Oil Slides as Surplus Fears Return, Even as Hormuz Shipping and Freight Costs Stay Elevated

Traders are contemplating excess supply rather than persistent tightness
Analyst Tim Waterer on the shift in oil market sentiment as Hormuz shipments recover.

Oil markets, long gripped by the fear of scarcity that a months-long war around Iran brought with it, have begun to turn their attention toward the opposite worry: too much crude. The Strait of Hormuz, a narrow passage that carries a large share of the world's energy, has regained nearly its pre-war traffic, and the International Energy Agency now expects supply to outrun demand in the final quarter of the year. Yet the sea itself remains dangerous, and the cost of moving oil across it has not fallen with the price of the barrel. The story is one of relief arriving unevenly, where the easing of one burden leaves another still in place.

On Monday morning, WTI crude was trading at $88.35 a barrel and Brent at $95.40. The changes were small, but the mood behind them had shifted. For months the market had worried about too little oil. Now it was beginning to worry about too much.

The turn was driven by the Strait of Hormuz, where shipments have recovered to nearly pre-war levels after long disruption. The wider conflict between the US, Israel and Iran is now in its ninth month. As signs of lower geopolitical risk spread, WTI fell 16% and Brent 13% over the previous week.

The International Energy Agency reinforced the change. It now expects a fourth-quarter surplus of 1.7 million barrels a day, reversing its earlier forecast of a deficit, as Middle East exports recover faster than demand grows. Reserves released in March will also supply 71 million barrels by the end of February, including 15 million barrels of diesel.

Washington added to the flow by extending the suspension of Jones Act restrictions for 90 days, allowing foreign-flagged ships to carry fuel between US ports. Analysts say traders are now openly discussing excess supply for the first time since the conflict began.

Lower crude has not brought cheaper shipping. Freight rates remain high, since tankers face real danger in Hormuz and many vessels are tied up in transfers. That danger returned Sunday, when Iranian state media reported that a tanker caught fire after hitting a naval mine east of the strait, with no further details given. The open question now is whether freight costs ease as traffic normalizes, or whether incidents like this keep them high even as supply loosens.

On Monday morning, WTI crude futures were trading at $88.35 a barrel, down 21 cents or 0.24%, while Brent stood at $95.40, lower by 44 cents or 0.46%. The moves were small. The reason behind them was not: for the first time in months, the market was talking about too much oil rather than too little.

The immediate cause is the Strait of Hormuz. Shipments through the waterway have recovered to nearly pre-war levels after months of disruption, according to the report. The war itself, the US-Israeli campaign against Iran, is now in its ninth month. Signs of reduced geopolitical risk had already pushed both benchmarks sharply lower: WTI shed 16% and Brent 13% over the previous week, and oil settled lower on Friday.

The International Energy Agency added weight to that shift on Friday. It said the global oil market is expected to move into surplus in the fourth quarter of this year, reversing its earlier forecast of a deficit. Average supply for the quarter could reach 105 million barrels per day, exceeding projected demand by 1.7 million barrels per day. The agency expects the recovery in Middle East exports to outpace growth in global demand, even though attacks on shipping continue.

The IEA also addressed the emergency stockpiles. Of the record release of reserves its members pledged in March, 71 million barrels will be made available by the end of February. That includes 15 million barrels of diesel, intended to ease tightness in that part of the market.

Washington has added to the supply picture. President Donald Trump extended the suspension of Jones Act restrictions for another 90 days, a White House official said on Friday. The law normally requires cargo moved between US ports to travel on US-flagged vessels. With it suspended, foreign-flagged ships can carry oil and fuels, including petrol and diesel, between domestic ports, which widens the pool of available tankers.

Tim Waterer, chief analyst at KCM Trade, described the change in mood. For the first time since the US-Iran conflict began, he said, traders are actively contemplating excess supply rather than persistent tightness, and that shift in narrative is clearly dampening the tone of the market.

Cheaper crude does not mean cheaper shipping, though. Waterer said elevated freight rates continue to support oil prices. Tankers face real risk passing through Hormuz, and vessel availability has suffered because ships are tied up moving oil through the waterway, where cargoes are transferred to other vessels for onward delivery to refineries.

That risk was on display again Sunday night. Iran's navy said, according to state media, that an oil tanker caught fire after hitting a naval mine east of the Strait of Hormuz. The report comes from Iranian state media and the source offers no further detail on the vessel or its cargo.

What to watch now is whether freight rates ease as traffic normalizes, and whether incidents like the reported mine strike keep tanker costs high even as the supply outlook loosens.

For the first time since the US-Iran conflict began, traders are actively contemplating excess supply rather than persistent tightness, and that shift is dampening the tone.
— Tim Waterer, chief analyst, KCM Trade
Contattaci Domande frequenti