miller masterpiece in Game 2 that ended on a walk-off single despite three consecutive walks loading the bases. Now, with Miller sidelined on the paternity list, San Diego had reason for cautious optimism.

Nick Pivetta and Dustin May matched up on the mound, and the Padres struck first in the third inning. Samad Taylor reached and stole second, Cronenworth bunted him over, and Fernando Tatis Jr. drove in the opening run. Jackson Merrill singled and stole second himself, then scored on a Manny Machado single — Machado, who had been quiet through the first two games, finally delivering in a moment that mattered. San Diego led 2-0.

Milwaukee refused to fold. Contreras hit a majestic homer in the fourth to cut the deficit, and the Brewers tied it in the fifth on Chourio's sacrifice fly. But Cronenworth answered almost immediately, launching a solo shot to right field that put San Diego back in front at 3-2 and sent Petco Park into full roar. A throwing error by Cooper Pratt in the sixth pushed the lead to 4-2, giving the Padres the margin they needed.

Milwaukee pulled within one in the eighth, but Michael King — a starter adapting to a reliever's role — shut the door across the final two innings, stranding the tying run in the ninth to preserve the 4-3 victory. The sweep was avoided. The season continued. With Game 4 now set at Petco Park, San Diego had earned the right to make Milwaukee earn it one more time.

The San Diego Padres were one loss away from elimination when they took the field at Petco Park on Tuesday night. The Milwaukee Brewers had already won the first two games of their National League Division Series matchup, and a third consecutive defeat would send the Padres home for the season. What unfolded instead was a taut, back-and-forth affair that kept both teams trading blows until the final inning—the kind of playoff baseball that justifies the entire enterprise.

The series had already produced its share of drama. In Game 1, William Contreras hit a go-ahead homer in the seventh inning to put Milwaukee ahead, while San Diego's Ty France nearly answered with one of his own in the ninth, only to have his bid thwarted by the roof support structure at American Family Field. The Brewers won that game 3-2. Game 2 belonged entirely to Milwaukee's closer Mason Miller, who despite being pushed to 40 pitches, struck out the side in the ninth after three walks had loaded the bases. Jackson Chourio then lined a single to center field for a walk-off victory, giving Milwaukee a commanding 2-0 series lead heading to San Diego. Miller's availability for Game 3 became moot when he was placed on the paternity list and ruled out entirely.

Nick Pivetta took the mound for San Diego against Dustin May, and early on the matchup played out as expected. Jackson Merrill made a spectacular catch in the first inning to rob Chourio of extra bases, and Pivetta worked through the early innings cleanly. May, however, unraveled in the third. Samad Taylor singled and stole second, then Jake Cronenworth bunted him to third. Fernando Tatis Jr. drove in the first run with a grounder, and Merrill followed with a single to center. After stealing second himself, Merrill scored on a Manny Machado single—Machado, who had struggled through the first two games, finally delivering when it mattered most. The Padres led 2-0.

Milwaukee answered immediately. Contreras, coming off a down year by his standards, launched a mammoth homer to left field off Pivetta in the fourth inning, taking his time admiring the shot as he rounded the bases. That cut San Diego's lead to 2-1. When the Padres worked a leadoff walk in the bottom of the fourth, Brewers manager Pat Murphy removed May from the game, turning to his bullpen. Milwaukee tied it in the fifth when Cooper Pratt and Sal Frelick singled back-to-back, setting up Chourio's sacrifice fly to center that made it 2-2.

But Cronenworth refused to let the momentum shift. In the bottom of the fifth, he launched a solo shot to right field off Antonio Senzatela, restoring San Diego's lead at 3-2 and sending Petco Park into a frenzy. The Padres added insurance in the sixth when Xander Bogaerts scored on a throwing error by Cooper Pratt, pushing the lead to 4-2. Milwaukee scratched across one more run in the eighth off Bradgley Rodríguez to cut it to 4-3, but that's where it ended. Michael King, a starter-turned-reliever, took over in the eighth and pitched two gritty innings, stranding the tying run in the ninth to secure the 4-3 victory.

With the win, San Diego avoided the sweep and cut Milwaukee's series lead to 2-1. Game 4 would be played at Petco Park, giving the Padres a chance to force a decisive fifth game. The series had delivered exactly what playoff baseball promises: elite pitching, powerful bullpens, and stars delivering in moments when everything hangs in the balance. For Milwaukee, the lead had narrowed. For San Diego, the season was still alive.

William Contreras launched a mammoth homer to left field, taking his time admiring the shot as he rounded the bases
— Game 3 action
Quieres la nota completa? Lee el original en Fox News ↗
Contáctanos FAQ