In the early hours of an August morning in Upper Pottsgrove, Pennsylvania, a 22-year-old college student knocked on the wrong door after a night out with friends — a small, ordinary mistake that ended in his death. A police corporal, responding to a reported break-in, shot the unarmed young man twice from nearly twenty feet away, despite body camera footage showing compliance rather than aggression. Now charged with voluntary manslaughter, the officer's case moves toward the courts, while a family buries a son who was supposed to start university that same week. The incident asks, once again,
Pa. officer charged with voluntary manslaughter in fatal shooting of college student at wrong home
Glenwood Earl Pysher IV, a 22-year-old college student, was fatally shot by police while unarmed and complying with commands at a wrong residence.
A young man with no weapon, no aggression, no threat to anyone present
Mark
So the officer claims the student charged him, but the body camera shows something else entirely?
Mimi
That's what the prosecutor says. The video shows Pysher with his hands up, walking toward Farrell, complying with commands. No aggression, no weapon.
Luke
But we're relying on the prosecutor's interpretation of the video, right? We haven't seen it ourselves.
Mimi
True. But the criminal complaint itself documents what's on the footage—hands up, no weapon, distance of 17 to 20 feet.
Mark
And Farrell had other options available to him?
Mimi
He had a taser and a baton. He went straight to his gun.
Luke
The question is whether a jury will see it the same way the prosecutor does. Voluntary manslaughter is a serious charge, but it requires proving he acted recklessly or with extreme disregard.
Mark
What about the fact that Pysher was drunk?
Mimi
The prosecutor acknowledged he was inebriated, but said that doesn't change the analysis. He was still listening to commands, still complying.
Luke
The preliminary hearing on September 10th will be the first real test of whether the evidence holds up under scrutiny.
Mark
And the family—what are they hoping for?
Mimi
Justice, according to their attorney. They want answers about why a wrong address became a death sentence.
Luke
That's the human question. The legal question is whether the evidence supports the charge.
Der Puls
- A confused, intoxicated college student sent his friends his location so they could find him — he never imagined he would need to be found by a coroner instead.
- Body camera footage directly contradicts the officer's account that Pysher charged him screaming; prosecutors say the video shows a young man with his hands raised, doing what he was told.
- Despite having a taser and a baton at his disposal, Corporal Farrell drew his pistol and fired twice before finishing his own warning — with the unarmed student still seventeen to twenty feet away.
- Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele called the shooting flatly unjustifiable, marking a rare moment when law enforcement leadership publicly turned toward accountability rather than away from it.
- Farrell has been charged with voluntary manslaughter, turned himself in, and faces a preliminary hearing September 10th — while Pysher's family, who buried him Monday, prepares to see the case through.
In the early hours of an August morning in Upper Pottsgrove, Pennsylvania, a 22-year-old college student knocked on the wrong door after a night out with friends — a small, ordinary mistake that ended in his death. A police corporal, responding to a reported break-in, shot the unarmed young man twice from nearly twenty feet away, despite body camera footage showing compliance rather than aggression. Now charged with voluntary manslaughter, the officer's case moves toward the courts, while a family buries a son who was supposed to start university that same week. The incident asks, once again, what restraint we owe one another in moments of fear — and who bears the cost when that restraint fails.
On the morning of August 23rd, 22-year-old Glenwood Earl Pysher IV left a bar with friends and walked to what he believed was a friend's house. He knocked on the wrong door. The alarmed homeowners called police to report a break-in. Pysher, realizing his mistake, texted his friends a photo of the house and his location so they could come get him. He was waiting on the back patio when Upper Pottsgrove Police Corporal Sean Farrell arrived.
What followed, according to Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele, was a killing with no legal justification. Body camera footage shows Pysher raising his hands when ordered and walking slowly toward the officer — unarmed, intoxicated, but compliant. Farrell issued commands twice more, shouted a warning that he would shoot, and then fired twice before the sentence was finished. Pysher was between seventeen and twenty feet away. Farrell had a taser and a baton available. He chose his pistol.
Farrell later told a fellow officer that Pysher had charged him while screaming and refusing commands. Prosecutors who reviewed the footage saw something different. The criminal complaint alleged that Farrell used deadly force unreasonably, with no consideration of less lethal options. On September 2nd, he was charged with voluntary manslaughter, turned himself in to Montgomery County detectives, and was arraigned with bail set at $75,000.
Pysher's parents learned their son would never begin classes at Saint Elizabeth University in New Jersey, where he had been enrolled to start that very week. They buried him on Monday. His family's attorney described the night plainly: a wrong address, a confused young man, and a death that should never have happened. A preliminary hearing is set for September 10th.
On the early morning of August 23rd, a 22-year-old college student named Glenwood Earl Pysher IV made a mistake that would cost him his life. After spending time at a bar with friends, he decided to walk to what he thought was a friend's house. He knocked on the wrong door. The homeowners, alarmed by the unexpected visitor, called the police to report a break-in. Pysher, realizing his error, sent his friends a picture of the house and then his location so they could come retrieve him. He was waiting on the back patio when Upper Pottsgrove Police Corporal Sean Farrell arrived.
What happened next, according to Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele, was a shooting that had no legal justification. Farrell found Pysher unarmed on the patio. Body camera footage shows that when Farrell gave commands to put his hands up and drop to the ground, Pysher complied. He raised his hands and began walking toward the officer. Farrell repeated his orders twice more, then shouted a warning that he would shoot—but fired twice before finishing the sentence. Pysher was between 17 and 20 feet away, and Farrell had access to both a taser and a baton but chose his pistol instead.
The distance and positioning mattered. According to the criminal complaint, Farrell was behind cover when Pysher approached with his hands already raised. Steele emphasized what the body camera actually showed: a young man with no weapon, no aggression, no threat to anyone present. Pysher was intoxicated but listening to commands. He was not trying to escape. He had committed no violent crime. "This is not a legal use of lethal force," Steele said.
Farrell later told another officer that Pysher had charged him while screaming and refusing to get down. But when prosecutors reviewed the video themselves, they saw something different. The complaint alleged that Farrell had used deadly force unreasonably and without any consideration of less lethal alternatives. On Tuesday, September 2nd, Farrell was charged with voluntary manslaughter. He turned himself in to Montgomery County detectives and was arraigned that evening with bail set at $75,000.
Pysher's parents learned that their son would never start classes at Saint Elizabeth University in New Jersey, where he had been enrolled to begin this week. They buried him on Monday. Ken Fulginiti, the attorney representing the family, described the arc of that night in stark terms: what should have been nothing—a wrong address, a confused college student—became the death of a 22-year-old son, brother, and grandson. The family is determined to see the case through. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for September 10th.
Bemerkenswerte Zitate
This is not a legal use of lethal force.— Montgomery County District Attorney Kevin Steele
What seems like a totally innocuous, pedestrian nothing somehow resulted in the murder of a 22-year-old son, brother, grandson.— Ken Fulginiti, attorney for the Pysher family
Möchten Sie die ganze Geschichte?
Das Original lesen bei CBS News ↗
Crime & Justice